Why you support the student ar?

Time has changed, Technology has changed.
Caring old method not applicable to Gen Z

in this case, teacher is too much to cane the student's body instead of palm.

I say both are sohai, teacher is to educate but not use excessive caning, student profession is to study but no study.

Both should kena buang sekolah.

if the ministry don't want to endorse, make sure release clear instruction no corporal punishment allowed.

Like I said, don't think this is called excessive caning la. If excessive, the skin would be even much worst than this.

I really sick with the comments like "Masa kecik-kecik kena rotan dengan cikgu, elok je jadi manusia".

It is not about whether the skin is torn = excessive. This is excessive force.

Canning anywhere besides the palm of the hand and buttocks, as per rules set out by MOE for canning discipline, is already excessive and illegal, exceeded the legal boundaries. If teacher don't follow rules, then what kind of message the teacher is sending to the students?

Why the palm of the hand? Have you seen those stings from jellyfish, the skin on the palm of a hand or sole of a foot is always under wear and regenerate, so the scar will go away sooner. For the rest of the skin on the body, the scar will remains for a very long time.

Why the buttocks? Because it is a part where it is covered all the time in public. So if there is a scar there, it won't affect the image/looks of a person. Also, there are cloth to "protect" the skin, so it will not be torn under excessive force. Canning the buttocks naked is also illegal.

If you daughter got permanent scars all around her because of a teacher's excessive canning, are you happy?

This post has been edited by RicoT: Jun 26 2019, 02:18 PM

basically the average quality of national citizens we got, they cant view the matter rationally, but emotionally

worst is relating the saying of "last time we all also kena caned la, now ok je"

the teacher has obviously lost it when he chose to cane at places other than palm n butt

y so many dont see the seriousness of this

Student is a person who is studying, doing something incorrect is normal.

I salute teachers who understood their profession well and be very patience in guiding students when they did something wrong, or be caring enough to understand why the student act in this manner, but I despise teacher who think violence is the only way to teach. Canning is usually reserved to discipline master, in my secondary school, teachers don't bring rotan into class anymore like primary school.

Those who think last time they were caned and it is normal, they are stuck in the past and never thought to improve the situation. So if they are born into a poor family, they should forever be poor since it is normal to them.

kids nowadays strawberry. Kena rotan sikit, make viral whole malaysia.

canning ok, but dera tak ok.
disrespect teacher, not ok...

this is not a yes or no situation.

after i see the photo, tak macam rotan sikit. so i wondering what is the teacher thinking when rotan her.

exactly, isn't this alarming and saddening

no wonder most of our people still play with R&R everyday coz they cant think n evaluate things logically n rationally, easily manipulated with uncontrollable emotions

Legit counselling is very important

Looking at the number and location of caning scar, it doesn't looks like the teacher is caning to teach a lesson. It looks more like a revenge caning.

I totally agree that the caning should be carried out, but should be done properly. This looks like wild swinging caning. The scar is in 3 distinct different places. Imagine you taking a wild swing.

If i were the parent, i will go to school amd thank the teacher to help me teach kids some manners.

This generation nowadays is all about entitlement and how the society or world owes you ...bla bla bla

obviously it is not rotan sikit

the teacher has obviously lost his shit in order to cane student like this

it is like expressing his outrage by abusing his power

That’s right, I agree with you.

TS too emotional and bias towards teacher from the get-go. TS useless char siew too.

Imagin you being called pondan in front of whole class

sokong cikgu. padan muka. cikgu tu kena hormat. ni buat cikgu macam tahi. mmg patut la

Clearly you don't have the EQ to handle this, much less to become a teacher.