The following comments were taken from the link below,
From (source):
http://mahaguru58.blogspot.com/2008/06/pus...ton-defies.htmlQUOTE
Dr Amir Farid Isahak said...
Assalamualaikum Mahaguru58,
I am keen to join the investigation of the truthfulness of the psychic surgeries done at Pusat Perubatan Keraton. I am a gynecological surgeon, and even though I am not a general surgeon, I have done enough surgeries over 30 years to know what to look for.
I have also been exposed to many "supernatural" phenomena and "psychic" healings and surgeries, some of which I have written in my column in The Star ("Art of Qi/Art of Healing" in SundayStar Fit4Life), so I can approach this matter with an open mind.
My initial impression after viewing the videos is that the "surgeries" are fake because:
1) During the surgeries done on the abdomen, the abdominal wall layers are absent (skin, subcutaneous fat which is usually thick, rectus sheath/aponeurosis, etc). You have to know anatomy to understand this, that's why it is easy for non-medical people to be hoodwinked.
2)in the videos, We never get to see the incision being done, something crucial to know what is being cut open
3)in the video, Even "heart" surgery is done on the abdomen!
4)the "blood" always looks pale and artificial. If you have done surgery you will know what fresh blood looks like. I admit that his method may involve little bleeding, but somehow all that "blood" in the videos doesn't look like blood.
5) in the videos, I note that the drapes totally cover the operated area and there is no way to tell if the "surgery" is being done on something put on top of the patient's abdomen (under the drape) instead of him cutting open the patient's abdomen as we are made to believe. Therefore I am not surprised that there is no scar when the plaster was removed.
I may have more comments to add later after viewing more videos.
I am prepared to give him the benefit of the doubt, not that I doubt the possibility of such surgery (with ALLAH's permission, anything is possible), but because what I see in the videos look fake (I may be wrong).
Since there are reports of patients being cured as well as being conned by him (from your blog and comments on YouTube), I think it is important that we investigate this matter together.
The videos may be genuine (no digital tricks), but the surgeries may be fake. It takes a surgeon to know if a surgery is real or not.
Please arrange:
1) for me to interview and get the medical reports of patients planned for surgery by him
2)for me to watch the surgeries at close range, instead of just relying on videos
3)for me to get the tissues or whatever removed so I can send to the laboratory for verification.
4) we can also interview and get medical reports of his previous patients (medical reports to confirm that after surgery they were cured of their disease or tumour/growth/cancer).
If he is not willing to abide by these conditions, then there is no way we can ascertain whether he is genuine or not.
Since he has also been found guilty of cheating 15 years ago (although his appeal is pending), it is important that we are sure that we are not helping him cheat more people this way.
On the other hand, if he is a genuine spiritual healer, then the people need to know that he can really help cure them of their health problems, since doctors still cannot cure many diseases.
I await your response. Selamat berpuasa.
Dr Amir Farid Isahak
Monday, 16 August, 2010
QUOTE
MAHAGURU58 said...
Wa'alaikumsalam Dr. Amir.
Thank you for sending in your comments as well on this subject matter.
I more than welcome medical doctors like your dear self to co-investigate this serious issue.
Just like everyone else, I too am quite concerned and wish to get to the bottom of this 'miracle healing'.
I am quite busy with my work at the moment. I will contact Prof. Dato Dr Raden Johari Mansor after Aidil Fitri and try to get an appointment with him where I'd like you and probably this Cybersetan to be present. Other surgeons who would like to be present can contact me and give me their details.
Lets do it after Raya, Insya Allah.
Any of you medical students/Doctors/Surgeons currently present in Malaysia would like to join?
Good Exposure for you guys~ (To Limeuu; Care to join?)
*P/S: For those who didn't get what the above post is for, do click my signature below and read through it. (Here is an additional link of interest:
http://forum.malaysianmedicine.com/topic.asp?TOPIC_ID=2503)