QUOTE(joshuatly @ Nov 17 2012, 11:19 PM)
Dont know if here is the place to ask this question, i dont know how to calculate, so I need you guy's help.
Its regarding the PTPTN 20% discount vs putting the money in FD.
I borrowed RM41,250 from PTPTN, i get 1% charge instead of 3%, i can pay back within 15 years (RM 263.55 x 180 months)
If I pay back all the money within September 2013, I get 20% from RM41,250.
Is it worth it?
What if I put the money in fixed deposite and slowly pay back for 15 years, which one save me more?
Can anyone help/teach me how to calculate this out?
----------
I did some homework too, but just dont know if my method is correct. I've did the calculation in a spreadsheet, any guru please check.
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?key...9GeTZwT3c#gid=0My question is, from my calculation, if i slow slow pay i get 13k bonus at the end of year15, but if i pay in full, end of next year i got back 8k.
if i take inflation into account, isnt that 8k now worth more than 13k 15 years later?
How how?

joshualy,
My calculations say the slow way is better off by about RM200 only. My assumptions :
* RM41250 capital available now
* 2 options - the slow way or the fast way
* start in 2013 and see how much money one has at the end of 2026 for the 2 options.
* capital not used will earn FD interests for the 2 options.
Let me know your email address and I will send you my spreadsheet. You may see some errors in there as I forced myself this morning to use my left hand in using the mouse (got rash on my right wrist for using the mouse too much lately).
So which option to use ? The breakeven point is when FD rate is about 3% pa. Consider future FD rate in your analysis/decision. Good luck!
P/S These are only my estimates and I may be way off. I am not an accountant, only an engineer. Use it on your own risk and I accept no liability etc. Sorry.
This post has been edited by plumberly: Nov 18 2012, 10:49 AM