maybe he golden dupe

don't flame.he didn't say what list.MamulaMoon,is it poached players list or academy list?lol

u r rite.. some people are always too quick to bash the others

but his post has high possibility to be added here

From my understanding,



From the 1st word until the last word, I cant and I didn't see him talking about "poached players" list.It's all about academy and funnily the 1st sentence is,



Where is it the talk about poached player?

Is either you guys have some problem understanding his post or you guys defending him for the sake's of defending.

Beckham not a Man U homegrown talent..

He start at Brimsdown Rovers
1987–1991-Tottenham Hotspur then ManU

Even Giggs not originally from Man Utd..
1985–1987-Manchester City..then MU

Only Neville..is a original MU..

So if you dont know your player..how come you talked about them...

KTBFFH!

You should see where the player starts to shine and improve instead of where he started to play football. For example, fabregas shone/improved when he joined arsenal tho he's from barcelona.

This is kinda out of topic tho.

Ichighost, whether beckham and giggs are originally from manutd or not it doesnt matter, because they became the best and improved the most when they're in manutd. Btw, i would not use the term homegrown talent, maybe manutd academy talent =P

This post has been edited by nshady: Sep 9 2009, 03:46 PM

I beg to differ.Just because he shines and improves there, that doesn't mean he is from their academy.Simple.How sure are you that he wont shine and improve in his former academy?No one can be sure of that.Regardless of whether he improve, shines or fades, it's undeniable fact that it's one of the classic example of big clubs raiding starlets...

Btw, actually im out of topic ady...lol...im just referring to some of the replies here...hahah...

First, I didnt say that he wont shine and improve at his former academy(i was just saying he shines and improves somewhere). I am referring to the players mentioned above, and no one would know if they will shine at their former academy unless you have a time machine where the players can train at two clubs =P

This post has been edited by nshady: Sep 9 2009, 03:55 PM

this is getting hotter

Man United could face Fiorentina complaint

Lazio probably follow Fiorentina after this...

Anyway, no worries for manu..All they got to do is recruit as many as possible before they land the ban...They took 2 years before landing ban on Chelsea, no?

not everybody here is a professor in english.. sometimes people just dont know how to express themselves correctly cause of lack of knowledge in foreign language

because its still 50/50, lets dun judge him now

This post has been edited by MADReaLJL: Sep 9 2009, 06:35 PM

Is not about language.It's pretty obvious he is saying those players are academy players.Cant you see it?Closely after Beckham,Neville, Giggs, he said can add "ronaldo and co" into the same list.

Seriously, I dont know why you are defending him for the sake of defending when it's pretty obvious language isn't really the matter here.

Oh well...Each to his own...

he didnt, u put that urself
its kinda offtopic now.. dun wanna turn this thread into man utd bashing or english class
plus, everybody has their own opinions.. u have urs and i have mine.. case closed


now more clubs started to enter the spotlight.. trying to get some money there?

This post has been edited by MADReaLJL: Sep 9 2009, 06:45 PM

Oh well, it's well known fact, the world is against ManU...

Agreed..

Ronaldo isn't from manutd's academy to whoever claims he is. Being a better club sure makes your rivals and their fans hate you more especially when you win more and more(from them).. No offense that there are many manutd haters out there..but manutd lovers aren't little either.

This post has been edited by nshady: Sep 9 2009, 08:11 PM

Not because he in a better club..but because he dive and smile after that...that really irritated..no offense...

What are you trying to say? Who is in a better club? I wasn't even referring to a player. We're talking about clubs. Relax man..you seem to be trying to express hatred towards manutd now...lol.

cool down =P

This post has been edited by nshady: Sep 9 2009, 08:14 PM

Hahhaha..okey....look like their lovers also know the habit of their player..

back to the topic..look like several english club reported to FIFA now...left Pool and Arsenal now from the top 4...

is there anything to point that he's a UTD fan? i guess he's not even a football fan