Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )

5 Pages « < 2 3 4 5 >Bottom

Outline · [ Standard ] · Linear+

Health Beware of Unethical Breeders, Please Read

views
     
muchan86
post Jun 27 2011, 10:59 PM

Regular
******
Senior Member
1,523 posts

Joined: Nov 2007
From: Subang Jaya
QUOTE(KiyoshiJoz @ Jun 27 2011, 10:43 PM)
As other forumers suggested.. go visit her shop first and foremost
(I heard her shop is located somewhere in PJ/Subang area)
Check to see if the dogs there are well treated..
Ask around the forums for people who might have bought from her
(do this by replying on the pet clubs below which refers to the particular breed you are interested in)
Ask for a few things
MKA cert-> check for inbreeding
If there are inbreeding-> check whether or not the pup's dam and sire has any genetic illness etc.
(Unlike U.S.A, Malaysia cannot check for history of illnesses in a dam and a sire so you gotta dig it out from her)
Not all inbreded pups are bad... but its not encouraged... and preferably better not..
but nowadays its hard to find those kinda puppies who are not resulted from inbreeding before..

use your judgement and common sense as well as if you feel something is wrong.. or do not feel quite right
go back and do a little more research..

remember to ask questions about the pup from her...
(usually a responsible breeder will not hide anything from you)
Ask about the temperament of the dam and sire etc etc...

Good luck in getting your pup (=
*
She doesn't have shop. Basically she have those puppies at her house and some of them are with MKA cert but she did have puppies that no cert as well.

@nicole : I went to her place twice I think and if not mistaken she told me the parents of the puppies are not with her but if I really keen to see the parents she will try to get their picture for me to see smile.gif
TSKiyoshiJoz
post Jun 27 2011, 11:08 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
80 posts

Joined: Jan 2007


eh i thought her bf and her opened up a sort of "shop"?
what i heard is.. it isn't really a shop.. more like a kennel...
CyaNide27
post Jun 27 2011, 11:46 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
83 posts

Joined: Feb 2010
QUOTE(muchan86 @ Jun 27 2011, 10:59 PM)
She doesn't have shop. Basically she have those puppies at her house and some of them are with MKA cert but she did have puppies that no cert as well.

@nicole : I went to her place twice I think and if not mistaken she told me the parents of the puppies are not with her but if I really keen to see the parents she will try to get their picture for me to see smile.gif
*
i personally prefer to see the parents physically.... whistling.gif
benjac
post Jun 28 2011, 12:11 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
75 posts

Joined: Oct 2008
QUOTE(KiyoshiJoz @ Jun 26 2011, 01:32 AM)
)= yeah the truth is.. we bought from irene thinking its better to buy from her, a home breeder...
instead of going to shops (which has a higher chance of their puppies coming from puppy mills)

Whereas i was made to understand Benjac (owner of mellomouse blog (=) went up to Penang.. we didn't have the time to go up nor the vehicle to do so..

as such we didnt have a chance to inspect the location and see how was the condition of the pups before it was brought to us..

its hard to find a good breeder anymore
*
If anyone does get a chance to meet Irene Kang personally without knowing her bad reputation, you will surely fall for her promises. She talks non stop and you won't have a chance to ask her anything. I had a list of questions ready and yet she bulldozed me over when I tried to ask. My husband was shooting the dogs and in the background you can hear her talk talk talk talk. Anyway I was so in love with her Westies (Ozzy and Christy) that I didn't suspect a word she said. I wasn't even really looking at the puppies laugh.gif

Irene lives in a semi-d. Obviously a well-to-do family and it looks like a happy family home with her kids grown up. I didn't get to see where she keeps all her dogs. Everytime I ask to see another breed, she will carry them in and bring out another. Always 2-3 dogs of the same breed. At that time, it never crossed my mind just how many dogs she has inside her house. Easily a dozen and more.

Honestly, we totally fell for her "home bred with love" and "dogs are part of the family" selling point. I guess by seeing her and her dogs with our own eyes made it worst. Everything was so perfect that we paid deposit on the spot even though our intention was to just see. So for all the people who bought from her, I bet we all became "victim" the same way shocking.gif

Another point to add: Irene always assured us that she waits with the puppies outside of the vet for their vaccines. She will wait until is her turn only enters and leaves immediately to assure the puppies don't get sick from other sick dogs inside the vet. The irony from this is, her own home is filled with dogs that are sick surrounds all her newborn puppies doh.gif

This post has been edited by benjac: Jun 28 2011, 01:11 AM
TSKiyoshiJoz
post Jun 28 2011, 04:13 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
80 posts

Joined: Jan 2007


QUOTE(benjac @ Jun 28 2011, 12:11 AM)
If anyone does get a chance to meet Irene Kang personally without knowing her bad reputation, you will surely fall for her promises. She talks non stop and you won't have a chance to ask her anything. I had a list of questions ready and yet she bulldozed me over when I tried to ask. My husband was shooting the dogs and in the background you can hear her talk talk talk talk. Anyway I was so in love with her Westies (Ozzy and Christy) that I didn't suspect a word she said. I wasn't even really looking at the puppies  laugh.gif

Irene lives in a semi-d. Obviously a well-to-do family and it looks like a happy family home with her kids grown up. I didn't get to see where she keeps all her dogs. Everytime I ask to see another breed, she will carry them in and bring out another. Always 2-3 dogs of the same breed. At that time, it never crossed my mind just how many dogs she has inside her house. Easily a dozen and more.

Honestly, we totally fell for her "home bred with love" and "dogs are part of the family" selling point. I guess by seeing her and her dogs with our own eyes made it worst. Everything was so perfect that we paid deposit on the spot even though our intention was to just see. So for all the people who bought from her, I bet we all became "victim" the same way  shocking.gif

Another point to add: Irene always assured us that she waits with the puppies outside of the vet for their vaccines. She will wait until is her turn only enters and leaves immediately to assure the puppies don't get sick from other sick dogs inside the vet. The irony from this is, her own home is filled with dogs that are sick surrounds all her newborn puppies  doh.gif
*
sigh as what other forumers say...
if she wants to put up a front as a responsible breeder its easy... and thats why so many ppl fall into this trap...

i just need more proof about her yorkies..
we don't know who else bought her other yorkie pups...

and as i know.. its been a long time since she has a litter from her yorkies...
she is mainly selling westies and silkies...

even if she could at least answer our query properly instead of washing her hands off the whole matter will be sufficient..
we are not even seeking for compensation..
we're just seeking for an answer and to prevent future pups with similar condition from being born )=
less 1 future sick puppy and heart sick owner in this world then sad.gif


Added on June 30, 2011, 11:29 pm
QUOTE
Hi Josh,

Sorry for the late reply. I just got back from overseas and was told by a friend from the forum about your postings on LYN Forum.

I am very sorry for the loss of Tiffie and would like to express my deepest condolences to you and girlfriend. I know how painful it is for you and Joanne to lose such a beautiful dog.

The sire and dam of your dog have had 3 litters, totaling 10 puppies. This is the first time that a puppy from this pair of parents has died of congenital heart failure. All other puppies sold, including 1 female pup that I kept for myself are all healthy and doing fine. Both the dam and sire are also strong & healthy.

I have consulted my vet and he thinks that it is a 1 off thing since all the other puppies are healthy. He also says that congenital may not necessarily be genetic. Ask some breeders and they should be able to tell you that occasionally, there may be 1 or 2 cases of congenital abnormalities like cleft palate, heart defects, etc. out o f the many litters delivered. This may not be due to a genetic factor but environmental causes in the womb before birth like exposure to chemicals, drugs, etc.

As a responsible breeder, I will definitely not breed the pair if it is found to be a genetic issue.

You mentioned that your puppy's fur was messy & smelly at time of delivery. I am quite shocked to hear that. All my puppies are very well taken care of, kept in very clean environment and are given a bath & thorough groom before delivery (I make this a point with all my puppies sold). She was in tiptop condition. There was not even a blemish on her skin. All our puppies are even trained to eat kibbles direct from the pack and trained to be independent so that they will adjust easily and not cry in the new owner's home due to separation anxiety.

As for Taco, the owner has taken the westie puppy away for 2 weeks before it died. Anything could have happened in the 2 weeks. The puppy could have contracted the virus while under her care. She was given a week's health guarantee. She was shouting on the phone asking for full refund, refusing to hear me out and I had to put the phone down. I'm not sure if you are aware of this, but she did eventually buy a second westie puppy from me with a discount of RM500.

The other thing is about Benjac. She was not grateful to me for selling her a beautiful westie called Scubby, and she appears be very unreasonable to me. She is still harping away about me. She claimed that her dog has hip dysplasia. You may read further from this link: http://homeapet.com/english/viewtopic.php?f=39&t=4549 to know the truth.

Sorry Josh, to bore you with this and you may see this as me giving "excuses" but I need to let you know the other side of the story and it is very frustrating to hear and read about all these inflammatory remarks about my puppies and my breedings. I am truly disheartened that I've been labeled "unethical" and "irresponsible" breeder when I truly put alot of effort and love into taking care and breeding my dogs.
One more thing, could you pls ask Benjac to remove my address in this link: http://forum.lowyat.net/topic/1932845, failing which I will have to lodge a police report for privacy and safety of myself and my family. It is unlawful for her to be disclosing details (my address etc.) to the public.

Once again, I am truly so sorry for your loss of Tiffie. I hope this clarifies the comments about me. I hope you will fair to me.

Best Regards,
Irene
This is what Irene sent to me..
you guys be the judge...

And I'm sorry I won't reply via pm as I want this out in the public
As for the dirty fur at time of delivery

I bear testament to it..
I personally do not like lying and therefore will not lie..

When I took Tiffie.. we were surprised how coarse her fur was and tangled..
At first we thought nothing of it thinking maybe that is how puppy fur is like..
And we didn't dare to use the un-tangler comb (the comb with steel edge) for fear of hurting her

Then 1 night I just couldn't it and I started combing Tiffie..
It was heck painful for her.. and every comb I make my heart pains
But I manage to untangle her fur and gave her a nice bath after which she began to smell really nice...

I'm sorry Irene Kang but dogs just don't lie and they certainly cant tangle 90% of their fur themselves..


As for the other allegations.. it is not for me to prove.. I will let them tell their story...(taco and scubby)
As for the address part... I don't think its wrong to put it out.. unless there has been a death threat or a threat to cause menace at your place..
But I will tell benjac to do it for the sake of civility...

we don't seek to find war with any parties..
we just tell it as it is...
this thread seeks to cause awareness amongst public..


I fully realise that there is a degree of uncertainty that VSD may not be genetic..
If it can be proven I will apologise and i will take back my words..
However I will not take this thread down as this serves as a good reminder for others who are planning to get a companion
I will however take away details of how Tiffie died...

Only if it can be proven..
if possible could you please forward me medical reports for Sire/Dam of Tiffie namely -> Huahua Star and Max...
Also the grand sire and grand dam... -> genetic defects may skip a whole generation

And it cannot be denied that either you or where you get the dogs from are products of inbreeding..(We have Tiffie's cert)
There is a high chance of genetic diseases being passed down

no doubt it is hard to find a dog which is not a product of inbreeding anymore.. but I do know of breeders (albeit outstation ones) who do not condone nor practices inbreeding... and I wish for you to stop inbreeding as a start...

If you could do that, I will be willing to take down your name from the list
(again.. we do not have anything against breeders nor are we looking for a war.. we are educating people.. and if we know the breeder is willing to change his/her practice to conform to ethical styled breeding.. we are more than happy to let it go.. and in fact I will personally recommend you on to others)

Have a good day


This post has been edited by KiyoshiJoz: Jun 30 2011, 11:29 PM
aiyoyoann
post Jul 1 2011, 12:23 AM

New Member
*
Junior Member
24 posts

Joined: Nov 2009
QUOTE
Hi Josh,

Sorry for the late reply. I just got back from overseas and was told by a friend from the forum about your postings on LYN Forum.

I am very sorry for the loss of Tiffie and would like to express my deepest condolences to you and girlfriend. I know how painful it is for you and Joanne to lose such a beautiful dog.

The sire and dam of your dog have had 3 litters, totaling 10 puppies. This is the first time that a puppy from this pair of parents has died of congenital heart failure. All other puppies sold, including 1 female pup that I kept for myself are all healthy and doing fine. Both the dam and sire are also strong & healthy.

I have consulted my vet and he thinks that it is a 1 off thing since all the other puppies are healthy. He also says that congenital may not necessarily be genetic. Ask some breeders and they should be able to tell you that occasionally, there may be 1 or 2 cases of congenital abnormalities like cleft palate, heart defects, etc. out o f the many litters delivered. This may not be due to a genetic factor but environmental causes in the womb before birth like exposure to chemicals, drugs, etc.

As a responsible breeder, I will definitely not breed the pair if it is found to be a genetic issue.

You mentioned that your puppy's fur was messy & smelly at time of delivery. I am quite shocked to hear that. All my puppies are very well taken care of, kept in very clean environment and are given a bath & thorough groom before delivery (I make this a point with all my puppies sold). She was in tiptop condition. There was not even a blemish on her skin. All our puppies are even trained to eat kibbles direct from the pack and trained to be independent so that they will adjust easily and not cry in the new owner's home due to separation anxiety.

As for Taco, the owner has taken the westie puppy away for 2 weeks before it died. Anything could have happened in the 2 weeks. The puppy could have contracted the virus while under her care. She was given a week's health guarantee. She was shouting on the phone asking for full refund, refusing to hear me out and I had to put the phone down. I'm not sure if you are aware of this, but she did eventually buy a second westie puppy from me with a discount of RM500.

The other thing is about Benjac. She was not grateful to me for selling her a beautiful westie called Scubby, and she appears be very unreasonable to me. She is still harping away about me. She claimed that her dog has hip dysplasia. You may read further from this link: http://homeapet.com/english/viewtopic.php?f=39&t=4549 to know the truth.

Sorry Josh, to bore you with this and you may see this as me giving "excuses" but I need to let you know the other side of the story and it is very frustrating to hear and read about all these inflammatory remarks about my puppies and my breedings. I am truly disheartened that I've been labeled "unethical" and "irresponsible" breeder when I truly put alot of effort and love into taking care and breeding my dogs.
One more thing, could you pls ask Benjac to remove my address in this link: http://forum.lowyat.net/topic/1932845, failing which I will have to lodge a police report for privacy and safety of myself and my family. It is unlawful for her to be disclosing details (my address etc.) to the public.

Once again, I am truly so sorry for your loss of Tiffie. I hope this clarifies the comments about me. I hope you will fair to me.

Best Regards,
Irene



Hello Irene,


Firstly, when we took Tiffie home, we were all fine with her tangled-fur & her smell
I can be honest to you that it took us almost three weeks to bathe her out of the smell.
About the tangle part I left it for my boyfriend to do because it hurts my eyes to see her in pain
when we comb her. We thought FINE,maybe its because she's still puppy so we can bear with it.

Then we found rashes on her bottom part which at first we thought it was puppy rashes
but it got worse months later,so we took her to the vet and confirmed she was already infected
with fungal after he did some test on her .
I can assure that it is IMPOSSIBLE that Tiffie will be infected with the fungal in my place
as she sleeps with me on my bed & furthermore, there is no such rashes on my other puppy.

As of well trained,yes she was really a very good baby and independent too
I won't deny that as because of her behavior,I really love her.

QUOTE
This may not be due to a genetic factor but environmental causes in the womb before birth like exposure to chemicals, drugs, etc.

Are you telling me that she might be already infected in the womb of her dam?and it was also caused by the environment in your place?

Look, I have already lost Tiffie and NO other puppy can ever replace her .
I am not asking for refund nor do i want to give you a bad reputation .
There is no use for me to do so!It doesn't give me any Good!
I just want you to really give a good environment for your puppies
and bring your dogs for medical check up regularly as Tiffie isn't the only puppy
that was infected with diseases (Taco & Scubby for eg)
There may be more puppies had already infected but the owners do not want to seek problems
or they might not even know the cause of the illness.
I do not want other owners to experience what I'd been through and also
I do not like to see other dogs to go through that kind of pain that Tiffie had went through.
It really does give a big impact in my life & haunt me every time when I think of her.

I am sorry if I did really offended you but as a buyer/owner
I do have the responsibility to tell others what my boyfriend ,me & Tiffiie
had been through .It was told by the vet that the hole had already been
in her heart ever since the day she was born.



verulin
post Jul 1 2011, 09:34 PM

New Member
*
Junior Member
33 posts

Joined: Jan 2010
From: PJ n Ipoh


seriously? there is already so much evidence against Irene Kang, and yet she keeps trying to come up with excuses. doh.gif
(^(@)^)
post Jul 2 2011, 03:31 AM

New Member
*
Newbie
1 posts

Joined: Jun 2011
Breed because of money some more breed a sick puppy!

What kinda human are you Mrs Irene Kang? Wont you feel shameful? You are cold blood animal!

Even you have made a police report for yourself or your family got any usage?

Tiffie , scubby and tako owner have you all tried to report to SPCA? They will investigate da issue if 3 of da puppy owner go report on the same time.

akmal81
post Jul 2 2011, 03:39 AM

New Member
*
Junior Member
13 posts

Joined: May 2010


her house not for animals to live one ... and human too
TSKiyoshiJoz
post Jul 2 2011, 10:43 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
80 posts

Joined: Jan 2007


QUOTE((^(@)^) @ Jul 2 2011, 03:31 AM)
Breed because of money some more breed a sick puppy!

What kinda human are you Mrs Irene Kang? Wont you feel shameful? You are cold blood animal!

Even you have made a police report for yourself or your family got any usage?

Tiffie , scubby and tako owner have you all tried to report to SPCA? They will investigate da issue if 3 of da puppy owner go report on the same time.
*
its not really a case of animal abuse
doubt spca has any jurisdiction in this and hence why benjac reported it to Penang's MPPP (local council)
under the guise of having too many puppies in the house..
(See thread 1)

there is no rule/law barring them from breeding from doing inbreeding nor passing of genetic disease
(and as I say, if she can successfully prove that in the line of Tiffie's lineage including grand dam/sire, I will apologise)
However, until and unless she stops inbreeding and or clear up the doubts of some of the issues relating to her.. her name will stay on that list..
Sorry mrs. Irene Kang..

Think of it as a way for you to regain your reputation and come back stronger...
This is actually a chance for you to prove that you are an ethical breeder as you claimed...
If you are willing to change.. and change can be seen.. I will gladly take your name off
Not only that.. I will personally RECOMMEND you...

This is your chance to make a stand as an ethical breeder.. I hope you will do the right thing..
Start by stopping inbreeding.. then provide a good explanation to some of the issues highlighted by the pet owners whom you have sold pups to..
your pups do not have to be of champion lineage in order to be healthy..
Right now if I could turn back time.. I'd hope that Tiffie wasn't born of any lineage which has hereditary disease/illnesses

The ball is in your court Mrs. Irene...
You want me to be fair to you.. I am being fair to you..

I'm giving you a platform to clear yourself and also a chance to be a better breeder..
You have a chance of reversing something bad and setting a good example!

I hope you will make this opportunity count..
If there is a real improvement from you..
I will be the first to get another pup from you..

This post has been edited by KiyoshiJoz: Jul 2 2011, 11:08 AM
(^(@)^)
post Jul 2 2011, 01:09 PM

New Member
*
Newbie
1 posts

Joined: Jun 2011
Totally agree that name or website shouldn't remove till she clear the doubts.

Maybe she don understand that this thread is create for what propose. Not that buyer need to pre caution on her only but also other irresponsible seller.

Just curious that why she don come here defence herself if she's a good breeder?


hebihime
post Jul 4 2011, 10:39 AM

New Member
*
Newbie
0 posts

Joined: Apr 2011


aiya..i really hate those illegal breeder.luckily i bought mine from a responsible home breeder.
sorry to hear about ur puppy.it was so sad.

another illegal and irresponsible breeder that i know is aryan petshop in klang.dun buy any furkids from him.all the puppy are infected.he will sell very cheap.if u do some research,there are so many complains about him
Jaroque
post Jul 4 2011, 10:55 AM

Enthusiast
*****
Senior Member
995 posts

Joined: Mar 2007


sorry for the loses =(

This post has been edited by Jaroque: Jul 4 2011, 11:00 AM
ix3Rukia
post Jul 4 2011, 01:43 PM

New Member
*
Junior Member
18 posts

Joined: Apr 2011


QUOTE(KiyoshiJoz @ Jun 28 2011, 04:13 AM)
As for the address part... I don't think its wrong to put it out.. unless there has been a death threat or a threat to cause menace at your place..
But I will tell benjac to do it for the sake of civility...
*
I dont want to side her , but she's right. you cant post people's address in public unless they say u could. Failing to do so would result of having u getting sued. Its under that stupid lawbook.

Once again i say , i'm truly sorry for your loss. Whatever that happens , god knows. In the future , karma will happen.

This post has been edited by ix3Rukia: Jul 4 2011, 01:44 PM
TSKiyoshiJoz
post Jul 5 2011, 12:18 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
80 posts

Joined: Jan 2007


mm I wonder if benjac removed her address...
too bad she didnt post her address on her website...
benjac
post Jul 7 2011, 09:59 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
75 posts

Joined: Oct 2008
Ok I've removed the entire post. It's such a useless debate with that woman. What comes around, goes around.

Irene, if you are really reading this: Grow up and take responsibility.
blastberry
post Jul 8 2011, 06:43 PM

New Member
*
Newbie
0 posts

Joined: Dec 2010


hmm... sry for ur lost. i m a breeder too but i m not a dog breeder.. in fact i m a rodent one. wat she is doing is totally not acceptable. as a breeder i m very particular on my rodents that i make sure they r 100% healthy at all times. business of course make money but be responsible even tho have to sacrifice. Animals r just like us. They eat/zzzz/urine/poop... so be responsible. Bad Image she have.
TSKiyoshiJoz
post Jul 9 2011, 01:48 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
80 posts

Joined: Jan 2007


QUOTE(benjac @ Jul 7 2011, 09:59 PM)
Ok I've removed the entire post. It's such a useless debate with that woman. What comes around, goes around.

Irene, if you are really reading this: Grow up and take responsibility.
*
I've heard more stories about her....
hopefully the owners of those puppies will come out and make a stand...


Also reminder.. if you guys have anymore experiences with bad breeders (i.e the way they treat their pups/ the way they breed them/ dishonest breeders) please post here with evidence...

lets keep this alive..

kuluuluk
post Feb 18 2014, 06:11 PM

K u l u u l u K
*******
Senior Member
2,178 posts

Joined: Oct 2006
From: The Pearl of the Orient - MY
So does anyone know where got get pets from reputable breeder? I'm looking for MS
dtags
post Feb 26 2014, 11:14 AM

New Member
*
Junior Member
25 posts

Joined: Feb 2014


QUOTE(KiyoshiJoz @ Jul 9 2011, 01:48 AM)
I've heard more stories about her....
hopefully the owners of those puppies will come out and make a stand...
Also reminder.. if you guys have anymore experiences with bad breeders (i.e the way they treat their pups/ the way they breed them/ dishonest breeders) please post here with evidence...

lets keep this alive..
*
We have the same bad experience from Irene Kang. Hate her. Hv spent RM4000.00 at Medivet for my white schanauzer.
We bought it at RM1400.00 2 years ago. Luckily, he is doing well now.

Please keep this alive. Don't shut this line.


5 Pages « < 2 3 4 5 >Top
 

Change to:
| Lo-Fi Version
0.0354sec    0.49    6 queries    GZIP Disabled
Time is now: 21st December 2025 - 03:15 AM