Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )

Outline · [ Standard ] · Linear+

 BMW 118i vs Mazda 3, Which one would you buy?

views
     
wayfeel
post Feb 28 2014, 10:23 AM

Member of Elite Negotiators xD
*******
Senior Member
2,114 posts

Joined: Sep 2005
From: East


QUOTE(Mikeshashimi @ Feb 28 2014, 10:13 AM)
still not sure if TS meant the MPS or normal version.
*
Even if it was MPS3, the FWD has a bad torque steer tho with a LSD, it's not a RWD Bimmer and doesnt ride like the comfort of a 118i, no doubt cheaper by a RM15-20K, but higher roadtaz

The few good points of MPS3 over 118i other than price is that it is not afraid to look badass (the wicked hood scoop and oversized spoiler), japanese reliability and low maintenance, and it is 5.6sec car, very very quick...this alone is a value for money performance car and can be well considered, at 170K you get a mtfkr that is nurburgring tuned car with mazda service and warranty is a steal leh...Evo/Subby is 300K new. It's a wildest dream (affordable) performance car

One is more performance oriented with alot more above average comfort and feel like luxury stuff thrown in. Another is a perfectly packaged daily drive with a serious brand name.



This post has been edited by wayfeel: Feb 28 2014, 10:29 AM
jchue73
post Feb 28 2014, 12:40 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
2,496 posts

Joined: Nov 2006
QUOTE(wayfeel @ Feb 28 2014, 10:23 AM)
Even if it was MPS3, the FWD has a bad torque steer tho with a LSD, it's not a RWD Bimmer and doesnt ride like the comfort of a 118i, no doubt cheaper by a RM15-20K, but higher roadtaz

The few good points of MPS3 over 118i other than price is that it is not afraid to look badass (the wicked hood scoop and oversized spoiler), japanese reliability and low maintenance, and it is 5.6sec car, very very quick...this alone is a value for money performance car and can be well considered, at 170K you get a mtfkr that is nurburgring tuned car with mazda service and warranty is a steal leh...Evo/Subby is 300K new. It's a wildest dream (affordable) performance car

One is more performance oriented with alot more above average comfort and feel like luxury stuff thrown in. Another is a perfectly packaged daily drive with a serious brand name.
*
MPS has oversized spoiler?

user posted image

user posted image

A bit only lah. Not the surfboard ah beng style.

Yes, a daily driver with 4 doors plus a 3 paddle car to boot for those who want it.
dtna7
post Feb 28 2014, 01:36 PM

Casual
***
Junior Member
456 posts

Joined: Sep 2009
QUOTE(wayfeel @ Feb 28 2014, 10:09 AM)
Here M135i how much? Net rarely have M135i price
but Porsche/Cayman how much? 500-1M? but its simply a different segment/class car but the 135i is simply slapped with a M in front and suddenly the century sprint is -2.2second Rofl....
Ya definitely not the 'ordinary' 1s thats why its so good...1series is a brilliant cover-up, it treasds almost to a M3 supercar territory!!...damn rodent rage the road ...but it always goes back to pricing in which I've no idea because most of us is not rich biggrin.gif
*
M135i Recond 2013 source
A 2012 Boxster would cost very near.
Mavik
post Feb 28 2014, 10:35 PM

Patience is a virtue
Group Icon
Elite
7,826 posts

Joined: Jan 2003



QUOTE(wayfeel @ Feb 28 2014, 10:09 AM)
the previous 118i design better in my eyes. Oh wai, we can always wait for the next generation/model....but design aside, I didnt expect this 1s bimmer to be so well well-packaged ,packing 170HP doing friggin' 7.2sec is absolutely admirable and only at a fraction of 320i new car price...yet the 0-100 is same, if not better. IINM, my friend 2010/11 E92 Coupe 190/200Hp only 7.6sec(?) Makes it affordable yet totally not compromising on practicality, performance and build quality
*
At the price of the BMW 1 Series 118i. I would rather go for the Volvo V40 T5 or pay a bit more and get the Volkswagen Golf GTI.

170hp and doing 7.2sec is really nothing to shout about.

If you are comparing to the E92 coupe, then at that exact same price of the 1 Series 118i, you can get a decent E92 335i which has 300hp.

I can't say with all honesty that the 1 series has a combination of practicality and performance at all especially when the 118i does not have the M-Sport setup. Suspension is soft on that car and at high speeds you will feel it bouncing on the highway. The F30 non M-Sport 320i, 320d, 328i and 335i all face this.
Mavik
post Feb 28 2014, 10:38 PM

Patience is a virtue
Group Icon
Elite
7,826 posts

Joined: Jan 2003



QUOTE(wayfeel @ Feb 28 2014, 10:23 AM)
Even if it was MPS3, the FWD has a bad torque steer tho with a LSD, it's not a RWD Bimmer and doesnt ride like the comfort of a 118i, no doubt cheaper by a RM15-20K, but higher roadtaz
*
All this talk about RWD is pure bullshit unless you tell me you drive your RWD with traction control turned off all the time and push your car to the edge. Otherwise with traction control on, it doesn't feel very much different from driving a normal FWD car.
Mavik
post Feb 28 2014, 10:40 PM

Patience is a virtue
Group Icon
Elite
7,826 posts

Joined: Jan 2003



QUOTE(dtna7 @ Feb 28 2014, 01:36 PM)
M135i Recond 2013 source
A 2012 Boxster would cost very near.
*
At the price can get a nice 2009 Cayman with PDK as well. At least that would be a nice keeper biggrin.gif biggrin.gif biggrin.gif

But the M135i car is a fugly car and it doesn't beat the 1M in terms of looks man. I really wish to own a 1M but the damn car and its low production run costs RM430kRM430k!
6UE5T
post Feb 28 2014, 11:10 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,704 posts

Joined: Sep 2012
QUOTE(Mavik @ Feb 28 2014, 10:38 PM)
All this talk about RWD is pure bullshit unless you tell me you drive your RWD with traction control turned off all the time and push your car to the edge. Otherwise with traction control on, it doesn't feel very much different from driving a normal FWD car.
*
Hmm my car is RWD without having traction control and sometimes I do push it. Of course nobody drives like crazy all the time every single day lor, coz it's public roads and we still want to live! biggrin.gif Just feels nice to have a car where the front won't wash wide when you corner on the gas.
wayfeel
post Mar 1 2014, 12:22 AM

Member of Elite Negotiators xD
*******
Senior Member
2,114 posts

Joined: Sep 2005
From: East


QUOTE(Mavik @ Feb 28 2014, 10:35 PM)
At the price of the BMW 1 Series 118i. I would rather go for the Volvo V40 T5 or pay a bit more and get the Volkswagen Golf GTI.

170hp and doing 7.2sec is really nothing to shout about.

If you are comparing to the E92 coupe, then at that exact same price of the 1 Series 118i, you can get a decent E92 335i which has 300hp.

I can't say with all honesty that the 1 series has a combination of practicality and performance at all especially when the 118i does not have the M-Sport setup. Suspension is soft on that car and at high speeds you will feel it bouncing on the highway. The F30 non M-Sport 320i, 320d, 328i and 335i all face this.
*
Ya I tot about gti too but solely for the gb concern...I think 190k is an ok for a 118i for peace of mind n stronger branding since the 3s is nearing 300K...n not really fancy volvo. I believe E92 (in 2013) is about 190K recon, some still deem is used unit, 7.2s is by no means blistering fast, but for normal road, it is much more than enough, also considering the NEW gti (220k) is 6.5s and FD2R (200K) about 7s....7.2s is REALLY ok for me since it is no performance car like the gti which was built with fast in mind, unlike the 118i ,it is a wagon so all in all , 190k for a new bimmer with 7s performance, I do call that respectable and a good choice. I believe the M sport is mostly aesthetic cosmetic and ofcourse has performance advantages for the extra 30k? and the sub 7s E92, essentially a recon. and throw in recon, you can have more varied choices


This post has been edited by wayfeel: Mar 1 2014, 12:27 AM
wayfeel
post Mar 1 2014, 12:25 AM

Member of Elite Negotiators xD
*******
Senior Member
2,114 posts

Joined: Sep 2005
From: East


QUOTE(dtna7 @ Feb 28 2014, 01:36 PM)
M135i Recond 2013 source
A 2012 Boxster would cost very near.
*
Seem like they are pricing it around the M3 price? thats why so exorbitant. perhaps with the intention of being a sleeper car perhaps....coz it look only a wagon. Fundamentally, it's a niche market compare to sedan. I dont know much about boxster. If I did, I'm sure its difficult to choose as well


wayfeel
post Mar 1 2014, 12:33 AM

Member of Elite Negotiators xD
*******
Senior Member
2,114 posts

Joined: Sep 2005
From: East


QUOTE(6UE5T @ Feb 28 2014, 11:10 PM)
Hmm my car is RWD without having traction control and sometimes I do push it. Of course nobody drives like crazy all the time every single day lor, coz it's public roads and we still want to live!  biggrin.gif Just feels nice to have a car where the front won't wash wide when you corner on the gas.
*
Exactly.

I feel that I more n more lazy driving nowadays...I cruise at moderate speed only 100kmph and max 140 and much less aggressive driving of late.
Partly, many friends of friends died lately, road accident...seriously.
I almost met with a serious accident too yesday for speeding...close close shave, an inch and I might not be here oredy...I was reckless....So, drive a fast car also...drive slow slow now...no point. life is not THAT short to me, but fragile and can be unexpectably end, that I really admit...


SUSMamapapamsia
post Mar 1 2014, 12:27 PM

Casual
***
Junior Member
304 posts

Joined: Aug 2012
Pls la, u want to buy 1 series, get the 125i, if not dont buy!

The 1 series is really tiny inside. Plus the seats are very small. Uncomfortable for long journey.

And the interior is crazy cheapo for a car that exp. bmw quality is going down the drain!

Lastly, the looks of this bmw is ugly as hell.
jchue73
post Mar 1 2014, 06:11 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
2,496 posts

Joined: Nov 2006
QUOTE(Mavik @ Feb 28 2014, 10:38 PM)
All this talk about RWD is pure bullshit unless you tell me you drive your RWD with traction control turned off all the time and push your car to the edge. Otherwise with traction control on, it doesn't feel very much different from driving a normal FWD car.
*
Seriously no feel of better on power steering?

QUOTE(6UE5T @ Feb 28 2014, 11:10 PM)
Hmm my car is RWD without having traction control and sometimes I do push it. Of course nobody drives like crazy all the time every single day lor, coz it's public roads and we still want to live!  biggrin.gif Just feels nice to have a car where the front won't wash wide when you corner on the gas.
*
+1
Mavik
post Mar 1 2014, 09:42 PM

Patience is a virtue
Group Icon
Elite
7,826 posts

Joined: Jan 2003



QUOTE(wayfeel @ Mar 1 2014, 12:22 AM)
Ya I tot about gti too but solely for the gb concern...I think 190k is an ok for a 118i for peace of mind n stronger branding since the 3s is nearing 300K...n not really fancy volvo. I believe E92 (in 2013) is about 190K recon, some still deem is used unit, 7.2s is by no means blistering fast, but for normal road, it is much more than enough, also considering the NEW gti (220k) is 6.5s and FD2R (200K) about 7s....7.2s is REALLY ok for me since it is no performance car like the gti which was built with fast in mind, unlike the 118i ,it is a wagon so all in all , 190k for a new bimmer with 7s performance, I do call that respectable and a good choice. I believe the M sport is mostly aesthetic cosmetic and ofcourse has performance advantages for the extra 30k? and the sub 7s E92, essentially a recon. and throw in recon, you can have more varied choices
*
The GTI outperforms even the 125i M-Sport, what more compared to a soft 118i non M-Sport. Performance is not just measured in a 0-100 comparison.

But since you like just look at paper spec sheets, an E92 335i does the century sprint in only 5.0s.

The M-Sport package is A LOT more than just cosmetic. A lot of changes which includes the suspension setup, steering wheel, seats, it is definitely worth the extra RM30k.

In my opinion, the 118i at that price is not the best car you can get. But that is my own personal preference.
Mavik
post Mar 1 2014, 09:45 PM

Patience is a virtue
Group Icon
Elite
7,826 posts

Joined: Jan 2003



QUOTE(6UE5T @ Feb 28 2014, 11:10 PM)
Hmm my car is RWD without having traction control and sometimes I do push it. Of course nobody drives like crazy all the time every single day lor, coz it's public roads and we still want to live!  biggrin.gif Just feels nice to have a car where the front won't wash wide when you corner on the gas.
*
Different styles of driving for FWD and RWD, adjust where appropriate lol.
Mavik
post Mar 1 2014, 09:46 PM

Patience is a virtue
Group Icon
Elite
7,826 posts

Joined: Jan 2003



QUOTE(Mamapapamsia @ Mar 1 2014, 12:27 PM)
Pls la, u want to buy 1 series, get the 125i, if not dont buy!

The 1 series is really tiny inside. Plus the seats are very small. Uncomfortable for long journey.

And the interior is crazy cheapo for a car that exp. bmw quality is going down the drain!

Lastly, the looks of this bmw is ugly as hell.
*
+1
Noobi3
post Mar 1 2014, 10:28 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
4,984 posts

Joined: May 2010
From: South Pole


QUOTE(wayfeel @ Mar 1 2014, 12:25 AM)
Seem like they are pricing it around the M3 price? thats why so exorbitant. perhaps with the intention of being a sleeper car perhaps....coz it look only a wagon. Fundamentally, it's a niche market compare to sedan. I dont know much about boxster. If I did, I'm sure its difficult to choose as well
*
Partly cuz it's a 2013 car . 400k and below M3s are mostly 2011 and older , occasionally 2012 , depending on specs . If u compare it with a 2013 M3 , u can see the difference in pricing .
dtna7
post Mar 1 2014, 11:32 PM

Casual
***
Junior Member
456 posts

Joined: Sep 2009
the 118i is good if you are going for a used unit. Its seriously under demand and its a good car (provided space is not an issue). A new unit i wouldn't bother to look at it though.

 

Change to:
| Lo-Fi Version
0.0205sec    0.83    6 queries    GZIP Disabled
Time is now: 18th December 2025 - 06:45 AM