QUOTE(Lego Warfare @ Jul 13 2020, 06:19 PM)
If you only use them for streaming then not necessary to replace your Apple TV. Only if you watch local content then it is a good choice with all their lossless audio + DV passthrough.
Few months ago Nvidia said they were in talks with Apple to bring their Apple+ to their Shield, if that happens then there isn't much reason to stick with Apple TV box lol.
I mostly use for local content and Apple TV 4K did a brilliant job.
Too many people though Apple is more in stream and strict control on local content.
Frank speak this is not the case, Apple had freaking well support on local content.
I had 3000+ local films and 99% most of my 4K HDR collection is REMUX copy and Apple TV 4K never fail me at all.
It support full lossless track by direct playback all track in multi channel PCM format, this is good as you no need to worried your sound system support or not all the format, you just need to ensure your system support multi channel PCM format. This help for DTS-HD as my Soundbar not support it, but due to Apple auto render to Multi-channel PCM, this make me no worried on DTS-HD track.
Ya you do miss the Atmos because now Apple only support Atmos in DD+ but not Atmos in TrueHD but this is not very huge differences as I had personally compare with original 4K UHD blu-ray which run as Atmos, and frank speak it is not very big differences at all.
That the reason I don't find the need of replace it because Apple TV 4K also support Lossless track pass through as well as nearly all type of HDR passthru, this include HDR10, Dolby Vision and also HLG HDR.
You talk on Dolby Vision passthru for local content? Nearly 100% local content is not Dolby Vision but only HDR10 because Dolby Vision unable to remux out, you need a full 4K UHD blu-ray for Dolby Vision and not much people doing this.
Also I find Dolby Vision is not that big differences as well, thanks to LG's own proprietary HDR solution which process HDR signal dynamically frame by frame using enhanced dynamic tone mapping. This process make the normal HDR and Dolby Vision basically no different. I had compare it as well and I can't notice the different. Dolby Vision in LG OLED Cinema mode do far darker than normal HDR Cinema mode which is not my liking, thanks to LG give alternate option where once you change LG OLED of Dolby Vision to Home Cinema instead of Cinema, it is like exactly LG OLED of HDR in Cinema mode.
Now the only issue is I don't have any device capable to smoothly playback the only 8K HDR film I have, it is a documentary call "Wunderkammer: World of Wonder", probably my next TV Box will be need to support 8K HDR playback. Haha!
I will buy the Nvidia Shield if this TV Box can playback 8K HDR film as currently my Apple TV 4K only manage to playback around 12 mins but then it will crash! Haha! My few years ago Core i7 with Nvidia Geforce GTX-970M laptop is playing the film like 5 fps. My LG C9 direct connect the HDD is unplayable, it said format not support.

This post has been edited by Andrewtst: Jul 13 2020, 08:21 PM