The Curious Case of Benjamin Button
Have you watched Big Fish or Forest Gump? Well if you haven't, I'd advise you to flip a coin and if it's heads - Big Fish, tails - Forest Gump. Just avoid this at all cause.
At a Q and A session with the fans, Fincher was asked whether it was the charm or the romance that attracted him the most about The Curious Case of Benjamin Button. He simply replied "No, I just liked the script" or it was a reply of that sorts. I thought that was pretty cool of Fincher given that I have always put his name in high regard since movies like Fight Club, Seven, Zodiac (wasn't a classic like everyone said due to its length but still a good film) and the underrated The Game and thought he can answer however he pleases. But I stand corrected.
The Curious Case of Benjamin Button is lifeless. Never have I ever seen a wannabe epic (big budget, length, props and everything) seem like such a waste of resources. I can't commend the acting. I mentioned previously that I hoped that this film bags honors at the Oscars but I've changed my mind. The southern accents were as lazy as lazy can be and the element of time seemed trivial in this movie - what changed from the 30s to 70s apart from drastic aging? All was unseen in the film - apart from a short Beatles clip. Sure he goes through WWII but what, for like 30 seconds? And he lived for 80 years but how much do we know about him to actually care?
Even for the love story, I couldn't comprehend it. No matter which way we look at it, it just seems disgusting. When Daisy asks Benjamin in their forties, "Sleep with me?" I can't help asking, why should he sleep with you now when he rejected you decades ago? Because the age seemed right now? So is it love or lust? And it's hard to care for Benjamin when his character isn't of the same moral cloth as Forest Gump or that Indian kid in Mumbai - he sleeps around with women. Some kind of love for Daisy eh?
It's movies like these and Australia (that's another story) that make me laugh at directors when they try to spend their way to an Oscar only to lose out to an indie film (cues Wrestler, Slumdog Millionaire).
Benjamin Button is a star that shines twice as long, half as bright.
Rating: 2.5/5 for the the grandeur settings/props/designs/make up.
This post has been edited by kobe8byrant: Jan 4 2009, 09:28 PM