QUOTE(kwss @ Dec 20 2023, 09:05 PM)
You are conflating a lot of different Android specific stuff and the dump it onto encryption in this post. I feel compelled to straighten the fact.
Huawei filesystem:
It has nothing to do with encryption.
It's a great filesystem only used on Huawei phone prior to Android 13. From Android 13 onwards, it's used on all Android phone. There's no problem with the filesystem, nothing to do with encryption and it works beautifully
https://www.esper.io/blog/android-dessert-b...oid-13-47987123SDCardFS:
It has nothing to do with encryption.
In fact Android 10 should behave the same because the change only started in Android 11.
https://www.xda-developers.com/diving-into-...ce-io-overhead/It's documented here as well for developer to adapt:
https://source.android.com/docs/core/storag...ver-performanceHave you at minimum tried running top on your phone and see where is the bottleneck?
Also try trimming your phone?
CODE
adb shell sm idle-maint run
adb shell sm fstrim
Well, slowdown not affected by encryption, but how's Android implement it.
You keep jumping in between solution, sure it will be unstable.
Not talking about how's SAF get enforced since it give up like 5 years from Kitkat android 4.4...
https://source.android.com/docs/core/storag...ardfs-deprecatehttps://source.android.com/docs/core/storag...use-passthroughAlso, you posting about those factory Android 10+, not those get upgraded from Android 8/9.
If you got a android 9 phone, check the file system, at Android 9 it is reported as F2FS, then Android 10 reported as sdcardfs.
And kernel version don't change since that.
https://source.android.com/docs/core/archit.../android-commonTry get a latest emmc phone with android 12 then u will know.
PS: You may messed up by my poor speaking, I means huawei supporting duplicate file combine, don't means it is better in encryption.
I just means that google also trying to redo the same duplicate file combine, but failed because they wait Meta to write the code, but not them.
PS2: Huawei upgrade their kernel version, yes, you can check on it, but it got a lot of slowdown bug happen to their own NM cards, should be fixed la.
---
Yes, slowdownness caused by lazy fix as it need update of kernel + filesystem to fix it.
QUOTE
System lag / hang when daily use / playing games (Redmi Note 9, Redmi Note 11, Redmi Note 9S, Redmi Note 11S, Redmi Note 11 Pro, Redmi Note 11T 5G)
https://new.c.mi.com/my/post/11302They just stop update ROM, and called it a fix, kernel version stay the same, still using sdcardfs not FUSE.
QUOTE(kwss @ Dec 20 2023, 07:35 PM)
After reading all the disable encryption post, I feel you all are better off doing data backup.
Your failure to backup your data is the root cause, not the encryption.
Hardware can fail, filesystem can get corrupted.
Also what kind of phone is still slow today? UFS is commonly available.
Let's not spread the disable encryption like disable IPv6
Yes and no, UFS don't means fast, my old asus zenfone max pro M1 with emmc still faster than Huawei Y Max emmc, while this Huawei Y Max got NAND dead before this old max pro M1....
And hell, I got friend using Mix2s, which also UFS, slowdown until failed to open Alipay within 5s.
But after he get a temporary backup Redmi 10 or whatever phone, it feel snappy than that mix2s.
I run a benchmark using CPDT, it is much, much slower than that old Max pro M1....
https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?...com.Saplin.CPDTSo yes, should be too much log writing(china app love to do log writing and caching unlimited) and unbalanced writing + TRIM algorithm broke it.
And no, disable encryption not a solution, backup with NAS always is.
But you should know, 99% of people don't do backup properly, no one teach them, they just do backup on pendrive, which failed more easy.

And as u can see, he jump to Android because he think Android safer from data lost/failing, but no it is not.
I just point it out and how to disable it, don't means I recommend it, else why I point it out can get crack easy after disabled it.
Also, NAND kind of hard to recover nowadays, it is not SSD or HDD, even SSD also hard, lol
This post has been edited by BenYeeHua: Dec 21 2023, 12:38 AM