QUOTE(EddyLB @ Jul 13 2013, 11:22 PM)
Bro, I beg to differ. The thread has gone to 11th version, coming to V12. Those UUU camp seems to be right all this while. So the answer is quite clear (up to today)
Downturn will sure to arrive 1 day. Therefore those DDD camp will be right 1 day and say "I told you so". But when that day comes, it doesn't mean that the UUU camp is wrong for the last few years. For those who bought in 2009 for say, RM500k and the value is RM1m today (100% gain), even if the downturn cause the property price to go down 30% (RM700k), they still are making gain
There are many 1st home owners like debbie throughout the 11 version. Let's say debbie did ask in the 1st few version in 2009 whether she should buy or wait, and she takes the advice of DDD camp. She would have missed the opportunity on hindsight. Likewise, if she takes the advice of UUU camp, she could have made 100% gain and posting comments like the UUU camp here
So, let's just wipe out what happened for the past few years, and start all over again now. I would say the chance of the market going down is 50-50 only. Should debbie wait or buy ? She will be facing the same situation in 2009 when we have V1 - nobody knows the future. So, if I am first home buyer, I would buy whatever I could afford now and don't bother what will happen to the market (because up or down, I am not going to sell it anyway). It is a calculated risk I will take and the risk is just like the outcome of flipping a coin - 50% chance I will be right
i don't disagree with you on the "historical" part.
it is true if one did not wait in 2009 or 2010 but bought something, esp for own stay, it would have been a fairly good decision. i have no idea when v1 was as i got here only late 2010.
however, i am less sure if the same can be said for those bought in 2011 and onwards. again, for long term own stay, probably will turn out ok. for investment, particularly flipping, i am even less sure they will make good money. of course, there will be a range of results, but i seem to observe a good few types in diff areas now now being subsold in the market for <20% gross gain, which translates into a miminal net gain. no loss, that's the sure. but those holding vacant units are paying a lot of interest, so that will count in the end too.
i have never held the view that there will be a big crash, but i do think subsale prices will continue to soften but <10% or so in the coming months mainly due to subdued subsale demand. so, if i am thinking of buying for own stay now, i will take my time to bargain like hell but will still buy after all work is done. buying to flip, count me out. i'll rather wait to see strong signs of a new cycle.
This post has been edited by AVFAN: Jul 13 2013, 11:59 PM