Most probably we could ask the players themselves? I thought the nominations came from the players? And they themselves voted? I understand how important are Carragher and Terry to their respective clubs. As I'm not saying that both of them are not good. Most probably that Carra was overlooked or something. I'm not taking anyone's side or being biased towards my favourite team. But to be honest, I found that the partnership between Rio and Vida has been fantastic throughout the season. Our team conceded less goals when they were around and Vida scored a few important goals in UCL and Premiership. And not to forget that goal scored by Rio when playing Liverpool at OT. Maybe, because of this Vida and Rio was nominated. Frankly saying, Terry was out injured for quite a long time. How is he going to get nominated by warming up the bench and how fair is that if he's being nominated instead of Sol Campbell or maybe Carragher himself?

No offense to both of you, Duke Red and bwan. 8 players came out from Man Utd, well can we just discuss(rationally) whether these 8 players really deserved the nominations or not?