QUOTE(Icetea87 @ Aug 13 2014, 12:03 PM)
Here is my review for cvt transmission, i have been using it for 2.5 years. Car model saga flx 1.3.
- smoot ride, reads no 'push back' feeling when accelerate. When trying to overtake, you press down the gas pedal, rpm shoot up, maintain at 4k rpm but car speed climb too slowly.
Power delivery was delayed for at least 2-3 seconds. Solution , switch to sat mode when driving in highway. Town drving in d mode.
- good for hill climb. Can maintain speed when climbing up hill but engine sound will be rough and harsh due to high rpm while climbing hill. Solution. Insullate the car with sound deadening material , but it is a saga so meh....
- jerky in the morning, traffic jam. Solution , let go brake, let the gearbox do the work, once u feel the car is rolling only you can start giving some gas. Or else it will jerk. Rubber band effect is strong there.
- fuel saving ? Not really. 11-12l per km for a small car.
You can argue that is driver issue or traffic condition but for me this fuel consumption figure is alright but can be better.
I test drove the old sylphy n inspira. The rubber band effect is there. Maybe cvt is not for me but i just going to make use of what i have for now. I have yet to test drive the new city.
1) I don't think power delivery is that slow...it's just perception, more likely like 0.5 to 1 second. For my Inspira...going from 120km - 160km/h is really fast...My City also accelerate pretty fast. No complains at all...its more engine issue than CVT characteristic.
2) Engine rough sound - Again Engine issue....not CVT.
3) Jerkiness - This might be Punch CVT issue or need tuning....doesn't experience any jerkiness with Inspira or City.
4) FC - The gearbox can only do so much, if stuck in jam, any car also die....but Campro engine is known fuel sucker. However, if you put CVT in the similar cars, you can get better FC...ex: City vs VIOS vs Almera....City winrar in FC, as proven in PaulTan's test. All 1.5L engine, not the latest engines...VIOS especially ancient...LOL.
I think most of the things you highlight is an Engine issue rather than typical CVT characteristic for fair comparison.
This post has been edited by Matrix: Aug 13 2014, 12:38 PM