I also just finished the game today (let's just say the during the last 3 days I didnt have much sleep or did productive work...)
Overall I enjoyed it really a lot, imported my old randomly-faced male Shepard from ME1, went my usual full Paragon way, no death on final mission (Gormaz Shepard leaves no men/woman/aliens/others behind!), showed the finger to TIM (now that was a last minute twist and buildup for ME3 that I enjoyed greatly) and blew up the space station (no compromise)
Lots of good:
- Seeing Wrexx headbutt the shitty krogan warchief in the first 30 seconds I see him again made me go "that's my boy!", he was definitely my favorite character in ME1
- New interesting characters:
Thane was very well written and interesting for someone who could just have been another "quiet ninja", showed lots of depth there and surprised me
Tali was awesomely cute and I am planning to replay ME1 just to not romance anyone to "save it" for Tali in ME2 (and save Rachi queen this time too...) Wish we could see her face though.
Miranda has an awesome ass and a body suit that shows it, I suspect Cerberus indoctrination tentative....
Hearing Mordin sing was actually pretty funny and I loved his general voice acting, totally fit the Solarian character of an "hamster on coffee" like the Yeoman says.
- Excellent universe continuation from ME1
Bioware did managed to keep me immersed in the same universe from ME1.
When I noticed that when I started the launcher of the game the first time, the noise the button did when I clicked it triggered automatically the "Mass Effect!!!" memories in my mind, I knew they didnt screw up
- Story was a bit stretched sometimes but overall good dialogs and lots and lots of random small bits to immerse you in the universe
- You mean I don't have to spend 5 minutes after each mission to omnigel all the crap I looted because it's so inferior to Spectre gear anyway?
I would have enjoyed a bit more variety maybe (like maybe 1-2 more models of each weapons maybe) but after using it the new inventory system was better than ME1.
Some bad
- Some new not so interesting characters or badly used previous ones
Zaeed was an ass actually
I felt Garrus was too little used for one of the main NPCs from ME1, he felt less involved or developer than some new NPC. They did evolve his character quite a lot though.
Jackson was like the Kaidan from ME1, random-human-dude#6785
Jack story was interesting but character quite a bit offputting, hard to like her really.
- Same ol' Bioware
Yep I prepare for that "suicide mission" for about 30-35 hours, then I end it up in 1 hour without really sweating or anything.
Building a climax is good, but you need to create something at the end of it that is worth the wait, even for these who prepared like mad
Last mission actually action felt a little bit underwhelming for me, and the last boss was bad in my opinion (lolterminator?)
- Influence from ME1 were actually very limited
Guess it was to not screw up people who didnt play ME1 but impact of what u did in ME1 was actually quite low
You speak to the council (which I saved) a whole 30 seconds, Anderson (which I choose) about 2 minutes, they never appear again
You are again a Spectre but almost nobody mention it or care
Liara (which was my romance choice in ME1) give me a kiss then ask me to be her delivery boy..... okayyyyy
See some buildup for ME3 though so wait and see
Now to replay ME1+ME2 to make my "perfect" walkthrough and wait for ME3.... which is a long way to go I think

Edit: I got carried away... long post...
This post has been edited by Gormaz: Aug 11 2010, 12:44 AM