You go on the assumption that the realised investment income and cost is the only thing to consider.
As I mentioned many times on this thread (but usually ignored), there's a "hidden" profit/loss that FP funds also has to consider. The capital gains/losses. The buffer has to take into consideration the losses sustained from holding the shares/investments. For example one of the major holding for most ASx funds is Maybank shares. If you see the share price as at 31/12/2016, it was RM8.20 per share; in the previous year end 31/12/2015, it was RM8.40 per share. What the profit show would be the dividend income received; but it doesn't take into consideration the RM0.20 per share of capital loss year-on-year
Therefore they usually cannot declare too much as they need to cover the capital fluctuations; and some bad years, need to still maintain certain % of dividend above FD rate to avoid bank run. If I remember correctly ASB did declare more dividend than profits in 2015
Auditor is E&Y. Actually I don't think your AA or BB is that relevant. As demonstrated above, the reserves need to be used to cover capital losses (if any). If I draw parallel to Tabung Haji, their capital loss on investments as at 31/12/2016 amounted to RM4.5b. But PNB is smarter, they don't have to show the unrealised losses because the published financial statements do not have balance sheet.
Now, WHY there's no balance sheet? That's a question you should be asking yourself
If you go CIMB or pub mut MY large cap and islamic funds it'll be the same. The problem is the underlying holdings
You know what is the most ironic thing I noticed? On 31/8 everyone is cursing why 6% so low terrible Wahid
Today few pages on top up good news. So who's to blame for low dividends?
Well nicely said. As much as me being a small potato only, i believe ASx is a "safer" alternative compared to other investment vehicles... i always see ppl complaining bout the low returns, if so, he/she can always opt for other alternatives which bears more fruit but with higher risk, else just stick to FD, which in return offers much lower returns... despite only 6% being declared, i am "ok" with it, rather than having park in fd, or other riskier investments