QUOTE(Duke Red @ Apr 17 2012, 03:01 PM)
The problem with switching managers all the time is that success if achieved, is invariably temporary. Both Houllier and Rafa enjoyed moments of success which ultimately ended as dramatically as it had begun. The success of a football club on the pitch should be dependant on the team itself and not it's individual players. Using the mancs as an example, they have managed to continue playing good football despite losing players like Ronaldo, Van Nistlerooy, Beckham, Schmeichel and so on over the years. The team continues to do will even with fringe players in their side. Honestly, how do the likes of Wes Brown, John O'Shea, Johnny Evans and Rafael stack up against anyone of our own? Are they better players?
In the old days, we were just like Man Utd are today. Regardless of which manager came in after Shankly and which players left, we played the same brand of football and we were good. Today, we're still trying to rediscover that winning formula and it doesn't help that each manager has their own preference in terms of how we play, and who we play. The benefit of promoting from the academy is this. That the lads have been playing together for a couple of years and if more and more of them make the grade, we'll have a group of first team players who are already with one another and able to play as a unit rather than a group of individuals just like the mancs class of 92.
Entirely agree.
The Manchester United players aren't necessarily better than ours. I mean, Wayne Rooney, Antonio Valencia, Nemanja Vidic are some of the best players but compared to the likes of Danny Welbeck, Jonny Evans and all, we may have players in similar quality or could even be better.
However, United certainly know how to win games. They've lost good players over the years and yet they will always play every season the same. I've never seen them have a bad Premier League season.
I remember I mentioned why Liverpool were so successful in the late 1970s-1980s is because we played football the same way, the same philosophy from Shankly to Paisley to Fagan to Dalglish. Almost the same way Manchester United has been built by Ferguson in his 27 year reign.
Also, during those times, we had the great players of Aldo, Rushie, Beardsley, Digger who easily slotted in with the previous successful teams built by Fagan and Paisley. Success breeds success and we had the winning mentality.
However, all these were probably lost when Kenny stepped down, only to be rebuilt by Evans, Houllier and Benitez but only for the progress to be halted under Roy Hodgson and H&G. Now, Kenny's got to build us up again.
I keep saying how the 2008-2009 runners-up squad is the best Liverpool squad I have ever seen in my life as a fan but we never won anything with them. Mascherano and Torres were easily one of the world's best in their positions but we won nothing. So maybe Lucas, Henderson, Carroll are no Mascherano, Alonso and Torres but we've won a trophy with them and there's a chance for another in 2-3 weeks time.
And about the academy benefits .. Take a look at Barcelona. It took 20 years for results to come out!