QUOTE(cherroy @ Jan 26 2017, 09:47 AM)
A reminder, as well as to all forumers
It is a misleading statement to label final projection figure as "definitely higher than FD" when the investment projection final figure has non-guaranteed portion of return.
Apart from the guaranteed portion of return, other non-guaranteed will remain as non-guaranteed, nobody can say those return is "definite" better than FD.
Any insurance company out there, if they are not aiming for growth at all every year and just maintain measly on the worst performance year to year in this case Scenario 2, would be better off close shop and be better off to become a bank and just collect FD and give out housing loan which gives them 4.4% interest rate return on a daily rest.
You should also look into aspect that insurance companies hire qualified fund managers to make sure they know what they are doing to make the necessary funds grow and gain profit for the company.
The point is, the sales illustration is just a projection and it's also depending on the funds that the policy holder chooses to invest, if they are expecting a higher return and are able to handle risk, then they can go for high risk funds.
If they are low risk takers, there are always bond funds that they can choose from.
The illustration will project accordingly to the different funds that a policy holder chooses.
You are right to say there is no "definite" but it's will be better off than FD with the element of investment involved rather than a fixed amount paid off by the bank. Unless you're saying even with Bond Funds + guaranteed return portion from the insurance company is still worse off than FD, I rest my case.
I forgot to add in a point whereby the main disadvantage for these kind of saving plans compared to FD would be the long holding period but as I said if the main purpose of the savings is part of the retirement money or children education then it makes sense, however if you're planning to use the money in the next 3 to 5 years then you will definitely lose money. An endowment plan is whereby you save for a period of time and expect to get certain form of return as part of an interest, which you have the choice to not take it and continue to let it roll and allow the insurance company to grow the money for you.
This post has been edited by lifebalance: Jan 26 2017, 10:19 AM