Lvl 49 barb reporting in.. Read thru the trhead and it seems, pure tanking barb is not so viable??
I for one is actually making one "great wall of china" tanking barb. Lol. Can't access game now but I'll just post the screenshot of my barb when I'm home. I'm trying to play a pure tanking style becos my party consist of 1 DH, 1 wiz and 1 monk. Dh and monk pumping dps, and wiz for crowd control. For partying, I'm not facing any problem so far. Currently at act 4, just killed azmodan last night.. All I do is just war stomp, threatening shout and keep the effect at taunting the mobs, and wats the skill call.. Turning u into monster one.. And revenge. Only using the "turning into monster" skill when its really a lot. No problem so far becos my wiz and DH have really good dmg. And As far as I'm concerned, when I'm alone, I have not died in nightmare mode yet. Almost, but revenge and a lil bit ofrunning around kept me alive. Wat I can say is to play a pure tanking barb u need good party to clear the mobs for u fast. As for solo, u will be having hard time as dps is not high at all.
I'll post up a screenies on myy char tonight. Not exactly perfect, but working fine so far till azmodan. As far as I rmb, I'm having bout 25k hp, 3.2k armor, and only 800 dps. Something like that. Hope it helps to clear the doubt of ppl who intend to play pure tanking barb, at least for nightmare, its still good enuff though u need good dps chars in ur party. Solo is really tough..

Btw I do have a question, I'm currently in nightmare onli. So I'm not too sure whether tanking style is viable to be used when I reach hell or inferno? Thinking to actually stick with tanking all the way, but read thru forum, it seems no matter how hardshell ur barb is, inferno can just kill u with a snap of finger. So for the moment, I'm starting to keep dps item. Lol