On top of it, one needs to compare the individual players performance when the player is in the same form. Otherwise the comparison might not be fair.



This post has been edited by hwooi: Apr 5 2007, 02:21 PM

even outfield players also hard to find lo.....dunno that coach can trust or not if he say this maybe that player really play that position or what

ya lo....i wonder what the coach say for another youth team in the youth league. apparently, tat guy had a 4 star central defender.

What is the highest number of stars your youth team player obtain?
Mine was 1.5 stars.

mine was a 2 star..

more importantly you must understand how player stats contribute to the stars. then you'll figure out positions easier.

if an IM played offensive has 1.5 stars, playing him defensive / normal may result in more or lesser stars. then you can also play him on wing to see if he has winger skills.

now assuming stars in youth match work the same as stars in the team, then i think i have a great player with me.

my player

Alfred Scherer [1 booking accumulated] [Add this player to your bookmarks]
TSI = 1 960 , 32 years, solid form
Has excellent experience and passable leadership abilities [Powerful]

Stamina: excellent Keeper: disastrous
Playmaking: formidable Passing: inadequate
Winger: poor Defending: poor
Scoring: poor Set pieces: poor

gets only 2.5 stars when playing OCD. note the form, experience and other stats. (just dropped from outstanding PM)

a junior player of mine with inadequate form and obviously disastrous experience, gets 0.5 stars when playing OCD.

so comparing both, i think he MIGHT be a great player to pull.

*cross fingers*

hmm... nice summarize goldfries. I have 2 1.5 stars offensive mid to play in normal/defensive/winger position then

*typo

This post has been edited by dagg3r: Apr 5 2007, 10:09 PM

i saw from somewhere, every 2/3 blue star get by a youth, equal to 1 yellow star by senior...hope tis could help us evaluate how good a youth is...

Did you guys notice when the youth players' form change? I think its right after the match. Do check it out this coming week and post your findings here.

ouhh. that's the information i'm looking for.

i did read up here and there it's just crazy that youths get like 6 - 7 stars as keepers.

doesn't make sense, that's like a supernatural GK already.

lol, what an extreme conclusion.
I do hope also I have a promising defender to actually train..

Trainer said that one of my player is reacting to the defending training..

ah? what conclusion? anyway since sheepie here already replied i'll add a new post instead of editing.

so back to the topic. i checked HT-global a few days back and they have like 6 - 7 star players on GK slot.

from the stars given i'm seriously doubtful, just as my earlier post when i compare that a well skilled player on OCD has only 2.5 stars.

HiTechBakChi mentioned - every 2/3 blue star get by a youth, equal to 1 star by senior...

i think that's not correct. if 2/3 = 1 doesn't seem right. and you can't see 2/3 in the first place. haha. i think HTBC meant was every 2 to 3 stars = 1 star

so if we go based on average, that'll be 2.5 stars = 1

with this, a 7 star player would be equivalent to about 3 stars on a senior, that's so that comes to about passable keeper level.

so is it safe to say 2.5 stars = wretched core skill? maybe.......hehe. let's wait and see.

i think he meant 2 OR 3 star from youth = 1 star from senior

yeah. that's what i said. that's why i used the average instead, which is 2.5 stars.

nope, i'm not going to claim that. eargh (Nailemhard) was the first one and followed by IbrahimAbd

oh was it? ok, my mistake. then you're the 3rd. haha.

3rd?!?

At least is still podium finish....

Suwan Manuphan (141972154)
19 years, solid form, healthy
A controversial person who is calm and dishonest.
Has disastrous experience and poor leadership abilities.

Nationality: Prathet Thai
Total Skill Index (TSI): 1 990
Wage: 5 568 MYR/week including 20% Bonus
Owner: bmkid
Warnings: 0
Injuries: Healthy


Stamina: weak Goalkeeping: disastrous
Playmaking: poor Passing: inadequate
Winger: wretched Defending: formidable
Scoring: wretched Set Pieces: weak
tonight dateline just pop formidable pls support me lol

looks like the F1 weekend is getting into you d...

highly experience centre back for sale

Daniel Mallat (5759998)
32 years, passable form, healthy
A pleasant guy who is balanced and honest.
Has outstanding experience and poor leadership abilities.

Speciality: Unpredictable

Nationality: flag België
Total Skill Index (TSI): 690
Wage: 3 360 MYR/week including 20% Bonus
Owner: codottcore
Warnings: 0
Injuries: Healthy


Stamina: formidable Goalkeeping: disastrous
Playmaking: weak Passing: poor
Winger: weak Defending: excellent
Scoring: wretched Set Pieces: poor