Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )

Outline · [ Standard ] · Linear+

 Proton Suprima S V3, Slow Turbo.. Baru V3..

views
     
TDUEnthusiast
post Oct 20 2020, 01:31 PM

Critical thinking
Group Icon
Elite
10,015 posts

Joined: Mar 2009
From: the future
QUOTE(aku46 @ Oct 20 2020, 04:38 AM)
hi, plan to get a used car. tempted to get suprima s year 2017. quick check at mudah less than rm30k.

reading quite a bit on preve issues. did suprima have same issue? or proton already improve their qc for suprima.
my main concern:
1. cvt
2. och
3. aircon relay (fusebox design fail)

any thought?
*
Mostly same shit, slightly different packaging. Suprima has a different fuse box and the relay is easily replaceable


TDUEnthusiast
post Nov 22 2020, 05:23 PM

Critical thinking
Group Icon
Elite
10,015 posts

Joined: Mar 2009
From: the future
QUOTE(tawaubata @ Nov 22 2020, 02:53 AM)
Hi there, I'm in between getting a used Suprima S (30k, 2015) or new Proton Saga 2019 Premium AT.

New Saga met my expectation (felt spacious & comfortable than Bezza, handling review is good and not using CVT gearbox anymore)

But I'm surveying 2nd car too which I found Suprima S have what do I expected too (powerful engine, spacious, feature like keyless, touch screen, etc) but worried about spare part, maintenance and fc.

So as u guys owner of the Suprima S, what is your advice for me? Planned to grab car before end of the year.
*
The maintenance cost will kill* you, unless your maintenance budget is much higher than it would be for a Saga or Bezza

As you are planning to do Grab, stay away from the Suprima S. The suspension parts do NOT last, and this will only accelerate the wear and tear of everything

*Partly because a lot of parts do not last like the Oil Cooler Hose (burst issue), radiator fan motor and relays, plastic parts, etc, and mostly thanks to the turbo which makes it necessary to either stick to a good engine oil (i.e. relatively expensive), unless you would like to deal with oil sludge issues that will lead to premature failure of the turbo, which itself costs 4 figures

QUOTE(acid_head @ Nov 22 2020, 04:43 PM)
If you dont want have much headache, chill driving attitude only, go get the new saga.

Thos och and cvt gb is a time bomb. i have been taking extra care but the gb still not so smooth drive. Better walk away la
*
Exactly. This car requires a lot of money to be kept in a good condition, and really will or should only be kept by real enthusiasts of the car, which are not many..
TDUEnthusiast
post Dec 24 2020, 11:22 AM

Critical thinking
Group Icon
Elite
10,015 posts

Joined: Mar 2009
From: the future
QUOTE(tokuyushi.maeda @ Dec 23 2020, 11:17 AM)
hi guys,

which tyre brand is the best for suprima? i want to change 4 set. any advise guys?

Thanks
*
Best in terms of what? But the easy choice is usually Michelin Pilot Sport 4, 215/45R17

QUOTE(mrsu @ Dec 24 2020, 05:15 AM)
Thanks!
My Suprima S should be here next week, hopefully.
Thinking to change the Engine Lubricant (castrol magnatec), cvt oil and the filter(ori), coolant, brake fluid Nd power steering fluid, OCH, air filter, timing belt. Anything else I should also look at?
Anything I can do to prolong the Turbo? Servicing or anythg?
I have follow the fb group and little worry about the longetivity of the cvt gearbox, some cvt of suprima seems kong already.
*
Prolong life of turbo, use good fully synthetic engine oil as it lubricates the Turbo's bearing system and takes heat away from it. Lower quality engine oil can result in oil coking when they are exposed to higher temperatures like in a Turbo. This is usually the reason for turbo failure since the oil can no longer flow properly, or at all

CVT gearbox, unfortunately even at stock spec, it's quite close to the 220nm limit of the gearbox. It should last as long as the driver's foot does not work like an ON-OFF switch, i.e. either a hard press or nothing. Be gentle when moving off from a standstill, halve the recommended service interval from Proton, and if budget permits, get better CVT oil like Rock Oil CVTF and a better CVTF cooler

For the parking sensors, I read that some Android head units are able to work with the parking sensors which communicate via CAN, which means they have a CAN controller/reader built-in. Perhaps the accessory shop or group can provide more info
TDUEnthusiast
post Dec 24 2020, 08:22 PM

Critical thinking
Group Icon
Elite
10,015 posts

Joined: Mar 2009
From: the future
QUOTE(mrsu @ Dec 24 2020, 03:19 PM)
Hi thanks, such a relief. I will take good care of the cvt and might change the cvt oil every 45k km, the recommended interval should be around 60k km? If the CVT and engine not causing me any problem provided I take good care of them then I am ok with the common problem of ss. Such as fan relay, och need faster change than 40k km, noisy, plasticky interior ( although i dont think it is too bad, i like the interior actually).
Drove it twice and I really love the feeling and drive train of it.
Between, do you know if there is any reliable tires that is good in term of grip, not necessarily need to be handling excellently, safety and life span are still my main concern when come to tires.
*
Reliable tyres? Not sure. I have only used Achilles 2233, which are stock from factory for earlier batches. Not good experience cause it was already hardened. The replacement Continental CSC3 were better but still dreadful cause most of them were out of balance. Finally i chose PS4 and settled it with ever since, on second set now

Maybe Primacy 4 will fit your needs. If not look at some of the higher end Continental tyres. Don't bother too much with lifespan unless you drive long distances frequently. My PS4 lasted 50k km with some life left in them, and they felt a bit hard already. They were in the 3rd/4th year since manufacturing date. Still managed to sell two pieces for 50 MYR

QUOTE(mrsu @ Dec 24 2020, 03:22 PM)
Thanks, the AC belt is the fead belt? I intended to change that too shrn I receive the car.
Hopefully the car can take care of me if I take care of him nicely. seriously love the car. Been a father now and safety is my main concern, the 5 star Ncap and the drive train really are super b. Can't understand why typical Malaysian complaining it head to toe just because it is a Proton.
*
Yes, AC is FEAD. Be sure to buy original Proton, it's really cheap

You might be one of the many who will suffer from quality issues later. The good news is it's easy to predict what and when something needs to be replaced. The bad news is a lot of stuff do not last that long. They may be cheap but the costs add up quickly, and this is what many owners complain about

This post has been edited by TDUEnthusiast: Dec 24 2020, 08:22 PM
TDUEnthusiast
post Feb 5 2021, 01:39 PM

Critical thinking
Group Icon
Elite
10,015 posts

Joined: Mar 2009
From: the future
QUOTE(heavensea @ Jan 29 2021, 03:05 PM)
Hi guys, my car brake pad and radiator already rosak. Any recommendations?
*
Radiator - probably original. No idea about aftermarket options, but I'm sure there are plenty for Proton

Brake pad, some say original has really good bite without having to warm up compared to aftermarket options. Otherwise there are plenty of options like TRW and Bendix

QUOTE(thelousyllama @ Feb 4 2021, 07:12 PM)
hello. just wanna ask. i lost one car key. still have my spare key. how does one replace another key
*
You should be able to get it duplicated at a shop that does car keys. Otherwise the service centre should be able to help, although it will probably be very expensive
TDUEnthusiast
post Mar 8 2021, 12:24 PM

Critical thinking
Group Icon
Elite
10,015 posts

Joined: Mar 2009
From: the future
QUOTE(mafia1980 @ Mar 6 2021, 09:49 PM)
Ermm to all who are knowledgeable, i'm seeking assistant for my SS 2015.. Problem rough idling.. things i've tried

1. Replacing zip tube (proton replace)
2. Replacing new plugs (expensive, proton replaced)
3. 4 brand new plug coil ori (my DIY instinct)
4. Cleaning o2 sensor (dip with petrol few hours, light brushed and then CRC)
5. map sensor (sprayed with CRC electronic contact cleaner non residue)

Problem still exist.. Its sounded like high cam loping noise... haha if thats make sense.. since i replace all coils, when the engine hot, the idling smooth abit. I used obd code reader no fault code.. Send twice to proton to scan codes also no faults.. can somebody help me?
*
1. Timing belt tension
2. Check OCV valve
3. Check exhaust manifold gasket/turbo exhaust inlet gasket


Original NGK plugs are just slightly more expensive than aftermarket compatible iridium plugs
TDUEnthusiast
post Apr 29 2021, 12:52 PM

Critical thinking
Group Icon
Elite
10,015 posts

Joined: Mar 2009
From: the future
QUOTE(darrenwongts @ Apr 8 2021, 04:23 PM)
I am planning to get a used Suprima S 2014 soon, I am semi spirited driver, I saw someone on youtube saying using pedal shift is a major no on Suprima because it will accelerate the CVT kong. Is it true?
*
Some say it can be used safely but when performing manual shifts, it should not be done beyond 4000 rpm. I would say it is not healthy if the driver is very aggressive with manual shifting, otherwise it should be fine to use

Just don't expect it to be as nice as a DSG or even a normal auto

QUOTE(doorbell @ Apr 26 2021, 06:41 PM)
What do you think of a Proton Suprima  which is being serviced and maintained by Proton authorised service centre went kaput just after 5 years with mileage below 150,000km? The damage is so bad that you have to change the whole engine and cost you a bomb? This is what happened to my 5 years 1 month old Proton Suprima. (exactly one month after my warranty ended)

When you asked them to compensate something, they just said that my warranty has ended. So the car is a junk now. Proton quoted me Rm23, 000++  to change the whole thing.

Think of getting a Proton? Forget about it.
*
Did the timing belt break or something?

Also typically authorized service centres are not as flexible as the official ones. Try dropping a mail to proton we care and see if they can help, since you had your car maintained by proton for all this time

Alternatively outside workshops can probably have your engine repaired for less than 10000 probably, maybe even half of that


TDUEnthusiast
post Feb 15 2022, 12:16 PM

Critical thinking
Group Icon
Elite
10,015 posts

Joined: Mar 2009
From: the future
QUOTE(heavensea @ Feb 14 2022, 09:01 PM)
Hi guys, my car's antenna rod already "kaput" (black plastic all spoiled) and I just take it off. I am wondering whether I can just leave it without replace a new one since the radio channels are still working.

Anyone know what's the usage of that antenna road? It's for GPS or receiving radio frequency?
[attachmentid=11092465]
*
Proton ori = 20+ myr only

12 Pages « < 10 11 12Top
 

Change to:
| Lo-Fi Version
0.0237sec    0.21    7 queries    GZIP Disabled
Time is now: 10th December 2025 - 10:20 PM