QUOTE(cherroy @ Oct 17 2007, 02:25 PM)
I think what he/she tries to say is that:
PM is good, no doubt about that, but it doesn't mean all the funds under them is top performance in their category, some others investment house also got good top performance fund as well, so it doesn't mean when want to invest in UT, it must be or must choose PM, can as well others fund like OSK-UOB, CIMB, Hwang etc which some of their funds are as good, especially in global fund, PM or PB series funds are lagging others.
Don't get me wrong, PM or PB series funds are good in general term, just one always can broaden their view and options when want to invest in UT.
I'm not saying that people should stick ONLY with PM, don't get me wrong bro..PM is good, no doubt about that, but it doesn't mean all the funds under them is top performance in their category, some others investment house also got good top performance fund as well, so it doesn't mean when want to invest in UT, it must be or must choose PM, can as well others fund like OSK-UOB, CIMB, Hwang etc which some of their funds are as good, especially in global fund, PM or PB series funds are lagging others.
Don't get me wrong, PM or PB series funds are good in general term, just one always can broaden their view and options when want to invest in UT.
I believe non of my posts asked people not to choose other fund managers but only PM..
I'm just saying through what other forumers and I have experienced with PM funds, not just by rumours..
I'm just asking him for clarification, since he's saying he's not getting satisfactory returns..
If what he says is really true, then I could learn something too right..?
Cheers bro..
QUOTE(bengang13 @ Oct 18 2007, 09:30 PM)
I've got Small Cap, Ittikal, Focus Select and Islamic Equity.
Just a brief one here. Over all, i started investing year 2003 and i have profited about 56% since then. So about 14% anually. Is that much? I really don't know( I mean, i really do not know...not to be sarcastic here..what do you think?)
Perhaps i should not say overrated. it just that there are quiet a lots of funds outside there and people seems to be focusing just on PB. don;t get me wrong, i htink they are good, just that i believe we need to diiversify to other funds.
Just a brief one here. Over all, i started investing year 2003 and i have profited about 56% since then. So about 14% anually. Is that much? I really don't know( I mean, i really do not know...not to be sarcastic here..what do you think?)
Perhaps i should not say overrated. it just that there are quiet a lots of funds outside there and people seems to be focusing just on PB. don;t get me wrong, i htink they are good, just that i believe we need to diiversify to other funds.
QUOTE
PSMALLCAP (02-Jan-04 to 18-Oct-07) - 110.66%
PITTIKAL (Same period) - 98.85%
PIEF (Same period) - 94.88%
PFSF (25-Nov-04 to 18-Oct-07) - 78.82%
PSMALLCAP (02-Jan-04 to 18-Oct-07) - 174.29%
PITTIKAL (Same period) - 155.50%
PIEF (Same period) - 124.52%
*Data collected from PM website
Based on what I can see, if you invested anytime between 02-Jan-03 and 02-Jan-04 until 18-Oct-07, your average profit should be at least 95.80% (annualised 23.95%)..PITTIKAL (Same period) - 98.85%
PIEF (Same period) - 94.88%
PFSF (25-Nov-04 to 18-Oct-07) - 78.82%
PSMALLCAP (02-Jan-04 to 18-Oct-07) - 174.29%
PITTIKAL (Same period) - 155.50%
PIEF (Same period) - 124.52%
*Data collected from PM website
How come you're saying that you have only profited about 56%..?
I don't quite understand, unless PM did something on the charts to make their funds look better..
Even by looking at Lipper, you'll see these funds growing more than 50% on average for the last 3 years..
Have you still been keeping these funds, or did you redeem early..?
I'm not to say that you're wrong, but did you miss out something in your calculation..?
Did you include the distributions/splits by these funds (they have announced a few distributions already)..
Oct 19 2007, 06:40 PM
Quote
0.0218sec
0.70
7 queries
GZIP Disabled