Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )

Outline · [ Standard ] · Linear+

 change pickups, or buy new guitar?

views
     
TShanhanhan
post Nov 3 2007, 12:33 AM

(͡ ͡° ͜ つ ͡͡°)
******
Senior Member
1,205 posts

Joined: Oct 2006
From: Kuala Lumpur


oh and for amps right.. is LINE 6 Spider 3 good?
its selling for 400 only i think.
enteryourusername
post Nov 3 2007, 12:35 AM

entermyusername
******
Senior Member
1,000 posts

Joined: May 2007
From: KL


QUOTE(blacktrix @ Nov 2 2007, 11:44 PM)
Freakfingers have been pushing a 5150 for so long, hasn't he tongue.gif

I'm actually interested in the 5150, but then the Spider Valve came and the Ceriatone JCM800 is sooooooooooooooooo tempting!!!!!!
*
eh, how's ur so-called special deal on laney vc's huh..... brows.gif
no more news geh?
liew90kw
post Nov 3 2007, 01:33 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
239 posts

Joined: Oct 2007
From: Klang Valley.


QUOTE(freakfingers12 @ Nov 2 2007, 11:23 PM)
Why not get a new amp?If you have the cash to spare,then get a 5150.
*
I TOTALLY agree. The 5150 III is such a sexy amp. You can see it on EVH's guitars site.

Lol jk la, the pickups do matter, but as some other people(and me) have been saying, no matter what you do to the pickups, an SX is still an SX.

This post has been edited by liew90kw: Nov 3 2007, 01:34 AM
sean392
post Nov 3 2007, 02:19 AM

Hirano Aya-Tard
*******
Senior Member
6,339 posts

Joined: Jan 2003



QUOTE(hanhanhan @ Nov 3 2007, 12:33 AM)
oh and for amps right.. is LINE 6 Spider 3 good?
its selling for 400 only i think.
*
There are better choices, but they cost slightly more I guess. Its pretty hard to get good tones out of the Spider3 unless you spend hours on it. I'm no fan of it so I can't say much other than recommending you away from it.



QUOTE(liew90kw @ Nov 3 2007, 01:33 AM)
I TOTALLY agree. The 5150 III is such a sexy amp. You can see it on EVH's guitars site.

Lol jk la, the pickups do matter, but as some other people(and me) have been saying, no matter what you do to the pickups, an SX is still an SX.
*
And of what significance branding does to a guitars playability and tone? Sure, Gibson, PRS, ESP, Fender are "branded" because they produce stellar guitars, sure but for how much? You pay for what you get. Those brands use premium grade wood with strict quality control. If you're gonna recommend him to get a "better" guitar, you're probably going to tell a student who isn't making much even with part time jobs to get a probably 3000MYR and above guitar.

First thing first, are you skilled enough to own a "better" guitar, if your fingers can't keep up with your guitar, it doesn't matter if its a relic '59 Les Paul into a 87 JCM800 with a boat load of pedals, you're still gonna sound bad.

If you think installing pickups into an SX or a cheap guitar is not going to affect tone much, rest assured, many can prove you wrong easily. Cheap guitars come with poorly made pickups, meaning they either have too much or too little output, with poor to no wax potting and lousy note definition. How is that changing to better pickups will not change by a large margin?

Sure, body construction is also important for sustain, but don't forget even more expensive "budget" brands like Epiphone, LTD and etc don't utilize single piece bodies. Most of them use multiple pieces and glue them together to get a 2/3-piece body. So if thats the case, doesn't that beat the argument of "body construction?".

Woods are a different story, yes, I do agree, lower priced guitars tend to use wrong woods or very low grade woods. Thats why you test the guitar before buying. Also, doing some research before going out to spring your hard earned cash will also do you good. Its quite irrational not at least read up a little on details on something you're planning to spend a lot on.

I hate to, but I have to disagree with your statement. I do not think brand plays a very heavy role on what works.
enteryourusername
post Nov 3 2007, 02:48 AM

entermyusername
******
Senior Member
1,000 posts

Joined: May 2007
From: KL


some question here. my bro's sx lp is heavy as hell, n my epi lp is much lighter compare to his. his guitar made from mahogany, but dunno xxx or yyy mahogany. biggrin.gif

heavy = better? or otherwise?
blacktrix
post Nov 3 2007, 08:31 AM

Scott Pilgrim Vs The World!
Group Icon
VIP
13,063 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Toronto
Stop Worrying about an amp now..... just worry about the pickups!

And I tried the Laney....... Didn't like it..... tongue.gif

Oh, The Spider III, haven't tried it..... but tried the Spider II........ sounds like microchips.
nerd
post Nov 3 2007, 10:04 AM

another brick in the wall.
*******
Senior Member
3,373 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: My House



QUOTE(sean392 @ Nov 3 2007, 02:19 AM)
There are better choices, but they cost slightly more I guess. Its pretty hard to get good tones out of the Spider3  unless you spend hours on it. I'm no fan of it so I can't say much other than recommending you away from it.
And of what significance branding does to a guitars playability and tone? Sure, Gibson, PRS, ESP, Fender are "branded" because they produce stellar guitars, sure but for how much? You pay for what you get. Those brands use premium grade wood with strict quality control. If you're gonna recommend him to get a "better" guitar, you're probably going to tell a student who isn't making much even with part time jobs to get a probably 3000MYR and above guitar.

First thing first, are you skilled enough to own a "better" guitar, if your fingers can't keep up with your guitar, it doesn't matter if its a relic '59 Les Paul into a 87 JCM800 with a boat load of pedals, you're still gonna sound bad.

If you think installing pickups into an SX or a cheap guitar is not going to affect tone much, rest assured, many can prove you wrong easily. Cheap guitars come with poorly made pickups, meaning they either have too much or too little output, with poor to no wax potting and lousy note definition. How is that changing to better pickups will not change by a large margin?

Sure, body construction is also important for sustain, but don't forget even more expensive "budget" brands like Epiphone, LTD and etc don't utilize single piece bodies. Most of them use multiple pieces and glue them together to get a 2/3-piece body. So if thats the case, doesn't that beat the argument of "body construction?".

Woods are a different story, yes, I do agree, lower priced guitars tend to use wrong woods or very low grade woods. Thats why you test the guitar before buying. Also, doing some research before going out to spring your hard earned cash will also do you good. Its quite irrational not at least read up a little on details on something you're planning to spend a lot on.

I hate to, but I have to disagree with your statement. I do not think brand plays a very heavy role on what works.
*
Quoted for truth.

Putting Seymour Duncans on my sub-RM650 guitar worked wonders.

You pay for what you get -- that's the whole main point here. If somebody can afford a premium guitar, s/he would be going for it without much qualms. The key word here is, we CAN'T.

IF the pickups on branded guitars are so good, why do we still see people changing 'em?
liew90kw
post Nov 3 2007, 10:13 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
239 posts

Joined: Oct 2007
From: Klang Valley.


@sean ==> I'm not merely talking about the branding. It's true that testing a guitar before buying it is vital, but I feel the most important thing is a "connection", if you will, between the instrument and the owner. For example, when I bought my warlock, I was looking through all the other guitars at the store. All of them sounded great, but I didn't feel that "connection". They made an awesome sound, but that was about it.
Then I saw my warlock in a corner, beat up as it was, tried it, and bought it immediately. Haven't looked back since.
But it's always a matter of personal preference. I for one never really liked the tone of SX stuff. So to me, of course I would say change the guitar.

But honestly, man, active on a SX? Unless you're actively gigging I feel you should just stick with the stock pickups on the SX. han3, you already said you were gonna work part time and save up money right? Just do that, but save the money for a new guitar, just IMHO. Since you're still brushing off the dust and learning new tricks and licks, save up, and get a wicked new guitar when you get really good, and do yourself justice.

.....and I need to start making shorter posts.
Everdying
post Nov 3 2007, 10:56 AM

Two is One and One is None.
Group Icon
Staff
30,735 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
QUOTE(sean392 @ Nov 3 2007, 02:19 AM)
First thing first, are you skilled enough to own a "better" guitar, if your fingers can't keep up with your guitar, it doesn't matter if its a relic '59 Les Paul into a 87 JCM800 with a boat load of pedals, you're still gonna sound bad.
FLAME ON tongue.gif

dude this argument has gone on since before elvis presley came along.
thats why gibson in the 50s came along to offer quality stylish instruments to the mass public tongue.gif

and there is no rule that says you must reach a certain skill to own a certain guitar, this is not like bloody DOTA or whatever where u must level up to earn it.
so wat? must reach level666 godmode to earn a '59 LP?
oh man, in that case the guys in avenged sevenfold or even MCR have already reached very close to that level since they obviously arent using SX...damn what is the world coming to tongue.gif

yes, it may be irritating to you when someone who can only play MCR owns a AAAAA Flame top Gibson LP Custom Shop '57 VOS reissue with 100yr old Brazilian Rosewood fretboard...but then its their money.

ok, this post may get too long...so at the risk of reading this for longer than it takes for an avenged sevenfold guitar solo...i'll stop here for now tongue.gif
blacktrix
post Nov 3 2007, 10:56 AM

Scott Pilgrim Vs The World!
Group Icon
VIP
13,063 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Toronto
Well, to me, it doesn't matter what brand the guitar is or how expensive..... a good pick-up can really change the way a guitar can sound...... believe me, I know.

I installed a pair in my crappy LP-100 and it did wonders for the sound.
Dark Kai
post Nov 3 2007, 11:29 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
165 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Puchong


QUOTE(blacktrix @ Nov 3 2007, 10:56 AM)
Well, to me, it doesn't matter what brand the guitar is or how expensive..... a good pick-up can really change the way a guitar can sound...... believe me, I know.

I installed a pair in my crappy LP-100 and it did wonders for the sound.
*
To me the pickups will definitely be a great improvement.
And who cares if it's a Gibson or SX, its the playing that counts most in the end. cool2.gif
dilin
post Nov 3 2007, 11:31 AM

Casual
***
Junior Member
348 posts

Joined: Dec 2005
From: Kepong


Well, go ahead, buy a set and install it yourself. smile.gif I earned my Guitar Electronics 101 cert that way. biggrin.gif

If you're happy then we're happy!
sean392
post Nov 3 2007, 01:55 PM

Hirano Aya-Tard
*******
Senior Member
6,339 posts

Joined: Jan 2003



QUOTE(Everdying @ Nov 3 2007, 10:56 AM)
FLAME ON tongue.gif

dude this argument has gone on since before elvis presley came along.
thats why gibson in the 50s came along to offer quality stylish instruments to the mass public tongue.gif

and there is no rule that says you must reach a certain skill to own a certain guitar, this is not like bloody DOTA or whatever where u must level up to earn it.
so wat? must reach level666 godmode to earn a '59 LP?
oh man, in that case the guys in avenged sevenfold or even MCR have already reached very close to that level since they obviously arent using SX...damn what is the world coming to tongue.gif

yes, it may be irritating to you when someone who can only play MCR owns a AAAAA Flame top Gibson LP Custom Shop '57 VOS reissue with 100yr old Brazilian Rosewood fretboard...but then its their money.

ok, this post may get too long...so at the risk of reading this for longer than it takes for an avenged sevenfold guitar solo...i'll stop here for now tongue.gif
*
I know, but I'm talking about this case. Which he's just a student. So its not feasible aight?

QUOTE(liew90kw @ Nov 3 2007, 10:13 AM)
@sean ==> I'm not merely talking about the branding. It's true that testing a guitar before buying it is vital, but I feel the most important thing is a "connection", if you will, between the instrument and the owner. For example, when I bought my warlock, I was looking through all the other guitars at the store. All of them sounded great, but I didn't feel that "connection". They made an awesome sound, but that was about it.
Then I saw my warlock in a corner, beat up as it was, tried it, and bought it immediately. Haven't looked back since.
But it's always a matter of personal preference. I for one never really liked the tone of SX stuff. So to me, of course I would say change the guitar.

But honestly, man, active on a SX? Unless you're actively gigging I feel you should just stick with the stock pickups on the SX.  han3, you already said you were gonna work part time and save up money right? Just do that, but save the money for a new guitar, just IMHO. Since you're still brushing off the dust and learning new tricks and licks, save up, and get a wicked new guitar when you get really good, and do yourself justice.

.....and I need to start making shorter posts.
*
Actives sounds similar in most guitars that is made out of the same woods. Its actives, power > tone. At least thats how I hear active pickups. I'm not a huge fan of active pickups cause to me they sound harsh and tonally dull, but thats just me.

This post has been edited by sean392: Nov 3 2007, 01:57 PM
TShanhanhan
post Nov 3 2007, 10:43 PM

(͡ ͡° ͜ つ ͡͡°)
******
Senior Member
1,205 posts

Joined: Oct 2006
From: Kuala Lumpur


thanks for all ur comments......
i'll just earn up that 750 first.. then only decide whether to change the pickups.
right now i'll just concentrate on improving..
tropiccana
post Nov 4 2007, 09:31 PM

New Member
*
Junior Member
24 posts

Joined: May 2007
From: KL



go for it like i did! u will like it!
pickups are transferable! no worry dude!
freakfingers12
post Nov 6 2007, 01:03 PM

Honor thy father
*******
Senior Member
2,283 posts

Joined: Apr 2007


QUOTE(blacktrix @ Nov 2 2007, 11:44 PM)
Freakfingers have been pushing a 5150 for so long, hasn't he tongue.gif

I'm actually interested in the 5150, but then the Spider Valve came and the Ceriatone JCM800 is sooooooooooooooooo tempting!!!!!!
*
Lol,I love that skull crushing tone of 5150!Playing Necrophagist with that is extreme br00tal-ness
RustReaver4D1
post Nov 7 2007, 04:04 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,100 posts

Joined: Jan 2007


QUOTE(tropiccana @ Nov 4 2007, 09:31 PM)
go for it like i did! u will like it!
pickups are transferable! no worry dude!
*
TS: I think that's the bottomest of the bottomest bottom line: get kick-@ss pickups and load em up into your SX, coz the pickups are transferable.

Later if you save up money for a new guitar, chances are it won't be an ESP Custom Shop loaded with the dream pickups of your choice. (Unless you hit the jackpot.)

Chances are, you're next guitar will be better quality, but it may not come with the pickups that you like. So you may end up swapping pickups again then.

So if you think that EMGs are going to do it for your, get em now and when your next guitar comes along, pop em in there...

Are you sure that you want the EMG-ZW set in the first place? I bought that set pretty much on a whim but some days, that "character-less" sound kinda annoys me. The EMG-81 and EMG-85 are very high output pickups, and you may find that it makes your mistakes more apparent. That's not a bad thing overall because it'll force you to clean up your technique.. don't get me wrong, I'm not knocking your technique since I've never seen/heard you play, but it's easy to sound like a train-wreck when you're playing with high-output pickups. icon_rolleyes.gif

For RM750, you can take your pick of any 2 Seymour Duncan or Dimarzio pickups. You might want to scout around first before buying any pickups... thumbup.gif
crazychris
post Nov 7 2007, 10:02 PM

Bass!!!
******
Senior Member
1,399 posts

Joined: Sep 2004
From: KL PJ
if ur nex gita wud b in the range of 2-4k chances are u wil use the pups
if ur nex is a 6-10k range den they're oredi stock wit pups

like now...
im stuck wit the idea of changin pups or save up more for a better 2nd hand...
but of cz u can sell it wen u get 1 of the high range 1
but my fren is oredi stuck wit sellin his pups...

after he upgraded his JEM Jr wit 3x DiMarzios
suddenli a great deal of his dream gita appear
wit a very very gud price

now he owns the JS series
but the pups and gita stil nt yet sell out
he damn stress dy T-T


enteryourusername
post Nov 7 2007, 11:09 PM

entermyusername
******
Senior Member
1,000 posts

Joined: May 2007
From: KL


too bad he isnt selling the pups i'm aiming for. else might buy from him.
saw someone selling jb/jazz, but reserved. T_T

3 Pages < 1 2 3Top
 

Change to:
| Lo-Fi Version
0.0510sec    1.10    6 queries    GZIP Disabled
Time is now: 19th December 2025 - 07:27 PM