QUOTE(nicotine @ Aug 13 2014, 12:33 PM)
From what I read api rating is mearly improvement on fuel economy,more additives for extended oci, more cleaning agent to prevent sludge. It does nott say low vicosity can protect engine better then higher vico oil. Lets compare the same brand with different xw rating.
Bukan nak fight. The api pdf u posted., clearly it stated consult your manual before refering to the chart. The logic behind is simple, diffrent region have different temp. You expect iran or arab to use 0-20w oil? I think most manufacture will hailat due to replacement engine.
the API tests and certification (if you want to know more, consider referring to their ASTM documentation) are getting stricter and stricter NOT ONLY on environmental/fuel economy concerns.Bukan nak fight. The api pdf u posted., clearly it stated consult your manual before refering to the chart. The logic behind is simple, diffrent region have different temp. You expect iran or arab to use 0-20w oil? I think most manufacture will hailat due to replacement engine.
and even on fuel economy, do you think an engine having high friction (lack of lubrication as per your concern) can still achieve that very purpose?
also, additives are RESTRICTED even further mainly due to environmental concerns, do you think you can simply add additives and get certified? (that's why things like amsoil signature series for extreme/extended OCI, or racing oils like 300v will NEVER get certified ever - too much additives)
and you said it yourself ma, viscosity doesn't determine an engine's protection ma, why not use lighter so the engine can perform better
ps: amsoil ss pdf i linked is mmg same brand/same model with different viscosities for your comparison
feel free to dig up motul's 300v also.
and of course, there's also my UOA lab report which i am linking again:
https://forum.lowyat.net/index.php?showtopi...post&p=69700867

not the most impressive of wear report, however i've been ascertain by many people including the folks at BSL that the wear is normal for early engine stages (leftovers from running in and what not)
Aug 13 2014, 01:23 PM

Quote
0.0209sec
0.56
6 queries
GZIP Disabled