QUOTE(rayz1031 @ Aug 12 2010, 09:43 AM)
Transfer talk is always subjective, some might like it some might not. You can't separate transfer talk from football, its everyone wet dream to form their own dream team but sometimes is better to keep the dream to yourself because it will never come true in reality. I can understand the senior member frustration and I can understand the post of the newcomers in the thread, I won't call myself a senior here but I do lurk around alot, and some of the member has been here for the past 6 or 7 years and they know what they posting about.
If you wanted to quote a news, please quote from the official site. TheSun and TheStar reports are shitty to me..Rumors are better kept as rumors, keep it to yourself until Gill or SAF confessed on an open talk with the player.
Agreed somewhat, but we all have to bear in mind that transfer talk is part of the fun in pre-season anyway. You can't really talk about performance, matches, etc at this point so it is natural to comment on news etc. Even on the official site, they quote newspapers and tabloids that made headlines. Of course transfer talks are not a given and I am sure everyone on this thread agrees with the fact that a particular team might not sign anyone at all at any point, and that's ok. Commenting on transfers suggest optimism and desire to improve, not criticsm on the team in question. A forumer here suggested that a fan should support each individual player in the squad regardless of performance etc. Yes, that's true but that doesn't rule him out of criticsm. Fair criticsm is fair. Players earn millions every year and if their performances were to drop it's only fair to analyze the reasons why. Blind support is just that, blind.
And if it is true that you should support the team blindly no matter what, then please explain the gold and green movement. SAF has repeatedly come out and said that the Glazers are ok and yet the same group of so called "true fans" disagree with him and keep saying that we have no money. All this "we have no money" crap comes from the tabloid as well, there is no proof, there is no empirical evidence to support i; and yet we are selective to what is ok to believe from the tabloids and what is not. I'm not saying we have money, but you get my drift. Pot calling the kettle black.
At least the United fans on this thread comment on rumours rather than prophesize transfers out of thin air. Just read a few pages from the Chelsea and City thread and you'll know what I am talking about. It goes something like this:
"We lost today because our right back can't defend. Let's sign Lahm he looks good!" and queue everybody else coming up with names they could sign with all the Russian money at their disposal.
So let's all new and senior just get along and look forward to the new season. Like Alien said, if you don't like transfer rumours, just ignore it and become a reader. There' no need to abuse. Show that you've got some class and maturity.