bos, you are entirely wrong. why only read the last 2 pages and came up with that silly conclusion? Go read from 1st page, ok

There are 4 pages of healthy discussion.

At the end of the day, it depends on the individual to what sort of strategy they are after. Long term, short, hit and run etc.
If for Hit and Run - none of the ratios, business etc make sense to them. WHO CARES, get IPO dump on 1st day. LOL
A lot of things doesn't make sense for example in Smartag - traders/punters are just driving the price crazy. 

So, no harm whatsoever. Their money, their choice. 

You probably spend hundred of manhours trying to FIGURE out if its a GOOD BUY or not. Other people just spend 1-2 hours to make more money than you spend your effort on analyzing some numbers.

in the end, if people wanna goreng, they will goreng whatever price that will make no SENSE to you.

I mean even the 2 pages no nid to exist as every time the Q & A is repeated, am i said the the whole thread is discuing about how to apply IPO?

well..
if just goreng n goreng, hit n run thingy, there is no point open a thread here..bcos it is like kopitiam already.
The IPO education can ask the moderator to open a special thread for a newbie if it still not exist

yo andy, y so particular abt noob

in a forum we have so many diff level and knowledgeable individual

let it be...if noob need help, just help lo...
if u dont like to help then just dont help and wait for the forumer that u like appear and chat with the ppl that you like abt strategy or biz...
or post your thought and those that like u will sure reply and discussion will continue from there.

like me also, although seldom post but i benefit a lot from the feedback in the forum so those post that does not benefit me, i just ignore becoz others might benefit from it

this is public forum ma so cannot expect, it to just cater for you...

so how many lots are you applying?

I have applied 100lots through i-Trade-IPO. Now pending balloting.

On board too, I applied 4k units only. Save some bullets for others.

yo andy, y so particular abt noob

in a forum we have so many diff level and knowledgeable individual

let it be...if noob need help, just help lo...
if u dont like to help then just dont help and wait for the forumer that u like appear and chat with the ppl that you like abt strategy or biz...
or post your thought and those that like u will sure reply and discussion will continue from there.

like me also, although seldom post but i benefit a lot from the feedback in the forum so those post that does not benefit me, i just ignore becoz others might benefit from it

this is public forum ma so cannot expect, it to just cater for you...

so how many lots are you applying?

not applying after go through the whole prospectus...cheers

when is this IPO open??

not applying after go through the whole prospectus...cheers

I applied manually via CIMB atm (long story , so cut it short), and then just got the application from OSK and already courier the application form together with my ATM slip, IC photocopy to MIH. Good luck to myself.

What? I remember I used to do that, around 20 years ago... can't imagine there are still ppl doing that

I applied manually via CIMB atm (long story , so cut it short), and then just got the application from OSK and already courier the application form together with my ATM slip, IC photocopy to MIH. Good luck to myself.

I thought you are 20 years old, kinda rich to me.

Oops... leak out my age... correction, I used to help ppl do that during that time, got forms to fill & 2 envelopes to send, every time need to recycle the photocopy of IC some more... 

i remember my mum used to do that during 90's

always go bank to prepare several bank draft and lend I/C from relative
the form is like size of newspaper

not applying after go through the whole prospectus...cheers