QUOTE(RedBox @ Jan 9 2007, 01:47 PM)
Don't believe your vet. Your dog seems naughty or stubborn because he does not know how to behave yet. You have to teach him. Hitting should never be a last option or resort. IT SHOULD NEVER BE AN OPTION.
Think... A person who speaks a foreign language comes up to you and start shouting at you. When you don't understand, he gets angry and starts hitting you. Do you think you will understand better what he is saying then? NO. Of course not.
Pennywise, here is what I have posted before on teaching proper eliminating to your dog. Hope you find it useful.
Hey there, thanks a lot, your post have been helpful. The scenario of someone speaking a foreign language with me then beats me up when I dont understand really help applies more patience in me. I will keep in mind that I will not understand better even if with aggression.
QUOTE(ihawk98 @ Jan 9 2007, 02:46 PM)
I dunno whether it is the best lah but will use it as long as my dog likes it. Housebreaking was a "little" easier for us as we got him when he was 5 months old. The breeder must have taught him because all we did from day 1 was feed him, then carry him to the toilet (where we put newspaper on the floor), go in with him, close the door and said "pee pee" "poo poo" and never opened the door until he did his business (we are inside the toilet with him too just in case people think we were cruel...heh heh). We brought in magazines and newspaper to read to pass time until Sparky did his business.
If he did anything wrong around the apartment (like tearing newspaper, attempting to pee on the cupboards or sofa leg etc), we would scold him and hit his bum (the area above the rear leg is fleshy and is not really painful to the dog) so he knows not to do the action again. But you need to discipline him almost immediately close to the action or else they don't know what it is you are scolding them for.
My goodness, you are really lucky. My dog is so bad ass and possibly spoilt. Keep telling him to potty at the newspaper, he either shoot near it, far from it but hardly ever on it. Drives me up the wall. Unfortunately, I dont have time to train him to use our toilet so the newspaper will have to do.
QUOTE(jootat @ Jan 9 2007, 02:54 PM)
Your routine is more suitable for a person who are not working. For those who are working, i advice you to think twice whether or not to get a dog. I have planned for a dog long time ago, but until now i still do not own one yet. Simply because i do not have a proper place for him to play around my house, and i m working, so do not have enough time to train or accompany him.
But i do agree with the training methods that you share. I will try it in future when i have my own house and have more free time.

Thanks for sharing.
I have given it a thought about a thousand times. I wanted a dog when I was much younger but my mom disapproved saying its fur may cause asthma. Then I waited for many years, even though I never brought it up again, the desire of having a pet was there.
When I was in college, I told my mom again and yet she turned me down again becuase of my baby-sister then. My sister and I are 11 years different, so I was turned down again.
Finally when I started work, with all the house commitment and bills to pay, my mom told me to get my own dog with my own money. So I had to save but it took me a long time to collect the money and to find the right dog because Westies are quite difficult to find in Malaysia and quite COSTLY!
That's how I ended up with Casper, for RM1,600 - he's price tag is considered cheap.
I may be working but I spend time with him, everyday. Even when I got home at 11.00pm, dead tired, I still spend an hour with him before going to sleep. Clean up after him, run around with him, etc. I consider myself to be doing pretty well as a pet owner.
I hope you get your doggy soon! Good luck!
QUOTE(White Palace @ Jan 9 2007, 03:03 PM)
Blackwood is "heaty"?
Well i believe if we are feeding kibbles, it is a totally dry food, so water must be always available.
So far, i fed all my dogs Blackwood & i'm very satisfied.
Anyway, i think as long as your dog doing well with one brand, juz stick to it.

Yea, that's what I heard because Blackwood packs a punch. Not only 1 pet store tell me this but my breeder and another guy name Abias (he studied Animal Science in Canada but from Klang, like me) in Tmn Megah pet store said the same thing. Blackwood is very compact, a lot of nutrition compressed into each bite - content may be too high some times, thus very heaty.
If you're happy with it, then its good for you but right now, I am going with Pro Plan Chicken. Kibbles are like dentabone is it?
QUOTE(RedBox @ Jan 9 2007, 03:03 PM)
Yes, think properly before getting a dog. I am working but do have family members to help in the beginning stage. It did not take long for her to learn. You will still have to spend time on a schedule if you are working. If you don't then you will come here and complain 'my dog pee poo all over help me!'

RB
Yes, I agree, thats why I spend my last bit of energy with Casper everyday when I get home from work, etc. I hope I manage to house break him asap.
QUOTE(nairud @ Jan 9 2007, 04:51 PM)
Piper would do her business inside the cage and lepak outside.. as for Dookie, that fella can tahan the whole day when i'm out. sometimes more than 15 hours. pity him...
It's hard to say which dog food is the best. Just get the super premium and you're good to go as long as your dog likes it and there's no reaction towards that brand. I do switch brands every 3-5 months so that they wont get bored with what they eat. Now, i'm feeding Proplan alternating between chicken and salmon flavor.
What's 'the super premium'? I will try your way, with salmon flavor Pro Plan after I finish off this pack. I hope my Casper likes fish.
QUOTE(jootat @ Jan 9 2007, 05:37 PM)
Really make sense, if family also don like dogs, then better don have one. If not later anyone of the family members go torture the dog then pain in the heart ...

So, if family all love dogs, then really can come out with a nice schedule for the dog to well train them and they for sure will be more disciplined as well.

In most cases, even those whose heart has turned to stone can find their heart beating and melting again by dogs. I am sure most will agree with me. Dogs just have a thing to reach out to others, especially when they are clean puppies.
My mom hates dog. My grandma was against it afraid we dont have time to take care of it. End up, now they let the dog out to play more than me. While I am working, my grandma is playing with Casper, letting it run around her tongkat. Watch TV also let him out to sayang him. Mom also, hang clothes to dry time, let Casper out to run around her feet and the puddle of water. Same case happens with my gf's dog and her parents!