How Soybean financing affecting Wilmar’s oil seed & grain segment
February 7, 2014February 8, 2014tradingstock4aliving Leave a comment Edit
Soybean becoming a financing tool in China as a means to avoid the country’s tight credit rules.
1. Domestic traders would get banks to issue letters of credit with either at zero interest or <1% (in the case of soybean) for 90 to 180 days to import soybean.
2. Once soybean arrive in 30 days, they will be immediately sold for cash at a discount price in the local markets.
3. Then the traders will use the proceed to lend to small companies especially property developers who usually find it hard to get bank loan from banks due to tight credit rule in China with high interest rates.
4. The traders then either need to collect back the loans from those small companies or repeat the process when the due date for the letter of credit is due.
*Soybean financing has been mushrooming between 2009 and 2012 and has became a highly profitable business for commodity traders who benefitted from these :
i) Rising of commodity prices as the traders will either gain or bear less losses when they sell soybeans at a discount in the domestic markets.
ii) Appreciation in Renminbi.
iii) Interest rate difference between trade financing (zero or >1%) and chinese domestic underground leanding rates. The difference could be as high as doube-digit percentage points!!!
“IMPACT ON WILMAR INTERNATIONAL”
1. Soybean financing has lead to oversupply of soybeans. Hence lower domestic soybean price due to :
“supply > demand”
2. This will leads to price depressed in end-products like soybean oil and soy meal.
3. “Wilmar imports its soybean from north and south america”. Which means Wilmar has purchased Soybean higher than domestic soybean price and selling their end products at “depressed” price.
Which has leads to margin compression in the oil seed and grains segment.
Refer to table 1 below, Wilmar’s contribution from Oilseed and grain segment has contracted from 32% at 2008 to only 1% at 2012.
Table 1.
Which is the main reason why you see Wilmar share price drop from SGD 6.XX to SGD 3.XX.
Soybean financing heyday may be over soon. Why?
1. End of the commodity supercycle.
Those soybean financing trader will bear more losses.
2. USD vs RENMINBI
Gaining of USD meaning traders have to bear for forex losses.
3. Property Cooling measures by Chinese goverment
i) Goverment moves to force out the smaller developers that used to be the major customers of those soybean financing.
ii) Interest rate liberalisation and government actions against shadow banking could further downsize soybean financing market.
Will Soybean Financing REVISITED??
In fact, Beijing has implemented a series of measures to regulate off-balance-sheet lending and the cash crunch last year has caused many traders involved in commodity financing to go bankrupt.
Therefore, we can expect more stable earnings from this segment ahead. Indeed, we have seen this segment recorded four consecutive quarters of positive Profit before tax. However, its share price was still hovering at between SGD 3.10 – SGD 3.30. This is mainly due to some of those investors are not yet regain their confident towards this counter.
One more point to highlight. Base on table 1 segment contribution, we can conclude that Wilmar are expanding its sugar segment since 2010. Sugar segment will be their next leg of growth.
In conclusion, we can expect this counter rebound to SGD 6.00 easily in time to come.