I think Cook deserves the title, but I would love to see Castro win if just for the reaction...

Oh God, Jason Castro was abysmal beyond words. Vote him out America.

I think vocally Jason Castro is the WEAKEST among the top 12 and should have been out long long time ago! Instead Carly should have been among the TOP 4!!!

Anyway, David A totally rocked the house, and surprisingly David C was abit disappointing this week. His magic just couldnt work this week. And Syesha did a really good job, I hope the vulnerable side she showed this week will keep her in top 3.

And Jason's probably packing his bags now

This post has been edited by darren84: May 7 2008, 11:54 PM

well this is the first and only time so far i found david a song to be atleast likable. im so used to elvis's singing that i thought david a was gonna overkill it etc etc, but he did just enough and not overdid it to keep it good.

however i think the best performance and singing actually went to syesha for the first song... take note i just watched it in the midnight rerun and she woke me up.

i nearly fell asleep during castro's song both times, ive criticized him enuff so no need any more since almost certain hes out tomorrow.

cook didnt deliver up to expectations for me this time. i guess he was feelin the pressure too much since hes the 'rocker' in this season.

although as always im rootin for david cook, its gonna be a tough top 3 next week.

The result is out!! Say goodbye to.........

I would bet my money on him getting the boot. He screwed up on his first song, and then again on the second. And then he still had the guts to have that smirk on his face. Just before leaving the stage at the end of the show yesterday, he frantically waved at the audience, as if he already knew his fate.


Now it gets predictable.

Next is Syesha, gone next week.

Then it will be the battle of the Davids. David A will win. David C will 'almost' be a victory.

They both can release their albums. End of story.

i think David A is overrated.

he was even lazy to sing his exit song...

well next week should be good

thks gawd finally although i believe carly should have been in top 4 or even potential top 3 instead of brooke and jason should have gotten the big boot out way earlier than now wah this week episode camera pans a lot on carly cameo appearance behind the judge table

Well, the crap guys are edging closer and closer to the title. William Hung didnt make it through the auditions, Sanjaya got further and Jason nearly made the Top 3! Good progress. Muahahahahha

Though to be fair Jason can actually sing darn well.....















...when he wants to.

This post has been edited by BurgaFlippinMan: May 8 2008, 09:19 PM

haha yeah that is why his vote failed 2 support him but no doubt he will be regarded the legend of crappy singer 2 progress the furthest

I won't say he is a crappy singer. More like a crappy competitor. It always seems to me he entered just for fun, got further than he expected to, then kept on producing nonchalant performances (with an odd brilliant one here and there) to see how far he could go out of curiosity. He never seemed that he wanted to win it.

maybe he knows he cant win compared to some of the others...
but yeah.. surprised himself to see how far he could go

Which means the judges will have to think twice before letting anyone through. Though to be fair to them, this season's genre week has been either rubbish or incredibly difficult for the contestants.

---

Added on May 8, 2008, 11:07 pmHe's taken too much of that Paula juice

This post has been edited by kobe8byrant: May 8 2008, 11:07 PM

I badly want to see a rubbish singer win this damn thing...and watch the reaction to the credibility collapse!

yes! Finally! Better late than never

oh c'mon, castro aint that bad, probably having wrong choices for song, i would always remember him for this:

simply brillaint

nah i rather see AI come out the new rule of void vote where the judges can decide 2 canceled the total vote any time and kick out the ones with high vote that doesnt deserve 2 go through based on the performances

This post has been edited by skylinegtr34rule4life: May 9 2008, 11:42 AM

It seems like DA still got chance to win.

i couldn't agree more