Now, I would not be a good source for some of the answers. As a consultant, about 60% of my customers are Malays. These Malays are mostly in the white-collar industries; they understand the important of wealth accumulation and preservation, so they meet me for consultations - both paid as well as commission-based
In my personal views which may be biased due to the non-normal distributions of my clients, NEP has worked wonders; without which plenty of Malays would have been prevented from partaking in the country's economy. As you know, most Malays live in the villages, had their children and grandchildren remain there they would continue to become formers or any village-based employments. The Chinese community migrated to Tanah Melayu with a different mindset that is to make something for themselves; they are more studious and focussed to get what they want in life. These mentalities are yet to be ingrained in the Malay community as a whole
It may not seem fair, but due to the differences between the two cultures, it is a given that the Malays would be unable to compete unless given a hand to
out-Malay themselves. Have you noticed that most white-collar, professional Malays are generally very different than the rest of the Malays? I am referring to their openness to accept something that is different what they have been led to believe, their acceptance that at some point we need to accept merit-based appointments as opposed to clinging to "hak Melayu"? But did you know that these professional, white-collar Malays that we are discussing have benefited from NEP?
Their parents and themselves may have benefited from these policies, such as those through MARA - UiTM & MRSM. The ones that turned out well after coming through these systems realize that these
affirmative-actions will not remain forever and have continued to better themselves.
Had there not been any NEP, it would not be impossible for Malaysia to turn into Singapore, where Malays make up the majority of the labor forces and are excluded from the nation's economic activities. It may be good for Malaysia, but I would have none of it, not yet at least. It will take a few more decades for more Malays to change, if it will. If you ask a Chinese couple to raise a Malay child, he would turn out as successful, studious, academically-oriented as any Chinese or as his siblings - only that he would look-like a Malay.
The NEP is there to change out-Malay the Malays, perhaps it is misled, perhaps it is honorable. But when I was in Singapore for my business calls to meet my clients, kesian looking at the situations the Malays are in there - janitors, cleaners, fastfood employees are almost exclusively Malays. There are exceptions, but hey, I am an exception. What good are exceptions, Malays need to rise as a people too.
These are only my personal views though, and nothing that any of us here say would change the politically-biased economic landscape of the country.
Thanks for sharing your view. Well said.