Alright
Fair enough

So your are saying for example one of your portfolio is down 5% while the other is down 10%


It still does not address the main issue at least for the most aggressive portfolio when it has mispricing.

If Wahed is indeed better I don't mind recommending it too but till today no one has addressed this issue other than saying the price will ultimately converge with NAV which it hasn't for the past few weeks

"Platform result of your own portfolio that started together and one is having a +5% and the other is -22%"
that is a returns variance of 27% .
mind sharing?......

are they of almost similar risk level selection or are having almost similar FI:EQ ratio?
do you do any top up to just 1 of them only?
or top up both of them but on different time?
or top up both of them at the same time but at a huge amount variance in ratio?

if both are the same to the above questions, then mind sharing?
what is "the exact date" that you entered both the platform?
(this would be useful for non believers of your postings to email to the respective platforms for "investment since then result" confirmation purposes if needed."

problem with wahed is everyone complained about long time to withdraw..took more than 10 days and some dissapear.

Yes based on the NAV for their Very Aggressive portfolio

No real pure comparison as they have chosen at least 12.5% in FI even for their most aggressive port

The issue which is yet to be solved is can anyone really sell their portfolio at the price Wahed quotes since their main ETF I have seen has 10 cent bid ask spread

Yes. Withdraw everything. Put in FD or Malaysian glove counters

I'm still using SAMY. Having 2 portfolios with them now: SRI36, customized China-centric portfolio. Both consistent DCA since opening. SRI36 is at 40.26% MWR, customized portfolio is at 20.14% MWR.