Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )

Outline · [ Standard ] · Linear+

 When AC on, car shakes badly when idling, When AC off, car is quiet when idling

views
     
the_catacombs
post Aug 17 2010, 11:05 PM

8 stars wooo....
********
Senior Member
10,975 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: disini disana


QUOTE(sooyongng @ Aug 17 2010, 08:41 PM)
haha.sorry for late reply.
I bought from someone unknown, contact him thru hp...
Then it only cost me RM42+RM5 shipping.

I installed it myself after do some research on internet.
simple only...have to cut TWO hose, Aircond compressor LIVE WIRE.
then use T-joint for the hoses...

RM60 below can done liao!

already using it for 1 months plus...still very good condition~
*
oh u mean the FICD ahh??
dvlzplayground
post Sep 2 2010, 04:19 AM

Web developer Nadzim.com
*******
Senior Member
7,916 posts

Joined: Jul 2005
From: Kuala Lumpur


ah, so my car got this problem too. engine shake when idle with aircond on, but ok if off. hard to read thru this thread with the quarreling tongue.gif

so verdict is change engine mounting? how much would it cost?
Lineage
post Sep 5 2010, 12:21 AM

the Chaotic Throne
*******
Senior Member
4,524 posts

Joined: Oct 2007
From: ~Still finding the place~


Hi all, actually this problem happen to my Wira 1.5GL Auto quite long time ago..after reading and do some research..found out the Toyota FICD is the cheapest solution for me..

Seems everyone saying it's easy to fix and can DIY..but I don't want to do it myself(noob in doing this kind of things)..
If I would like to send to workshop, will they know about this Toyota FICD? and how much they will charge me?

My situation is when on AC, when the car idle, the RPM will up and down, and the engine sound like will die anytime..car a bit shaking..
kinmin888
post Sep 22 2010, 12:29 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
131 posts

Joined: Apr 2008
hi all.
i faced the problem as well.
mountings were changed but problem still exist.
any good suggestion?
GEFORCEXTREME
post Sep 27 2010, 06:34 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
60 posts

Joined: Jan 2009
Engine mounting problem, my car experienced this before, whole car shake like hell. After changing, much better.

Mind you I have FICD in my car before and after the whole experience.


Added on September 27, 2010, 6:35 pm
QUOTE(dvlzplayground @ Sep 2 2010, 04:19 AM)
ah, so my car got this problem too. engine shake when idle with aircond on, but ok if off. hard to read thru this thread with the quarreling tongue.gif

so verdict is change engine mounting? how much would it cost?
*
About RM 200+ for the parts only, installation depends on mechanic. That is for Satria/Wira.

This post has been edited by GEFORCEXTREME: Sep 27 2010, 06:35 PM
SiLv3sTeR
post Nov 10 2015, 06:29 PM

New Member
*
Junior Member
32 posts

Joined: Dec 2007
anyone can recommend sifu in ipoh who able to install FICD or checking error for my wira? rpm up down up down.... @@ 2nd throttle body
regvpn
post Nov 26 2016, 07:33 PM

New Member
*
Newbie
1 posts

Joined: Sep 2012


QUOTE(the_catacombs @ Aug 10 2010, 01:12 PM)
jz need to pusing 1 screw only... vr easy one...

» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «

*
THIS PROBLEM CAN BE SOLVE WITH ONLY ADJUSTING 1 SCREW! (in the event that all components are working properly). The best way to know that u only need to adjust the screw is.

1) Engine only gegar when you open the aircond
2) But when you press the accelerator, it become normal.
3) This only happen when you are in IDLE mode. When you are driving (press the accelerator), everything is good "even with aircond".


Yaa..seriously..only 1 screw (actually 2, there are 1 more at the back if u want to make it balance) i also have the same problem. Terbang RM 70 (Tuning + change spark plug) for nothing when hand it to mechanic. The mechanic dont tune it properly so that i need to go back there to change another part that he suggest " some aircond actuator-thingy". Lucky me i am a fast learner, i see the whole process when he tune the engine. It's just a matter of pusing a screw to adjust the rpm when in idle mode. I AM NO EXPERT IN CARS AND DONT KNOW ANYTHING ABOUT THE COMPONENTS IN THE CAR. BUT I MANAGE TU TUNE IT at around 1.1 rmp when ideling!!. THE PROBLEM "SHAKING WHEN AIRCOND IS ON" vanish!!. If only i had this knowledge yesterday. I save RM 70. The spark-plug in my opinion is not necessary. Most kedai want to tapau ur money only. Do a little experiments on ur car. biggrin.gif biggrin.gif . Will attach the picture of the position of the screw later.
ricko99
post Jan 30 2017, 02:48 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
184 posts

Joined: Apr 2012
From: KL, MY


QUOTE(regvpn @ Nov 26 2016, 08:33 PM)
THIS PROBLEM CAN BE SOLVE WITH ONLY ADJUSTING 1 SCREW! (in the event that all components are working properly). The best way to know that u only need to adjust the screw is.

1) Engine only gegar when you open the aircond
2) But when you press the accelerator, it become normal.
3) This only happen when you are in IDLE mode. When you are driving (press the accelerator), everything is good "even with aircond".
Yaa..seriously..only 1 screw (actually 2, there are 1 more at the back if u want to make it balance) i also have the same problem. Terbang RM 70 (Tuning + change spark plug) for nothing when hand it  to mechanic. The mechanic dont tune it properly so that i need to go back there to change another part that he suggest " some aircond actuator-thingy". Lucky me i am a fast learner, i see the whole process when he tune the engine. It's just a matter of pusing a screw to adjust the rpm when in idle mode. I AM NO EXPERT IN CARS AND DONT KNOW ANYTHING ABOUT THE COMPONENTS IN THE CAR. BUT I MANAGE TU TUNE IT at around 1.1 rmp when ideling!!. THE PROBLEM "SHAKING WHEN AIRCOND IS ON" vanish!!. If  only i had this knowledge yesterday. I save RM 70. The spark-plug in my opinion is not necessary. Most kedai want to tapau ur money only. Do a little experiments on ur car.  biggrin.gif  biggrin.gif . Will attach the picture of the position of the screw later.
*
Sorry for bumping old thread. My saga lmst has the same issue, idle with air cond on it shakes and rpm back to normal when accelerating. Would you mind showing which screw are you talking about to tune the idle rpm?
mot88
post Jan 30 2017, 11:42 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
141 posts

Joined: Oct 2005
QUOTE(ricko99 @ Jan 30 2017, 02:48 AM)
Sorry for bumping old thread. My saga lmst has the same issue, idle with air cond on it shakes and rpm back to normal when accelerating. Would you mind showing which screw are you talking about to tune the idle rpm?
*
To remove suspense, you may refer to the picture of post #2399 in the link below.
https://forum.lowyat.net/topic/2900268/+2380

If the air con idling adjustment does not change even after adjust, then it could be the gold coloured round thing tht screw attached to it (called air con idling vacuum pump or 'vacuum actuator' in the pic) is spoilt. Pls make sure it is Denso brand when replacing. Cost about RM 90 few years ago. Local brand costs half the price but only last few months. Denso last for years. I purchased the Denso part from a spare part shop in OUG years ago.

Pls also check for vacuum hose for leak (those small hoses) as they tend to crack at either end of joint. It will cause the adjustment take no effect.

Note:
1)You need to rev a bit after each adjustment for new setting to take effect.

2) Proper way is to adjust the base timing without the air con screw then only adjust air con idling screw.

This post has been edited by mot88: Jan 30 2017, 01:42 PM
ricko99
post Jan 30 2017, 04:09 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
184 posts

Joined: Apr 2012
From: KL, MY


QUOTE(mot88 @ Jan 30 2017, 12:42 PM)
To remove suspense, you may refer to the picture of post #2399 in the link below.
https://forum.lowyat.net/topic/2900268/+2380

If the air con idling adjustment does not change even after adjust, then it could be the gold coloured round thing tht screw attached to it (called air con idling vacuum pump or 'vacuum actuator' in the pic) is spoilt. Pls make sure it is Denso brand when replacing. Cost about RM 90 few years ago. Local brand costs half the price but only last few months. Denso last for years. I purchased the Denso part from a spare part shop in OUG years ago.

Pls also check for vacuum hose for leak (those small hoses) as they tend to crack at either end of joint. It will cause the adjustment take no effect.

Note:
1)You need to rev a bit after each adjustment for new setting to take effect.

2) Proper way is to adjust the base timing without the air con screw then only adjust air con idling screw.
*
Did what you suggested, adjusted both screws and currently the car idle without ac is at 1.1k - 1.2k rpm and with ac on at full blast it's at about 800 - 900 rpm. Is it okay? Because anything below 800 is quite shaky already even the front bonnet shakes really hard. I'm afraid the fuel consumption might increase as before this my idle rpm without ac was 1k

Also, in the long run, is it better to install Toyota FICD to regulate the rpm?

This post has been edited by ricko99: Jan 30 2017, 04:21 PM
mot88
post Jan 30 2017, 04:52 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
141 posts

Joined: Oct 2005
QUOTE(ricko99 @ Jan 30 2017, 04:09 PM)
Did what you suggested, adjusted both screws and currently the car idle without ac is at 1.1k - 1.2k rpm and with ac on at full blast it's at about 800 -  900 rpm.  Is it okay? Because anything below 800 is quite shaky already even the front bonnet shakes really hard. I'm afraid the fuel consumption might increase as before this my idle rpm without ac was 1k

Also, in the long run, is it better to install Toyota FICD to regulate the rpm?
*
without air con should be ard 800 to 850rpm and with air con ard 950 to 1k rpm.I dont have the factory spec for exact figure.

Looks like your fast idling is not working. To get the it to work 3 items must be working
1) air con vacuum pump /vacuum actuator.
2) FICD (carb version)
3) vacuum hose not leaking and correctly attached.
For hose it should be run from engine block to ficd (denso carb version) and another hose from ficd to a/c vacuum pump.

Yes, the proton wira carb has ficd as well. LMST shld hv as well as using the same drivetrain. It looks like toyota ficd, attached to firewall with 2 small vacuum hose attached to it.

Last time,not working, I changed 3 items after fed up workshop doing it using generic local parts. Item 2 seldom spoilt but I changed it as not tht expensive.

1) approx m90 (oem denso for carb)
2) approx rm 80 (oem denso)
3) vacuum hose rm 2 for 1 feet ( abt 4 to 5 feet )
(price quoted is few years ago)

Correct vacuum connection is priceless..as even changed all 3 items but connection is wrong, fast idling (i.e with air con on) will not work.

This post has been edited by mot88: Jan 30 2017, 05:10 PM
ricko99
post Jan 30 2017, 05:25 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
184 posts

Joined: Apr 2012
From: KL, MY


QUOTE(mot88 @ Jan 30 2017, 05:52 PM)
without air con should be ard 800 to 850rpm and with air con ard 950 to 1k rpm.I dont have the factory spec for exact figure.

Looks like your fast idling is not working. To get the it to work 3 items must be working
1) air con vacuum pump /vacuum actuator.
2) FICD (carb version)
3) vacuum hose not leaking and correctly attached.
For hose it should be run from engine block to ficd (denso carb version) and another hose from ficd to a/c vacuum pump.

Yes, the proton wira carb has ficd as well. LMST shld hv as well as using the same drivetrain. It looks like toyota ficd, attached to firewall with 2 small vacuum hose attached to it.

Last time,not working, I changed 3 items after fed up workshop doing it using generic local parts. Item 2 seldom spoilt but I changed it as not tht expensive.

1) approx m90 (oem denso for carb)
2) approx rm 80 (oem denso)
3) vacuum hose rm 2 for 1 feet ( abt 4 to 5 feet )
(price quoted is few years ago)

Correct vacuum connection is priceless..as even changed all 3 items but connection is wrong, fast idling (i.e with air con on) will not work.
*
So if I get you correctly, it means idle rpm with ac OFF should be lower than idle with ac ON?
mot88
post Jan 30 2017, 07:39 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
141 posts

Joined: Oct 2005
QUOTE(ricko99 @ Jan 30 2017, 05:25 PM)
So if I get you correctly, it means idle rpm with ac OFF should be lower than idle with ac ON?
*
Yes..If set properly and fast idling working, the rpm will drop a bit when air con on and then climb bk to slightly higher.

The fast idling is mechanically activated, tht explain the delay is more than electronically controlled.

If u need to set the rpm of air con off higher to compensate the load imposed when air con is switched on, tht explain tht fast idling mechanism is not working.

This post has been edited by mot88: Jan 30 2017, 07:39 PM
ricko99
post Jan 31 2017, 03:13 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
184 posts

Joined: Apr 2012
From: KL, MY


QUOTE(mot88 @ Jan 30 2017, 08:39 PM)
Yes..If set properly and fast idling working, the rpm will drop a bit when air con on and then climb bk to slightly higher.

The fast idling is mechanically activated, tht explain the delay is more than electronically controlled.

If u need to set the rpm of air con off higher to compensate the load imposed when air con is switched on, tht explain tht fast idling mechanism is not working.
*
I played around with both screws again and I set my idle ac off rpm to 850. When I switch on my ac it drops to 700ish and once I rev the engine a bit, it hovers around 950ish. If I don't rev, it takes quite a while before the rpm goes up. I've checked the vacuum hose and seems like there's no leakage or anything like that. I checked my FICD is probably cap ayam brand (pacific or sth like that) but looks like it's adjustable as it has this one part that I can turn left and right. I think my hose connection are correct as well

user posted image
user posted image
mot88
post Jan 31 2017, 11:05 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
141 posts

Joined: Oct 2005
QUOTE(ricko99 @ Jan 31 2017, 03:13 AM)
I played around with both screws again and I set my idle ac off rpm to 850. When I switch on my ac it drops to 700ish and once I rev the engine a bit, it hovers around 950ish. If I don't rev, it takes quite a while before the rpm goes up. I've checked the vacuum hose and seems like there's no leakage or anything like that. I checked my FICD is probably cap ayam brand (pacific or sth like that) but looks like it's adjustable as it has this one part that I can turn left and right. I think my hose connection are correct as well
From my experince, the correction of fast idling load should be 2 to 3 sec. The 1st thing is to ensure related hoses fit tight. Over time the hoses expand at the join end (bulging effect) causing it not air tight. Can cut at bulging area if the hose still have enough lenght. Not suggesting you to do that but thats maybe the root cause.Best to take out the hose to inspect. It could have micro crack.

Since it did climb back, but take longer, it shows the fast idling mechanism work but may not be optimum. I didnt adjust and dont think there is any adjument screw on the denso ficd for carb version. Maybe Proton changed the FICD supplier for newer batches.

Your hose connection looks correct based on your photos. Raw suction from engine block to FICD. Ficd block suction to a/c vacuum pump when air con off. When air con on, the ficd open the valve for suction to a/c vacuum pump, in turn pull the carb cable to add more air/fuel mixture.

For your reference on the adjustment screw at Toyota FICD for fuel injected car. Looks to me redundant for carb as there is adjustment screw at a/c vacuum pump (efi dont have a/c vacuum pump and rely on ficd screw for adjustment).
http://www.diytacra.com/2010/11/ficd-fast-...device.html?m=1



This post has been edited by mot88: Jan 31 2017, 11:28 AM
ricko99
post Jan 31 2017, 01:08 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
184 posts

Joined: Apr 2012
From: KL, MY


QUOTE(mot88 @ Jan 31 2017, 12:05 PM)
From my experince, the correction of fast idling load should be 2 to 3 sec. The 1st thing is to ensure related hoses fit tight. Over time the hoses expand at the join end (bulging effect) causing it not air tight. Can cut at bulging area if the hose still have enough lenght. Not suggesting you to do that but thats maybe the root cause.Best to take out the hose to inspect. It could have micro crack.

Since it did climb back, but take longer, it shows the fast idling mechanism work but may not be optimum. I didnt adjust and dont think there is any adjument screw on the denso ficd for carb version. Maybe Proton changed the FICD supplier for newer batches.

Your hose connection looks correct based on your photos. Raw suction from engine block to FICD. Ficd block suction to a/c vacuum pump when air con off. When air con on, the ficd open the valve for suction to a/c vacuum pump, in turn pull the carb cable to add more air/fuel mixture.

For your reference on the adjustment screw at Toyota FICD for fuel injected car. Looks to me redundant for carb as there is adjustment screw at a/c vacuum pump (efi dont have  a/c vacuum pump and rely on ficd screw for adjustment).
http://www.diytacra.com/2010/11/ficd-fast-...device.html?m=1
*
I see. Could be the vacuum pump or the ficd faulty but I have no way to test that. So I guess I'll just try to replace the ficd with Denso first plus change the entire tubing. And if that still doesn't help, I'll try to change the vacuum pump. Hopefully it's not carb or throttle body issue. I'll let you know if anything happens. Thanks for the info, appreciate it thumbup.gif
LoPakTao1122
post Aug 29 2018, 10:49 PM

New Member
*
Newbie
0 posts

Joined: Oct 2017
I have the same problem as well but during the A/C on..... Went to mech shop cant find the problem at all.... Any god here can help me out?

Idle with A/C on rpm went super low and car vibrate as hell..... As soon as it reach 0 rpm then the RPM bump back up to normal....
If idle without A/C on then is normal....

My car is Vios NCP 93 2012 model.

Anyone know whats the problem?

3 Pages < 1 2 3Top
 

Change to:
| Lo-Fi Version
0.0233sec    0.58    5 queries    GZIP Disabled
Time is now: 15th December 2025 - 03:43 AM