QUOTE(the99percent1 @ Nov 28 2014, 12:01 PM)
» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «
I understand your 'theory' of using ratios to govern your decision. But here is a scenario I propose to you:
You enter the stock market at its HIGHEST. Lets say your bond level starts to drops and so u top up. But then quickly, your stock position also starts to drop..
» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «
Sooner or later, you are at a losing point..
You see what i'm getting at.. same situation can happen if both rise at unequal rates, placing your ratios out of balance as you attempt to correct it..
Using ratios to govern your investment strategy is missing a crucial point of stock markets.. The market is emotionally fueled and driven.
Asset location does not make sense. At what point do you adjust your ratios? One day? a week? a month? Everytime you decide to adjust, that cost money as you move your funds around. Probably will wipe your gains..
A better way of doing this is to time your ETF investment at a good entry point and leave it 100% as Stock.. When markets begin to shift, then switch some to Bonds or buy up cheaper ETFS.. Alternatively, diversify your portfolio to include investments in share dividends and property. Allocation based on ratios may look good in theory, but it doesn't work applied..
the99percent1,
I DO NO THINK that you get IT.
Let's say that the ratio is 50/50 and you are putting $1,000 into your asset allocation every month. How could ANYTHING that you said will happen?? Show us...
<Asset location does not make sense. At what point do you adjust your ratios? One day? a week? a month? >>
If you READ the whole thread, you will know that it is either
A) Once a year
or
B) Based on the 5/25 re-balancing rule.
<< A better way of doing this is to time your ETF investment at a good entry point and leave it 100% as Stock.. When markets begin to shift, then switch some to Bonds or buy up cheaper ETFS..>>
This is BASED a BIG ASSUMPTION. A person know when to TIME the MARKET. 99+% of the people DO NOT KNOW. MAJORITY of the fund managers DO NOT KNOW either.
Dreamer
This post has been edited by dreamer101: Nov 28 2014, 09:24 PM