I'm considering between 2.0L CR-V, 2.0GL CX-5 and 2.0L X-Trail. Which is a better SUV?

depends on what is the purpose of the SUV for you?

general use.

The X-trail gets my vote because it is a 7-seater and it is the cheapest.
It is like an Suv+Mpv 2in1 combo package

Between the CR-V and the CX-5, the CX-5 seems superior in almost every aspect.
Honda is plagued with quality issues and killer airbags.

I would choose X-trail too. It seem much practical than CRV and CX-5.

CR-V and CX-5 would be just the aesthetic purpose rather than practical...

Subaru Forester might be a good choice too. Price around RM130k

Have you test drive all 3 (or 4)? I have and for me the Xtrail 2.0 seems under powered. The engine sounds quite loud and yet no pickup.

Forester FTW

Actually CR-V is more practical than X-trail. It has larger rear opening to store or retrieve large items.

The only pros for X-trail is the extra 2 seats for midgets/children & it is cheaper now.

CX-5 wins in terms of refinement however lacks of space.

C-RV is an all-rounder if not plague by QC issues

I agree. The only thing forester lacks is boot space.

my sis own x trail.
I personally don't like it and will never recommend to have it.

my vote go for Mazda.

The World first X2, not really expensive actually but it beats all of the above in branding & handling.

cx5-

y u no poll... How la pipu vote...

Never tried the CX-5.

I'd go with the CRV simply because it has a Turbo engine, LED lights and fairly nice interior (except the gear lever).

Speaking from an owner's perspective, I really like the X-Trail (2.0L version). It's not fast off the line, but as far as I can tell it's mostly because Nissan programmed it to be as smooth as possible. Cornering wise it is also pretty stable and fun. It struggles slightly going up hills but otherwise power is adequate. You're not supposed to speed in an SUV anyway given its high CG.

Edit: The X-trail's engine is much quieter than the CRV's. I'm not referring to the turbo whistle.

This post has been edited by TDUEnthusiast: Apr 8 2018, 02:42 PM

x-trail can throw in garbage dump. Problematic car. Be prepare for gearbox failure.

I have tested all 3 cars but Honda only have the 1.5 turbo for test drive so I can't really compared them. During X-Trial test drive, I did noticed a little slow in response/pickup during acceleration but I thought it it could be due to my driving style.

How long have you have you car? Can you share more on your X-Trial experience on
(1) handling
(2) workmanship
(3) comfort
(4) maintenance
(5) comfort
(6) after sales service
(7) reliability
(8) NVH

price is secondary to me.

Does CR-V manufactured in 2018 share the same QC issues?

Sorry, I don't know how to do polling?

This is serious. Does this happen to those manufactured in 2018 too?

Killer airbags ? You means TAKATA airbags ? Not only Honda use this. For quality issues is varies but do we want to compare Honda with Volvo/Mercedes ?

Xtrail got problem meh? Been driving a 2.5 since 2015.. no problem pun..

Not sure bout 2.0.. but the 2.5 is definitely not under power

Xtrail rebate 12k for the aero package with nappa leather.

Price is secondary to me, more importantly is its quality, after sales service, handling, power for overtaking, NVH, comfy etc.

Then is it obvious..cx5

What about CR-V? Is the 2.0 underpowered?

The CRV 1.5 T is my vote.

My opinion.

The CX-5 loses out on space but its a better drive.
The Xtrail is practicle as its huge. The 2.5 is powerfull and now got super discount, really poisonous.
The CRV sits in between.

Dont forget to just go try these other vehicles.
Renault Koleos
Hyundai Tuscon
Kia Sportage

NOTE : The CX 5 has a Diesel in Malaysia. Mileage must be awesome...

This post has been edited by Hades76: Apr 9 2018, 10:25 AM

1. CRV
2. CX 5 Diesel.

I am only considering 2.0L models between CR-V, CX-5 and X-Trail. What would be your recommendation?

Does 2.0L CR-V manufactured in 2018 have QC issues?

X-Trail only 2 airbag = cannot accept

CX-5 very nice, but the top 2 spec model is DIESEL. Also the GPS is not as functional as CRV.

CRV, perform its function (as an SUV) very well, support android Auto (i like it), no auto folding side mirror, no active noise cancelling for the cabin (overseas model has it), no handsfree boot door opening system (overseas has), no seat memory function (overseas has).

For 2018 model? With this aggressive rebate, is the new model coming out any time soon?

You're only looking at the low spec ~ 140k ish model then?

Get the CX5

Xtrail susah sell.

Its an SUV, a family car.

but only 2 airbag? They wan ppl's family to die ah?

I have not heard any major QC issues from the CRV. Takata airbag, well even now Toyota is having a recall. However do take note that the CRV 1.5T is selling better than the 2.0. So which means later on second hand value also will be better for the 1.5T.

The base 1.5T also has slightly better trim.

Looks like you are playing the 140K range. The 1.5 T is 155K.

The new Xtrail red ( i think its 144K ) is a very tempting offer. But its red. Hope its not like the Mazda red whereby you cant repaint it back. The Mazda red is so special that you cant get back the same red as factory.

there are also tucson , peugeot 3008 , subaru forester .

Close eyes, go for CRV considering its price, performance and RV

Got the 2018 2.0 CRV for 140k since January for the specs, SPACE, comfort and reliability.

No major issues so far except the occasionally rattle here and there. FC is not great and avg about 10KM/L for city and highway but adequate power for family use. Front looks good and back looks are subjective...

CX5 2.0 GL has poor specs - and no LED lights and no leather seats which is a must for me. Handles better than the CRV and looks good.

X trail 2.0 - super dated interior and lousy specs with 2 airbags only! Under powered when i tested it. Unless you take the 2.5 but thats another grade altogether...

I personally like the Forester 2.0iP also but wife didn't approve lol

Just my 2 cents, hope you find what you like soon

No idea about the new one, but the previous ver is under-powered and I could felt the bad engine vibration.

No idea....saw the ad from mudah that TCM is giving 12K for Xtrail.

I am looking for a SUV hence am exploring. I guess I will go with the CX5.

how about exploring the new Mitsubishi Outlander 2.0?
if not enough power can opt for 2.4 version.
7 airbags, 4wd, rock solid, 7 seater, larger boot space, better handling compared with xtrail.

As a 7-seater SUV, it should come at least with rear air-cond vent, or better still with 3rd row a/c vent too like Sorento,etc.
But it only has front a/c vents and the 2.0 is under powered.
Did not try the 2.4 version though.

The interior is very dated too. Seems like I’m stepping in to my previous Lancer GT from 2008.

Recently i saw a xtrail 2.0l 2015 sell at 86k..is it worth?

I have the current 2nd gen CX-5 2.5L and I do not regret the purchase..build quality is higher than both CR-V and X-trail..after sales service is so-so, my previous Honda CR-V service also similar...handling is good, feels like driving a sedan...power for 2.5L is good, century sprint in 8-ish seconds and good mid range torque..NVH and comfort level is levels above the 1st gen CX-5, which speaks volumes for itself..the - point for the CX-5 is that the suspension/absorber has a high fault rate, I had my strut bearings changed within a month of ownership...last point - the X-trail has only 2 air bags for both 2.0 and 2.5 variants, why even consider that?

what about kia sorento? 7 seater with a lot of gadgets. 2.2 CRDI now got promo at 170k iinm

Thanks for the feedback and enjoy your new ride.

Am surprised that the suspension parts are more prone to damage you mean? Strut bearings are defective or damage?

Yours FC kinda high.

I notice my wife's on 13.7KM/L on her 1.5T-P

This post has been edited by MeToo: Apr 10 2018, 04:44 PM

What do you mean by "the X-trail has only 2 air bags for both 2.0 and 2.5 variants, why even consider that"?

if just looking at a/c vents and dated interior, yes its not the best. But u overlooked the extra value in 2.4 version which sells for 155k included 4wd, extra 2seats, extra 1airbag, led headlamp, powered tailgate, bigger boots. the build quality of Mitsubishi chasis and parts is much better compared to cx5 and crv. just the fc is higher than both but u get all terrain suv and safe suv to transport your family.

Yeah, and thats with a very light-footed driving style!

Should have bought the 1.5T, save on the road tax and petrol to pay higher for the instalments.

Hope after the 10k service, the FC will improve a bit....

How old is this generation of Outlander? I notice there is a RM13k discount currently hence I suspect a facelift or new model coming out soon?
If not that it make a compelling case against CRV and CX5

erm...cx-5 2.2d also has turbo engine...and led lights...and premium interior

CX5 got turbo engine?

just simple gugle will answer

https://www.autocar.co.uk/car-review/mazda/...v-d-2017-review

the current outlander is the new facelift with dynamic shield face. the 13k discount applicable to 2.4 CBU Japan stocks only. so after discount will cost RM160k+. that CBU model is even more solid and quiet. u can observe the key welding points between ckd and cbu. the suv also have high ground cleareance but low center gravity for all terrain and curising on highways. the 2.0 is underpowered.

if looking for premium suv, mazda cx5 2.5 is good buy.
if looking for value for money family suv, the outlander 2.0 is good buy.
if looking for all round including fc n resale value, the crv 1.5t is good buy.
if looking for used suv, x-trail is good buy.

please try the Mitsubishi Outlander 2.4 CBU version and review here with other three choices.

X trail for 7 seater and 360 camera view angle.
Crv for their Honda sensing tech which is fking amazing.
Cx 5 only drove once. Too small for my opinion. Rest I forgot

yes.. mazda may not be premium nor luxury brand . its only the new gen of cx5 have premium looks , have conti handling and premium interior which the other similar price brands dont offer. its like a baby cx9.

CRV looks like one you're driving to pasar malam to buy groceries and pick up the kids at school whereas CX5 looks like one you will be driving to a 5-star hotel to pick up guests.

This i have to agree lol. Outlook wise, my 2 cent goes to cx5 for the premium feel.

Thanks! The strut bearings were defective right from the start, and not only myself but others are facing the same problem as well..the good news is that no issue after the replacement change

In other words, do not even consider the X-trail as it has only 2 airbags for both their variants. Compare that to e.g. CR-V or CX-5 which has 6 airbags, which one better? Specs list can be found here - http://www.nissan.com.my/vehicles/x-trail/prices

I just bought CRV 1.5 TC 2WD. Love it so much! you tint windows all black black and damn good it looks. Performance wise, for me, such a big car and it's easy to handle. the pick-up also good. Boot so large! No regrets buying this car.

Hi, how is the road or tyre noise when cruising on highway? Is it bumpy at the back passenger seat when crossing road bumps?

my tyre is toyo, it's not too noisy but still can hear la. Back no bumpy....it's comfy.

Looking for any Mazda can PM me for more information.

CRV

Thank you all for the valuable feedback and recommendation.