Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )

7 Pages < 1 2 3 4 > » Bottom

Outline · [ Standard ] · Linear+

 [BMW bang die moto] court case today, ppl hentam BMW driver & his father

views
     
mcchin
post May 12 2023, 01:05 PM

SLAVA UKRAINI !
*******
Senior Member
3,902 posts

Joined: Jul 2005
From: Sin Lor, B'worth,Pg.
QUOTE(ZforZebra @ May 12 2023, 12:58 PM)
oh hohoho u dont know alot malaysian's dont know white line = stop

i everyday have to pass by a t junction that has no "main" road.

all sides got a white line, but guess what.

those going straight ingat theyre on the main road, and have the right of way.

just jalan only. i am just waiting for 2 going "straight" people to clash only then see how they argue.

some not even slowing down to look at all.
*
Dashcam trumps all

QUOTE(iGamer @ May 12 2023, 12:58 PM)
Conclusion, both also wrong. But many emotional ktards die die wanna plotek TS title "innocent biker". I wonder if it's awek instead of amoi, will the replies be the same... innocent.gif
*
My own comments will be the sam
the proof is there
logic is there

why play on other sentiments? whistling.gif

QUOTE(mushigen @ May 12 2023, 01:00 PM)
Something is wrong about having the stop line (for BMW lane) here. Usually such stop line for traffic at major road exists only at junctions with traffic light. The vehicle from minor road must stop and yield.

Imagine you were driving there - are you really going to stop behind the white line? Conlanfirm kena butsek.
*
check back old street view

new road not same as pre 2018

QUOTE(iGamer @ May 12 2023, 01:01 PM)
The problem with those white line for main straight road is that road users unfamiliar with such road would most probably fail to slow down at the white line until too late.
*
that is not really a main road used by many
its just a wider new road that leads into taman

which one should not speed through
and definitely aware of surrounding more since higher chance of stray incidents happen
mcchin
post May 12 2023, 01:11 PM

SLAVA UKRAINI !
*******
Senior Member
3,902 posts

Joined: Jul 2005
From: Sin Lor, B'worth,Pg.
QUOTE(mushigen @ May 12 2023, 01:04 PM)
I'll play the devil's advocate.

Let's swap vehicle type: BMW the one exiting from the minor lane and moto was coming straight from major road.

Motor hits car and RIP. Who is wrong now?
*
if hit belakang BMW
moto wrong
cause that means BMW oredi enter the junction

if hit front fender means car wrong, cause the moto oredi enter junction



QUOTE(iGamer @ May 12 2023, 01:04 PM)
I will also honk 9 motobodo that came out of junction assuming the world revolves around them.
*
at least you have time to honk
this case maciam no contingency plan for the BMW jer
just power through

QUOTE(Human Nature @ May 12 2023, 01:05 PM)
I mean the lines in front of the 3 huge houses. Shouldnt it be a straight dashed line instead of following the contour of the curb. Anyway, what do I know. Maybe different codes.
*
here

user posted image

its actually a double line to prevent overtaking the middle like
but dashed for each house so they can cross to enter the home from the opposite lane


mcchin
post May 12 2023, 01:16 PM

SLAVA UKRAINI !
*******
Senior Member
3,902 posts

Joined: Jul 2005
From: Sin Lor, B'worth,Pg.
QUOTE(mushigen @ May 12 2023, 01:08 PM)
The one you posted is new view kan? Why talk about pre 2018 when the accident happened in 2023?

Don't you find the white stop line strange and not supposed to be there? Who's supposed to stop and who's supposed to have right of way if both junctions have stop lines and no traffic lights?
*
cause the main user is those 2 roads

the new one is not lead to any major road

plus the junction there changes from 2 lane to a single taman lane

so no issue with the markings

just a 3 ways stop

everyone that arrive to the junction should slow down ready to a stop, checking before continuing

just as the turn lane into Hillview
there is line
the cars are to slow down to check before turning

seems normal here cause you are slowing down cause of turning
so even when straight, where there is white line across you are to ready to stop when arrive to there
mcchin
post May 12 2023, 01:24 PM

SLAVA UKRAINI !
*******
Senior Member
3,902 posts

Joined: Jul 2005
From: Sin Lor, B'worth,Pg.
QUOTE(mushigen @ May 12 2023, 01:19 PM)
That white line means "get ready to stop" or "stop"? I never knew we have a "get ready to stop" white line.

And BMW was going straight, not turning kan,
*
cause entering taman road

its not a main road in the cctv view
mcchin
post May 12 2023, 01:37 PM

SLAVA UKRAINI !
*******
Senior Member
3,902 posts

Joined: Jul 2005
From: Sin Lor, B'worth,Pg.
QUOTE(mushigen @ May 12 2023, 01:35 PM)
Again, does that white line mean "stop" or "slow down" or "get ready to stop"?
*
That one ask jpj

I myself be careful

At least slow down ready to stop
But will I stop if not needed? whistling.gif

Who knows ?
mcchin
post May 12 2023, 01:40 PM

SLAVA UKRAINI !
*******
Senior Member
3,902 posts

Joined: Jul 2005
From: Sin Lor, B'worth,Pg.
QUOTE(Roman Catholic @ May 12 2023, 01:36 PM)
Very true but I can't as it's getting worse if you can only see what I see everyday.
When I drive I am always careful and give riders all the space  they need, so that not only me that reaches home safely but they too.

When I ride, the amount of stress is crazy. I have to anticipate every inconceivable damn stupid thing when others are around, so that hopefully I can go home in 1 piece.

If I can follow the rules when I am a driver, I don't see why others cannot ? Bloody ridiculous. This case will most likely be over even before it started and nothing will happen to the BMW driver. Cash is King. Nabeh.

If only this BMW had stopped where the line was, the lady would not be dead.
*
Fader powerful
Then maybe settled with family member

Further back the road bmw came from
Got powiis

Dunno got related bor whistling.gif

mcchin
post May 12 2023, 01:54 PM

SLAVA UKRAINI !
*******
Senior Member
3,902 posts

Joined: Jul 2005
From: Sin Lor, B'worth,Pg.
QUOTE(JohnL77 @ May 12 2023, 01:41 PM)
I said this in another thread, but ktards argued with me 10 pages that you don't need to stop if there's no oncoming traffic.
*
QUOTE(wdarke @ May 12 2023, 01:49 PM)
You must come to a full stop, whether there are other vehicles or not. 99% of Malaysians do not do that. When they see no incoming vehicles, they go d.
*
QUOTE(gaman @ May 12 2023, 01:50 PM)
Those fools are wrong. Try to do this overseas and see whether you would get a saman.

Fully stop is required to ensure that you pay full attention to observe any traffic on other roads, with or without traffic, for safety reason.
*
that said

in this case
the damage and injury would be miles less than it was, maybe could have been avoided all together
if only the BMW was able to slow down even not to a stop at the junction
mcchin
post May 12 2023, 01:54 PM

SLAVA UKRAINI !
*******
Senior Member
3,902 posts

Joined: Jul 2005
From: Sin Lor, B'worth,Pg.
QUOTE(Roman Catholic @ May 12 2023, 01:43 PM)
I read earlier posts got this word powiis, but what the hell is that ?
*
google lah

international school


mcchin
post May 12 2023, 01:58 PM

SLAVA UKRAINI !
*******
Senior Member
3,902 posts

Joined: Jul 2005
From: Sin Lor, B'worth,Pg.
QUOTE(ketupatjahat @ May 12 2023, 01:51 PM)
Thats the thing about malaysia road design...suka hati buat line jer but when accident then dunno who at fault
*
its a 3 way stop
nothing special about it

stop before the line before proceed

QUOTE(ketupatjahat @ May 12 2023, 01:54 PM)
Very confusing line. if everyone come to the junction and same time and stop then who go first?
*
down to who make the 1st move

at that time, the vehicle moving from standstill, even collided will be minor damage
mcchin
post May 12 2023, 02:13 PM

SLAVA UKRAINI !
*******
Senior Member
3,902 posts

Joined: Jul 2005
From: Sin Lor, B'worth,Pg.
QUOTE(doublecool @ May 12 2023, 01:56 PM)
car driver wrong, if he didn't stop at white line

but moto driver also wrong, cause she also need to stop at the junction to look right before turning out. no video to prove but i doubt she would turn out if she saw car speeding
*
QUOTE(karazure @ May 12 2023, 01:57 PM)
jgn buat bodo, dua dua ade isuue.

tak payah whitewash motobodo.

PS. bukan whitewaste la bangang, suru berlajar main lanjiao...ini la...
*
no proof say the moto no care the car

she might look, the car far away

then turn in, go in front of the CCTV house, around 10m then the BMW hit her

the Junction BMW to The impact around 15m

so the speed the car is going, it will look way back when the moto arrive at the junction

user posted image

This post has been edited by mcchin: May 12 2023, 02:18 PM
mcchin
post May 12 2023, 02:16 PM

SLAVA UKRAINI !
*******
Senior Member
3,902 posts

Joined: Jul 2005
From: Sin Lor, B'worth,Pg.
QUOTE(leymahn @ May 12 2023, 02:09 PM)
user posted image

got this from fb comments. very much confusing.
*
fail JPJ test is failed

what so confusing
see line stop laa

wat so hard about it?

malaysian driver like lembu kambing ayam jer

no lights, cannot use own brains to do stuff
always need others to suapkan
mcchin
post May 12 2023, 02:16 PM

SLAVA UKRAINI !
*******
Senior Member
3,902 posts

Joined: Jul 2005
From: Sin Lor, B'worth,Pg.
QUOTE(TanahGagal @ May 12 2023, 02:16 PM)
Manyak detectives in /k
*
forgot attached picture

user posted image

This post has been edited by mcchin: May 12 2023, 02:17 PM
mcchin
post May 12 2023, 03:43 PM

SLAVA UKRAINI !
*******
Senior Member
3,902 posts

Joined: Jul 2005
From: Sin Lor, B'worth,Pg.
QUOTE(ScooterBoi @ May 12 2023, 03:34 PM)
So the road was upgraded and the straight (main) road was extended. And yet, the stop lines were still maintain as it was before.

Just checked google street view. Looks like there's no warning sign that there's a junction ahead along the new widen stretch.

For sake of discussing what went wrong, motorists shouldn't be faulted if they didn't stop. They are on the straight main road, would be ridiculous to expect drivers to slam on the brakes when they saw the white line from a near short distance away.

For sake of the accident (and how the investigating officer would see it too), it is reckless driving.

Why? I have only see the photo of the point of accident (when the motorcyclist was hit) and not the video. Imho, the motorbike is already directly in front of the car. The car hit her directly from behind.

Ok. Not going to comment more as this will be a case in court.

Section 41, reckless driving causing death, at least 5k5y.
*
coming from a school area POWIIS, (not saying they are from there)
should a driver be more alert?

or izzit like singaporean
at home country kwai kwai chai, woff woff

but pass the imigresen, act like tought guy, speeding, throwing rubish etc

so the BMW drebar pass the school area, and though can speed through and through?
mcchin
post May 12 2023, 03:43 PM

SLAVA UKRAINI !
*******
Senior Member
3,902 posts

Joined: Jul 2005
From: Sin Lor, B'worth,Pg.
dbl posted,

This post has been edited by mcchin: May 12 2023, 03:43 PM
mcchin
post May 12 2023, 03:58 PM

SLAVA UKRAINI !
*******
Senior Member
3,902 posts

Joined: Jul 2005
From: Sin Lor, B'worth,Pg.
QUOTE(daniel2006 @ May 12 2023, 03:49 PM)
seems like the motor came out from junction without stoping.
just like that motor + truck in Telok Gong Klang a month ago.
*
how you know?

the brake line was way back
well out of CCTv view

you have special eye that can see something that is not there izzit?

QUOTE(hirano @ May 12 2023, 03:49 PM)
got someone i know who lives around there, mentioned about it.
*
well kes like this
like SKT case
some kids then claim she play with phone
but later when police ask those witness that please come forwards
then nobody came forward

not discounting your acquittance
but unless being reported by the news according to the police statements

it can be just a emotionally charged perceptions

QUOTE(mushigen @ May 12 2023, 03:49 PM)
That's mentioned by mcchin earlier. I told him normally such stop signs at all junctions are present only at junctions with traffic light, not this junction without traffic light. Takkan everyone stop and play scissors, paper, stone to see who moves first?

He said the solid line means slow down, to which I asked for confirmation (because I didn't know we have road marking like that which represents "slow down" instead of "stop") and then he asked me to ask JPJ pulak.
*
my grouse here is,

the BMW side have line but without the stop sign

so I cannot be sure what is proper here
the best is to stop

less, but better than the current is to slow down atleast
and this tragedy will no happen, or at least happens at a lesser extent

QUOTE(blanket84 @ May 12 2023, 03:52 PM)
How to race like that?
*
then it will be a class warfare
car vs moto

This post has been edited by mcchin: May 12 2023, 03:59 PM
mcchin
post May 12 2023, 04:01 PM

SLAVA UKRAINI !
*******
Senior Member
3,902 posts

Joined: Jul 2005
From: Sin Lor, B'worth,Pg.
QUOTE(JohnL77 @ May 12 2023, 04:00 PM)
If we compare with SKT case:

1. BMW cannot say night time very dark cannot see moto.

2. CCTV show BMW clearly speeding.

3. BMW cannot say moto not supposed to be on the road.

4. Moto wrong for not wearing helmet properly and maybe didn't ride properly, but if BMW didn't drive so fast, moto rider probably didn't die.
*
wanna add

5. Even if BMW have dashcam, it will show all his wrong doing

Checkmate!

mcchin
post May 12 2023, 06:02 PM

SLAVA UKRAINI !
*******
Senior Member
3,902 posts

Joined: Jul 2005
From: Sin Lor, B'worth,Pg.
QUOTE(loserguy @ May 12 2023, 04:44 PM)
user posted image

kek mcchin Roman Catholic iGamer

user posted image
*
i only comment on the logic and reasoning with proves
nothing more nothing less

QUOTE(knumskul @ May 12 2023, 05:07 PM)
It wasn't safe to enter the lane, not about who entered 1st. Still considered as 'sudden entering'.

If about who entered lane 1st, if I cross road on foot and car bang me is the car at fault? I fully entered the road already.

Regardless who is at fault, biker lost her life. Could've been prevented from both ends, especially the side which has higher risk of injury.
*
its akin to you crossing the street at zebra line
and car come barreling at 100kmph

so crossing the road takes around 5-6 strides, and 4 secs to cross
at the start of the 4 sec to cross, the car would be 50m away

thats like a olympic swimming pool away
of course when crossing, you can determine better

but as shown is gmaps, the distance from the stop line to the CCTV location is 10meters
with moto 15kmph @ 4m/s (average out from the stop to max 30kmph at impact)
the time to impact area is 2.5sec

at 2.5sec, the car was 70m away, 70m not enuff time to enter the road?
and some how you forget that moto is also part of a vehicle on the road

this is no different than a car driving past and hitting a moto on a straight road


QUOTE(iGamer @ May 12 2023, 05:08 PM)
Walaowei...... not sure how driving school teaches ppl nowadays, exiting junction properly is not just about whether you managed to fully exit, it's about you fully exit in a safe condition.

Getting hit upon fully exit is not how you supposed to do it. sweat.gif
*
see above



mcchin
post May 12 2023, 06:13 PM

SLAVA UKRAINI !
*******
Senior Member
3,902 posts

Joined: Jul 2005
From: Sin Lor, B'worth,Pg.
QUOTE(DeMoNBLooD24 @ May 12 2023, 05:49 PM)
what you say don't matter , because what happen is obviously the car did not stop and the people has died , u cant just say oh there's a white line and every car will stop automatically and i can just go out with a free of mind without looking anything coming or not that's just having the wrong mentality especially as a motorcyclist we have to be extra careful on the road because we are very vulnerable on the road..
*
when you say like that we're no better than animals

mcchin
post May 12 2023, 06:23 PM

SLAVA UKRAINI !
*******
Senior Member
3,902 posts

Joined: Jul 2005
From: Sin Lor, B'worth,Pg.
QUOTE(knumskul @ May 12 2023, 06:12 PM)
No need maths so much. If car has to brake for moto entering, it wasn't safe for moto to enter the lane.

Regardless who is at fault, who will kena kemek when shit happens?

Too many only look at who is right or wrong in eyes of the law, ignoring whether you'll be alive after the fact.
Now the moto lady cannot go pangsai ever again, does it matter if she is right? BMW driver can still pangsai in jail.
*
Kek bodoh lagi dengan otak nie

Not entering main road

It's a 3 way stop

All overlapping route shall stop before proceeding
mcchin
post May 12 2023, 06:48 PM

SLAVA UKRAINI !
*******
Senior Member
3,902 posts

Joined: Jul 2005
From: Sin Lor, B'worth,Pg.
QUOTE(knumskul @ May 12 2023, 06:32 PM)
Nobody stop, who pays the highest price? Metal box or skin and bones?

Bodo don't get the point.
*
Baik duk rumah dah
Tak yah keluar

Human are societal creature
What different is we creat laws and rules that most agree

What do done is done
But I don't go acting high and mighty that how the victim should or shouldn't do

I want justice only

At least I am here talking about what happen in a logically manner

While you pushing down your own egotistical idealistic crap on how it should been happen



QUOTE(talexeh @ May 12 2023, 06:33 PM)
Wait, he said he has just done teaching? He is a teacher at POWIIS is it?
*
Then kaya lor
International school not cheap leh 30k per year , last check in lyn comment

7 Pages < 1 2 3 4 > » Top
 

Change to:
| Lo-Fi Version
0.0675sec    0.90    7 queries    GZIP Disabled
Time is now: 1st December 2025 - 07:16 AM