You should see where the player starts to shine and improve instead of where he started to play football. For example, fabregas shone/improved when he joined arsenal tho he's from barcelona.

This is kinda out of topic tho.

Ichighost, whether beckham and giggs are originally from manutd or not it doesnt matter, because they became the best and improved the most when they're in manutd. Btw, i would not use the term homegrown talent, maybe manutd academy talent =P

This post has been edited by nshady: Sep 9 2009, 03:46 PM

Btw, actually im out of topic ady...lol...im just referring to some of the replies here...hahah...

First, I didnt say that he wont shine and improve at his former academy(i was just saying he shines and improves somewhere). I am referring to the players mentioned above, and no one would know if they will shine at their former academy unless you have a time machine where the players can train at two clubs =P

This post has been edited by nshady: Sep 9 2009, 03:55 PM

Ronaldo isn't from manutd's academy to whoever claims he is. Being a better club sure makes your rivals and their fans hate you more especially when you win more and more(from them).. No offense that there are many manutd haters out there..but manutd lovers aren't little either.

This post has been edited by nshady: Sep 9 2009, 08:11 PM

What are you trying to say? Who is in a better club? I wasn't even referring to a player. We're talking about clubs. Relax man..you seem to be trying to express hatred towards manutd now...lol.

cool down =P

This post has been edited by nshady: Sep 9 2009, 08:14 PM

Agreed here