QUOTE(s[H]sIkuA @ Dec 10 2006, 09:56 AM)
Already 1 year ++ and still rocking , my 160GB samsung thats it

I use the Active Smart software (trial version) and there is absolutely no sign of dying or any ECC error , plus it is silent

heh production place will not make a difference, but Samsung hdd is good , atleast for the 160gb version, the newer 400gb version still dont have experience but based on SilentPCReview, its a good drive too, but behind the new 500GB Western Digital which is faster and quieter
I dont know if this is normal but my ActiveSmart keep showing this ECC error-on-the-fly on my Seagate 320gb drive, whereas the only thing changes in my Samsung is temperature

, hope it dont die though cause my valuable movie collection is all inside

amazing...
please keep us update with your samsung hdd information regard of any errors such as SMART etc.
after since i used the samsung DVD optical drive, and it gave me alots of problem where unable to read MOST of the dvds, hard to detect the media. that's why, base on this i never trust Samsung products...
QUOTE(RokXIII @ Dec 12 2006, 10:54 PM)
nope! WD wont noisy at all!
Currently using my WD 120GB PATA for almost 2 years ald, no problem at all! Highly recommended!

wow, already been using it 2 years...
oh ya, one thing i would liek to bring out is,
those WD hdd that i bought which has SMART error was 80GB version.
according to some expert said, maybe the 80GB batch of hdd is not that good,
SMART errors possible occur in this batch.
However, the 120GB WD hdd which in my another system running smoothly...
so far no SMART error show on the boot screen. I will use some hdd software to check my WD 120GB condition later.