go David Cook..
i guess last night wasnt that memorable. i already forgot their performances

Thank God she's out. KLC was in the audience - freakin' hot.

Why is Jason Castro still in? He had 2 bad performances and he just seems disinterested.

He'll be next. Syesha has been improving, hate to say it.

IMO, Jason Castro's performance has been falling flat. Like Simon says his performance were not outstanding, unique and just plain blah-another-meh-song. I hate those stupid voters who votes him just for his looks and not his singing which is what American Idol is. See what happened to Melinda Doolitle in the last season. How the heck did she not make the Idol? She was incomparable to Blake and Jordin.

Top 5 performance available HERE.

yup, i think he's next.Brooke should been booted out last week, but her time is finally up

My opinion is syesha is still in there because she is the only black girl.However, i have to admit she is improving every week

This post has been edited by nikyas: May 1 2008, 09:16 PM

Blah shes out...so who will win this thing

It's either David Cook or David Archuleta will win, it still depends on the performance, cause in final, the song wrote for winner is always ballad, which in David A comfort zone, he might perform better than Cook.

thanks gawd she is finally out and yeah KLC audience cameo is awesome

do u guys know that there are 2 version of Carly's come together song?
One is with original pitching, and the other is where they change it to a higher pitch

original pitch:
http://youtube.com/watch?v=PXs81MWZUqo

modified pitch:
http://youtube.com/watch?v=d47dve_E6dA

i was wondering why the need of the 2nd version?

This post has been edited by nikyas: May 2 2008, 04:49 PM

I hope David Cook wins!!!!! David A. is just way too overrated...

Cant understand why Jason Castro still on the list. He should be kicked long agoo.. But he has too many schoolgirls and college student voters who prioritize pretty face rather than true musical talent.

Mind u it is afterall American IDOL..ofcuz they will vote for those they IDOLIZED..so pretty face and good boy/girl attitude is a must..If not Bo Bice might have won last time..

well for the most part that may be true, but season 5 is the exception.
daughtry best singer was out as 4th.
katherine mcphee the ultra hottie was 2nd and didnt even win.
dont even remember the winners name anymore tho

to me syesha deserves to be in the final two.
archuletta is too damn boring. why doesnt simon critisize him for being too old fashion?

i think it'll be bias definitely. syesha would most probably be out this week

top 4 episode just aired in the US

David A is finally back. You can call me a sap but I thought his rendition of Love Me Tender was amazing.
And I'm rooting for Syesha as well (hope American makes the right decision this time ard)..she's improved leaps and bounds

YOU ARE A SAP!

is david A really that good?? just watched the performances and i didnt feel that he crushed the competition like simon said...