ok...

Imagine China economy crash because they dunno how to communicate using the right words

Japan would nor exist without Chinese character and word too...

Japan already existed even before they borrow Chinese writing. It is Chinese people who cannot survive now if they don't use Japanese words.

I mean, you are opening your whatever threads to get attention what. Why so upset when you got what you deserved?

I'm not really motivated to waste time reporting your nonsense. You provide free post counts for me

i really should ignore you... but...

read back your own statement... "Just stop using Japanese words and see how you survive."

Malaysia definitely don't use japanese, and pretty sure our economy didn't crash.

again, would you like to change your statement or at least try to realize how silly your behavior is?

Why do people like you only want to see people fail? You hate people for a living? What life are you living?

Then why not stop using Japanese words when you are speaking in Chinese and see how?

Calm the tits down, those western oso derived and borrowed with each other so does the eastern like Chinese, jap or Korean which shared amongst themselves.

Even malay, Indo language all oso campur aduk and even derived from sanskrit english etc too.

Oh yes I do hate people. More especially so when people behave so nonsensically.

I'm such a Japanophile yet I don't go to such length making bogus claims

ok lar... my last reply to you... you are weird...

read back what you wrote. "Just stop using Japanese words and see how you survive."

also, while you are at it and using your convoluted reasoning, why not ask if Japan's economy will fall if skip all chinese words?

now I see what u mean by TS being autistic....

Sounds like jealousy to me.

Simple, because they are Japanese words, not Chinese words. Japan can still rely on their hiragana/katakana, but if China drops all the Japanese words, they don't have their own words to use.

The characters 经 and 济 were adapted from Chinese. The word 经济 was created in Japan, and it was borrowed into Chinese. Lots of words are like this (e.g., 科学, 社会, 電話)

I dunno why the need to discuss this? What is better? What is not better? Without Chinese providing the 汉字 (漢字), can the Japanese create all these terms in Kanji (漢字)? So, I dunno what is there to discuss.

This post has been edited by MasBoleh!: Oct 26 2024, 11:38 PM

did you get confused between writing scripts with the actual words of the language?

Okay, stop using Japanese words and see what happens.

Do you know most wasei kango are adopted from classical chinese text ?


经济 - “皆有经济之道，谓经国济民” 《文中子・礼乐篇》
民主 - “天惟时求民主，乃大降显体休命于成汤” 《书·多方》）
“仆为民主，当以法率下” 《三国志·吴志·锺离牧传》）
教育 - “君子有三乐，而王天下不与存焉。 父母俱存，兄弟无故，一乐也;仰不愧于天，俯不怍于人，二乐也;得天下英才而教育之，三乐也。” 《孟子·尽心上》

Please don't learn half half then come ajar orang.

Says who?

Don't bother mate. This autistic twat already has him preconceptions he is behaving like a broken record. While knowing a bit of Japanese is good and all, he has this tendency of acting all high and mighty for his linguistic prowess. And then he wonders why people are having issues with him