GIA: 6211625016
HCA:
[attachmentid=8434876]

ANA:
[attachmentid=8434877]

Enchanted Cut Score:
[attachmentid=8434878]

GIA: 1172933516
HCA:
[attachmentid=8434879]

ANA:
[attachmentid=8434880]

Enchanted Cut Score:
[attachmentid=8434881]

If only 2 to choose from, then GIA 1172933516 (diamond 2) is a better choice. However, if it is up to me, I won't buy neither one because the HCA score is too low to my liking. Standard advice is to filter out anything that goes above the score of 2. I also won't go for SI2 diamonds, just personal preference.

For around RM 5700, you can get this:
http://www.whiteflash.com/loose-diamonds/r...id=myengringexp (this is an affiliate link) Together with a 18K white gold ring (with palladium content) from iDo Jewellery.

AGS-104090534005
HCA:
[attachmentid=8434889]

ANA:
[attachmentid=8434890]

Enchanted Cut Score:
N/A (only available for GIA cert)

Minor complains I have for this diamond is probably the star length of 56%. The hearts and arrows look great to me, although I won't rate it really the best of the best.

Or maybe from BGD:
http://www.briangavindiamonds.com/diamonds...#33;prettyPhoto[gallery2]/1/ (not affiliate link... yet).

AGS-104090535018
HCA:
[attachmentid=8434908]

ANA:
[attachmentid=8434909]

Enchanted Cut Score:
N/A (only available for GIA cert)

Note: AGS is comparable to GIA, if not better.

For more info, you may refer here: http://myengagementringexperience.blogspot...-brilliant.html

One more advice: Always get the diamond images - Actual diamond image, ASET image, IdealScope image, Hearts & Arrows image.

Hope this helps and good luck!  :thumbsup:

Hi,

Need you guys opinion about

Stone 1:
GIA No.: 6222860082
Spec: 0.58c D colour VS2 3EX
Quoted price from Wxx CXXX after some discount: RM10,400 (loose diamond)
It looks fine to me as a newbie under microscope and naked eyes. However I realised a big discrepancies between the score of cut between HCA tool (3.9) and Enchanted (96.6)

Stone 2:
GIA No.: 2175840567
Spec: 0.6c D colour VS2 3EX
Quoted price from Wxx CXXX after some discount: RM12k (loose diamond)
It looks fine to me as a newbie under microscope and naked eyes. However I realised a big discrepancies between the score of cut between HCA tool (2.4) and Enchanted (88.1)

Stone 3:
Another stone with casing (ready set):
GIA No.: 2196145177
Spec: 0.6c F colour VS2 3EX
Quoted price from Wxx CXXX after some discount: RM14,500
HCA cut score: 2.4
Enchated: 88.1

Stone 4:
Another stone with casing (ready set):
GIA No.: 5186587820
Spec: 0.5c D colour VS2 3EX (This 1 looks good but size is slightly smaller than my expectation
Quoted price from Wxx CXXX after some discount: RM11,300
HCA cut score: 0.8
Enchated: 100

No sure if either HCA tool or Enchanted cut score is more reliable?
Is this a good stone or good buy? I have been spending almost 2 months time visiting several shops for several times. Hope can finalise the decision soon.