definitely go for the sgs, but a bit iphone-ish

but is there any good 3d games out there really push the 3d to the max?? so far all the games are pretty 8/16bit kind of games in the 80s....even asphalt looks like a ps1 game

Tried NFS : Shift on SGS? Damn, so sexy.

How about Quake 3 Arena?

so u expect the game will be like PS3 game???
this is a mobile phone with small GPU inside dude...

video call should be the tie breaker, and of course the lovely SUPER AMOLED screen...

i choose SGS but i hate samsung CS and software

reason is pretty simple, hardware is top of the line for the moment (other then out look) ...
Software ? do u compare laptop/PC software installation ? i bet no ...

Out of the box i guess the desire wins, my dads SGS lags greatly and battery dies out quickly. If u plan to root and flash customs on the SGS, things would be on the good side

battery life poor ? my battery can last me 1 and half day ..... include most of the time online and game

out of the box i kinda agree that desire wins without any mod, but nothing much to do to galaxy to make it fly, you just need to download an app from market, 1st click to root 2nd click for lag-fix. tadaaaa its done, less then 5 minit no need to attach to computer and do all sort of complicated update.zip stuff

you cant judge the battery life just like that, you need to see the usage, and desire have a kernel that could save battery, so no fair if you compare if you already have that kernel install. i always have about 30% left at the end of the day (12 midnigt). i use it to play simple games such as asphlat for half of the day, while wifi is on half of the day also

Grab HTC buddy!!! u wont regerd for sure ^^

looking for the comments here listed make me even more cant decide what to choose...

should i choose the 3rd option... wait for newer andriod release???

---

Added on September 4, 2010, 4:23 pmHardware = SGS, Software = Desire...

This post has been edited by xproc: Sep 4 2010, 04:23 PM

you will never get any android in the end, since they are just keep coming

Just get one that the hardware would last long enough, and I think SGS has that potential? (do bash me if i'm wrong )

Here's another article for you to indulge on :-
http://www.techradar.com/news/phone-and-co...galaxy-s-702739

Hohoho... what do you expect?

A flop in desktop gaming coming to mobile phone arena and being crowned champion... that says it all.

Just wait for Nvidiot offering and see how they eat PowerVR for lunch...

Im not hoping for much on the phone, after all gaming is not a priority. Rather some stupid games to pass time.
However, Im thinking to buy a powerful tablet to replace my laptop and hoping Nvidia could deliver.

If gaming is a crucial requirement - the Galaxy S wins hands down due to its better and faster graphic processor, Coupled with its gorgeous and bigger screen . There are several comparisons on the web - each case the Galaxy S win ove other other Android - Nexus, Desire, Motorola Droid

If gaming is crucial, get a PSP or a Nintendo.

its not about the matter of gaming... i mean the hardware able to support future version of andriod anot... like gingerbread / honeycomb.....

i still wondering whic to choose.... nw looking at the tech radar page

---

Added on September 4, 2010, 7:27 pmtech radar choose HTC Desire ==

This post has been edited by xproc: Sep 4 2010, 07:27 PM

Wait for the Desire Z then. It's touted to be the next dev phone.

then the price tag and spec would be another decision factor afterall...