QUOTE(Makakeke @ Aug 31 2009, 11:46 AM)
Your own rating? Carrick is nowhere near 5, he was very good and his best game this season.
Didn't say much though, hardly do anything. Hopefully it's just a case of him being in that crappy form for a few weeks and then play like normal again.
QUOTE(shortleg88 @ Aug 31 2009, 12:04 PM)
I've finally managed to give my own opinion on the game after internet deprived for the past 2 days. From what I've seen, we are no champions material YET but at least we still have the champions luck. I'm surprised with the 5 men midfield, but somehow that's expected from SAF who likes to cramp the midfield against the Top 4 in order to gain possession. But that leaves Rooney isolated upfront, he still unable to play the lone frontman yet but can see he's improving. It used to be Ronaldo in that role, as he has a strong header, speed and can attract the defenders to him and bringing others into the play.
Rooney tries his best to win headers and on few occassion he did. But no one was there supporting him, a role which I have expected Giggs to fill but his age has clearly caught up to him. At least last time Ronaldo has Rooney at his side which he can feed to, but I can see no one with Rooney on that role, no one has gone close to him perhaps Evra and Fletcher on some occasion. It's very disappointing to see Rooney trying his best yet no one understands him.
Another area that need to be work on is the right wing. Park did more in his 20 min cameo than Valencia. Valencia clearly need to work on the chemistry with the team, on countless occasion i see, there are only few link up play coming from Valencia and O'Shea, unlike Nani and Evra on the left. He still seem clueless cutting in from the right to the middle. Giggs first half performance was awful as well, stray passes or passes cut.
Fletcher is indeed bringing more influence to the team. I might be greedy but I do hope he can polish his scoring boots as well, he is able to run into spaces in the box but often his touch lets him down. Seriously we lacked of creativity at the moment and we are relying on Rooney too much. If he *touch wood* out, against more significant team we might struggle
I beg to differ. We have plenty of creative influence in the team. Giggs clearly is one.. but he was shocking that night. Ball got to him, we would always lose it/made the wrong decision/pass not quite there. He can rush things sometimes, which is his frustrating trait.. but generally he's fine there, but that night, god I wanted to kill him. Ando is another one..
Clearly Valencia is not in the groove yet. Showed good play in patches, but other times can be a bit clueless and not involved. Doesn't help when we keep on changing the RB every single game though. SAF, just stick with one! Stick Wes/Fabio there and be done with it.
QUOTE(deora @ Aug 31 2009, 12:20 PM)
agree with u quite much..
but for me..
valencia - after seeing him play a few matches..i started to wonder whether is he REALLY good enuf to play for man utd..during the arsenal game..he kena attacked by other players more than he attack other players..GG...well..only time will tell
nani - eventhough many of u will still disagree with it..i still dont think the team can rely on him (yet?) ..always MIA when it matters the most (as usual)...zzz
berba - his '30mil' shot during the last few mins against arsenal makes me lol..who cares if he got nice touches when he cant even shoot..lol
yea..u might say when he and park came off the bench..our striking department look much 'sharper', for me..its more like arsenal are putting more men forwards and started to neglect their defensive department rather than our striking department turns 'sharper'
i wonder where's our midfield creativity goin to come from...and what will happen if rooney is injured...who's gonna drag the whole team up
It was an even contest I thought. They got their fair share of chances, so did we. Maybe our attacking side found more space in the end, but they didn't really found it easy either to breach us.
It was a bad shot by Berba, but he only got what, 15mins? Give him the whole game, he would contribute as much as the others if not more. I find your constant attack on Berba embarrassing for a so called fan.
It was a bad night by Giggsy, our creative outlet in that game.. the others played their part, and Giggsy didn't do his that night. Big deal. One bad game, and we have no creativity? Ando, Scholesy, and Carrick when he's in form do provide them.