QUOTE(alaskanbunny @ Nov 26 2011, 11:47 AM)
isnt that fair? then what's a company car for?
Depends on what the car allowance is for. Whether it is part of your renumeration package, or some of reimbursement for out of pocket expenses.
For us, unless you're customer facing (salesman or tech service etc ie. tool of trade), a car allowance is level dependent. If you're senior enough, you get it as part of your overall package. Whether they pay that part of the package as salary or allowance is merely an administrative matter.
If you spend out of pocket for company business, that's a different matter which is not linked to your package.
If people who get car allowances cannot claim taxi, mileage etc, then the sales managers (who need to move around a lot) will be disadvantaged vs. say the finance managers (who stay in office) - when it comes to their package despite being the same job level. The sales managers' out of pocket expenses will eat into a lot more of their car allowance, compared to the finance managers.