QUOTE(hestati @ May 19 2018, 05:08 AM)
Just few points, I never mentioned that Fresca as a system is NSF certified, but all components are NSF certified.
But NSF certification doesn't tell you much if you don't know what filter can or can't do. For instance, take Easy Complete by 3M, good system, NSF and all, but it doesn't filter bacteria. Take Aquaphor, no NSF, but it does filter bacteria.
And NSF, while it's pretty much the only reputable certification out there, it's not perfect. Problem is that NSF is not quality control system. I always repeat the same story of RO tank we tried to manufacture in China for the previous company I worked for. We got it NSF certified, however some batches of the tank were giving terrible smell to water. We narrowed it down to raw material variances and pulled out of China completely, but if company hadn't decide to do so, who knows how quickly NSF would catch it? Maybe never.
For the independent test, yes it can be done, but here's the issue: what kind of input water to consider? Regular tap water? Not the best idea. Test for every contaminant? Ok, can be done, this is what is done in California, but it's costly, especially if done for many systems. I guess what I can do is to contaminate water with bacteria, lead, cyst, chlorine and pass through various filters, compare the result. But even then, this is when they are new, what happens after 6 months of usage, repeat the test?
P.S. the guide will not tell whether to choose Aquaphor or 3M, it will help to choose between say RO system or UF system, assuming that both systems are made of good components. Meaning it will tell the difference within classes of systems rather than brands.
Exactly my point, you can't state that Fresca is NSF certified, but all the components are.
All will be back to the purpose of the water filter, what is the main purpose, if it is only to filter the sediment or rust from the water source, then I believe the sediment filter on the POE is enough.
For me, the main purpose is, I want to drink straight from the tap, and my setup is having 3M AP902 as POE and Espring as POU. This is the only way I can skip the boiling and confident enough to drink from the Espring faucet directly. This is the best setup out there available from 3-4 years ago, because I also learn this from this exact thread 4 years ago.
If you ask me, is this actually safe, I don't know, I blindly trust the NSF certified 3M AP902 and Espring. However I never had my water tested, whether it is safe to drink or not, is there anyway to test the quality of the water coming out from the Espring faucet?
And you could also compare the quality of the water of the direct boiling, I believe this will be a very convincing way to prove that water filter is indeed important and which water filter is actually doing what they are supposed to do.