Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )

Outline · [ Standard ] · Linear+

Sociology Weird education, Malaysia BOLEH

views
     
TScommunist892003
post Aug 3 2009, 08:40 AM, updated 17y ago

On my way
****
Senior Member
550 posts

Joined: Dec 2008


Most teachers waste their time by giving exam and asking questions which are intended to discover what a student doesnt know, whereas the true art of questioning has its own purpose of discover what a man capable of knowing..Maybe the way to score well in exam is to know what u shouldnt know and dont know...Weird Education....SHould goverment somehow implement a policy to replace some role education play in this society???WHy spend 15 to 20 years on study in school just to get a secure job??? Learn things that is meaningless and most probably couldnt be apply in job...facing book full of words which tend to be memorized than understand....I sugguest a policy than a kid should work in a protected condition....Experience is always better off than what we learn in school
geforce88
post Aug 3 2009, 08:51 AM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
2,841 posts

Joined: Jun 2009


1000% agree with u!
Cheesenium
post Aug 3 2009, 10:49 AM

Vigilo Confido
*******
Senior Member
4,852 posts

Joined: Aug 2006
This is more like Education Essential content than LhD Lab content.

Still,what you say it's true.We are pretty forced to memorise the whole book till you know everything in that book but dont have any soff or people skills that employers actually looking for.

The best example would be Pendidikan Moral in high school.Absolute rubbish.
Joey Christensen
post Aug 3 2009, 10:56 AM

Purgamentum init, exit purgamentum
*******
Senior Member
3,651 posts

Joined: Jan 2009
From: Fort Canning Garden Status: Dog Fighting



Good Morning...logged in this morning and saw the title has been changed from "The Science Lab" to "PhD School".

Okie...let's look at Malaysia’s progress in education since our (Is it ours? Or it belongs to certain race?) country gained Independence in 1957.

What I'm going to say would be a knack sensitive to certain individuals but what I'm going to pen here is just my piece of mind.

Primary school? Secondary school? National school? Vernacular school? These aren't worth to mentioned. There are certain nincompoops who think that our education system has absolutely no need to change...It's still running albeit a little bit ~!@#$%^&* up, why want to change it's course?

But, of course, life isn't rainbows and sunshines...Life's is not fair. We are not playing "Monopoly" board game where everyone gets $200 at Start. Yes, life likes to kick yu in the balls. No point grieving over it because it a vicious cycle. Would I be getting used to it? To tell yu the truth, YES. I'm sick and tired of that some people have had better opportinities than me.

Hey, 5% discounts for house purchasing? That's ~!@#$%^&* fair. Implementation of 30% quota? That's really ~!@#$%^&* nice. UiTM? WHOA~~~That's really thoughtful.
Hey, if yu don't like what we are doing, heck! it, just leave. All this for the exchange of citizenship??!! Yu got to be kidding me, right? Is Article 153 questionable? NOPE. Unless the Government's table is turned.

On my other note, I'm not some leftist or anything nor I'm a ~!@#$%^&* PhD holder. I'm just a regular Malaysian who wishes to eat roti canai in the morning and a cup of Kopi-O.

Back in the 80's, I still remember me and my other classmates who had to borrow our textbooks through Skim Pinjaman Buku Teks (SPBT), do they still have that? Anyway, for the bright ones and the shallow ones as years passes by...who will have the opportunities to enrol into MARA junior science colleges, bumiputera boarding schools, or even Matrikulasi?

If life were fair, what would happened? What would have possibly happened? Denial after denial...we are taken as a second class citizens. Don't yu know that after years living in Malaysia? Am I emotional for these denials? Not entirely. But what ticks me off is the wastage of talents and brilliance of fellow Malaysian. Brain drain, anyone?

Recently the ASMB's shares? Look at the percentage allocation of shares to Bumiputera and non-bumiputera. It's on the newspapers. Closed tenders to Bumiputera contractors? It's well opened news. So what's the hidden agenda, huh? Transparency? It goes down in the drain.

It's ALL ABOUT CHANGE.

There are certain steps which can be considered in regards of hiring good English teachers. Don't tell me the Government doesn't have enough funding. It's all ~!@#$%^&* crap. Incentives can be given, training and development can be implemented, what about hiring those who retired but still have the passion and ability to teach science and mathematics properly in English?

Yes. It's ALL ABOUT CHANGE.

The change of the system. It can be improve and ameliorate. Curriculum can be cleaned up and revamped. Encourage critical thinking and the sense of curiousity both in the class and outside activities. Not some figure crunching, text memorising living zombies.

Aaaahhhhh...if only our Government change. Change in the education system. For those ~!@#$%^&* ignorant minded individual piece of shit who think that our education system is on the right track, yu ought to be shot in the head.

Although our education system is ~!@#$%^&* up, it's advisable that yu get a basic education. Find a way to weave your future. It took me 3 times of application to enrolled in a local private University with a scholarship couple of years back. It very much ticked me off but it served as an experience.

Unless yu are one of the "elites" in our society, yu can bid goodbye to good education. HG Wells once said "It is not exaggerating to say that human history becomes more and more a race between education and catastrophe. If we continue to leave vast sections of the people of the world outside the orbit of education, we make the world not only less just, but also less secure."

Regards, Joey

p.s: Thread Starter, your mentality is totally wrong. No matter how bitter our lives would be, education plays an importance in our lives.

15 to 20 years of education IS NOT JUST FOR SECURING A JOB.

Endless years of education IS FOR ACQUIRING KNOWLEDGE and BETTER UNDERSTANDING.


This post has been edited by Joey Christensen: Aug 3 2009, 04:43 PM
TScommunist892003
post Aug 3 2009, 11:28 AM

On my way
****
Senior Member
550 posts

Joined: Dec 2008


I am mentioning about our education ...u need to be clear the purpose of our education..how our people treat education as???...I am not blaming the goverment...but our mindset toward education...that screw our brain...tat education...I had been discussing it a lot with global ppl...their view and my view...i lazy to write everything about it ..but i just write my understanding about knowledge

Knowledge...Ledge of knowing..tats it...Understandledge....ledge of understanding...which sometimes ppl call it equation
I was wondering...Knowledge is power of?? Knowing for me doesnt bring any meaning in life...I think that what is important in our life is understanding
Do u know how many equation there is for physics subject in my high school??
18 ...and based on those 18, i need to study entire 500 pages...and i still got a bad grade for tat...And then, i was outrage one day...sawing one of my fren who had a best grade in school for pyhsics and actually doesnt even have a proper physics reference book where as i got 4 -5 ...All i could conclude is tat he is indeed a smart ass
From tat day onward, i always get close to him, trying to find out what secret lie behind him...because student always wish to find shortcut in study...
At the end, i think i found one...shortcut indeed been discover
I found tat i'm actually an apple collector, where as he is an apple planter..or we can call him farmer...Apple symbolize knowledge...everyday we student's duty is to collect as many apple as u can from everywhere so tat we could score well in exam...But my little smart fren doesnt need it, he just need to sit down there waiting the apple drop from the tree...The tree symbolize equation...generating a lot lot apple...And u know wat, apple do get rotten...so at the end of the day...i still got to collect the same standard of apple to increase my quantity...I am very tired of collecting ....i am so jealous my fren just sit down there and he get more apple than mine

My theory is tat understandledge or equation generate more knowing...where as knowledge is just a product of it...Knowledge is power?? I dont think so
Sometimes old man in the market said : u just need to know few things in life which is better to be an experience...it is simple but it perform better than wat u learn in school.
When i intepret it in different meaning, he actually talking about equation(experience is the combination of knowledge and understandledge)
THe most valuable life is thinking not to know but to understand

Joey Christensen
post Aug 3 2009, 12:04 PM

Purgamentum init, exit purgamentum
*******
Senior Member
3,651 posts

Joined: Jan 2009
From: Fort Canning Garden Status: Dog Fighting



» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «


Do yu need a crutch?

Your case is applicable to the admission of bumiputera in the higher learning institutions. They have the "privileges". UiTM? Sounds familiar? Matrikulasi? Sounds better than STPM? But all these institutions are churning nothing but ~!@#$%^&* craps? Yu do the guessing.

Have yu heard of the saying "A bad carpenter blames his tools?" How true it is to yu?

Let me ask yu a very straight forward question: Would yu DISCOURAGE/HINDER your child/children to get basic schooling/knowledge? Yes or No?

Regards, Joey

This post has been edited by Joey Christensen: Aug 3 2009, 12:05 PM
obefiend
post Aug 3 2009, 12:37 PM

Selamat Hari Raya Aidilluminati
*****
Senior Member
863 posts

Joined: Mar 2007
From: Tanjung Segitiga Masonic Lodge



compared to the days i was in school ( early 90's) i can honestly say the education system improved alot! students are more open to new ideas and have nice debate with their teachers. back in my days the teacher is the absolute truth. if you even dare question time get ready for some unfair grading during exams.

i dunno why people still wanna whack the edu system so much. all this BS about abolishinng exams and what not. if you stop giving them exams how can you gauge their knowledge? like it for not memorising is part of education. nothing wrong with that.

btw

learn things that are meaningless? what do you mean by that. no knowledge is meaningless. only useless people who fail to see the significance of it in real day to day usage.

i disagree with you TS.
TScommunist892003
post Aug 3 2009, 12:40 PM

On my way
****
Senior Member
550 posts

Joined: Dec 2008


I am 20...way to young to have child...i wont discourage the children to get basic schooling...THIS it not about unfair treatment we received, if goverment change , i don think they aware of the problem in education, i think they would just make everyone equal...WHy we go school???coz my parents cannot teach me and need go to work...SCHOOL IS GOOD SOLUTION

Knowledge is everywhere
I wonder why german kids study 5 hours in school...all they did is socialize and play...but they still manage to produce a huge number of philosopher and scientist...same go to US...The country that so obsess by intellectual and genius that they do anything to lock them in AREA 51 ....how come they dont implement our education in their country...STPM, very very hard oh, malaysian said only smart can overcome....WTF country like US, german, france, UK, australia doest take a look at it??? THey had always known for their best quality in education...AYa, u try figure out urself la ...human is superior because of discovery knowledge or installment of knowledge???
I aslo felt the same way u did for the unfair treatment by goverment...all those scholarship stuff...but i think this is nothing to do with the origin purpose of education
kei_86
post Aug 3 2009, 04:24 PM

New Member
*
Junior Member
13 posts

Joined: Dec 2007
if we're talking about the problem of student not really learning because we're memorizing more than understanding, then I'd say the problem isn't really about our education system per se but also the society. This exam oriented education that we have today has lots of pro and cons

the thing about exam is that it is tangible, can be seen and gauged by everyone. The parents want it because it is a proof that either their child has done something in school or the school has been doing their job. Teacher needs it to see whether his pedagogy worked or not and whether he should change into something else. The administration needs it to administer their teachers.

on its own, our curricular and exam is GOOD, but the overemphasize on exams and wrong emphasis of the curricular is BAD. With the parents and administrator racing to collect As, students are shoved with information and required to just vomit everything out again during exam. Just for the As, whether they understand or not does not matter.

I'm taking TESL myself and I find the fact that literature classroom in our country is very sad indeed. Literature is supposed to be appreciated and not dissected into points of data per se.

however I'm not against our system of education, I do believe that almost all the subjects offered in our primary and secondary school isn't that bad. I doubt that a child would know what to learn at such early a stage in their life. I consider education really starts at tertiary education because only then would a child know his/her path. If everyone would just drop the obsession with the exams in school, our school isn't that bad at all I'd say. At least teachers are able to do more than teaching with less stress and observation from the higher ups.

get rid of the exam obsession I'd say.
cekutz
post Aug 3 2009, 04:30 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
291 posts

Joined: Jan 2007
From: Usm n. tebal / Kepong



QUOTE(communist892003 @ Aug 3 2009, 08:40 AM)
Most teachers waste their time by giving exam and asking questions which are intended to discover what a student doesnt know, whereas the true art of questioning has its own purpose of discover what a man capable of knowing..Maybe the way to score well in exam is to know what u shouldnt know and dont know...Weird Education....SHould goverment somehow implement a policy to replace some role education play in this society???WHy spend 15 to 20 years on study in school just to get a secure job??? Learn things that is meaningless and most probably couldnt be apply in job...facing book full of words which tend to be memorized than understand....I sugguest a policy than a kid should work in a protected condition....Experience is always better off than what we learn in school
*
Is this just a sorry excuse for failing your exams?
transhumanist92
post Aug 3 2009, 05:54 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
255 posts

Joined: Feb 2008
From: Prison Planet


I think that we should abolish the process of attending classes too. A person should be able to get a Doctorate from Yale by just sending in his fee. I mean why mess with all of that stuff in between. It doesn't make much difference does it? I mean what does one really learn anyway?

As a matter of fact let's just do away with school altogether. You get a degree at birth and then sort of muddle through. That seems about right.

Screw knowledge, it's all subjective anyway isn't it?

Let's just all become lefties and work together for the common good. We can all starve together. What a trip.
obefiend
post Aug 3 2009, 05:55 PM

Selamat Hari Raya Aidilluminati
*****
Senior Member
863 posts

Joined: Mar 2007
From: Tanjung Segitiga Masonic Lodge



QUOTE(cekutz @ Aug 3 2009, 04:30 PM)
Is this just a sorry excuse for failing your exams?
*
actually i wanted to say that but i might risk hurting TS feeling. i notice that the people who complained about how "poor" our ed system is the same person who FAILS to make the grade. blaming the system for their shortcoming.

"ooooooo.. malaysian system no friendly to ADHD/asperger people like me"

i think that is kinda sad. mayeb you need to read on the Scientologist was of teaching. they believe that you MUST NOT force your kid to study. Must allow them to choose their own path. that way they will allegedly able to hone their natural skill

what a load of bs

lin00b
post Aug 3 2009, 08:07 PM

nobody
*******
Senior Member
3,592 posts

Joined: Oct 2005
QUOTE(communist892003 @ Aug 3 2009, 08:40 AM)
Most teachers waste their time by giving exam and asking questions which are intended to discover what a student doesnt know, whereas the true art of questioning has its own purpose of discover what a man capable of knowing..Maybe the way to score well in exam is to know what u shouldnt know and dont know...Weird Education....SHould goverment somehow implement a policy to replace some role education play in this society???WHy spend 15 to 20 years on study in school just to get a secure job??? Learn things that is meaningless and most probably couldnt be apply in job...facing book full of words which tend to be memorized than understand....I sugguest a policy than a kid should work in a protected condition....Experience is always better off than what we learn in school
*
of the many jobs out there, how will you know which you want? try each one out for 1 month? many job cannot be experienced in a month. what job can you give a 7 year old? what happens when you choose a job, worked at it for 2-3 years then decide you want something else without basic education?

do you think the 1st 15 years of education up to PMR as worthless information? all of it should be considered general basic knowledge that everyone should know.
Thinkingfox
post Aug 3 2009, 09:30 PM

Le Renard Brun Rapide
****
Senior Member
617 posts

Joined: Jun 2008
QUOTE(communist892003 @ Aug 3 2009, 08:40 AM)
Most teachers waste their time by giving exam and asking questions which are intended to discover what a student doesnt know, whereas the true art of questioning has its own purpose of discover what a man capable of knowing..Maybe the way to score well in exam is to know what u shouldnt know and dont know...Weird Education....SHould goverment somehow implement a policy to replace some role education play in this society???WHy spend 15 to 20 years on study in school just to get a secure job??? Learn things that is meaningless and most probably couldnt be apply in job...facing book full of words which tend to be memorized than understand....I sugguest a policy than a kid should work in a protected condition....Experience is always better off than what we learn in school
*
By knowing what the student doesn't know, the teacher can help that student. Exam also helps to solidify knowledge in a student because a student usually won't want to remember facts unless s/he is examined. An exception would be a student who is passionate in that particular subject. But many young children don't have such passion as they find it hard to understand the merits of learning. So how do you build a foundation for them?In an exam, you should know what you should know and that would be the topics covered in the syllabus.

<<SHould goverment somehow implement a policy to replace some role education play in this society>>
You are being very ambiguous here without stating the cause, effect or method of solving. Do you mean by making some informal education formal? e.g. making a syllabus on what to wear and what not to wear?

<<WHy spend 15 to 20 years on study in school just to get a secure job??? Learn things that is meaningless and most probably couldnt be apply in job..facing book full of words which tend to be memorized than understand....I sugguest a policy than a kid should work in a protected condition....Experience is always better off than what we learn in school>>
But things like ABC and counting 123 can't be taught in the industry. They will have no time to teach you all these, therefore you have specialised institutions for formal education and they are called schools/colleges/polytechnics/universities. And these skills are crucial for living in the modern world. Imagine what problems an illiterate person will face: he won't be able to keep his money in the bank, he won't be able to work in many industries thus his job prospects are limited, and he won't be able to use the computer or handphone, which are almost indespensible today.

This post has been edited by Thinkingfox: Aug 3 2009, 09:31 PM
azarimy
post Aug 4 2009, 01:08 AM

mister architect: the arrogant pr*ck
Group Icon
Elite
10,672 posts

Joined: Jul 2005
From: shah alam - skudai - shah alam


QUOTE(communist892003 @ Aug 3 2009, 04:40 AM)
Knowledge is everywhere
I wonder why german kids study 5 hours in school...all they did is socialize and play...but they still manage to produce a huge number of philosopher and scientist...same go to US...The country that so obsess by intellectual and genius that they do anything to lock them in AREA 51 ....how come they dont implement our education in their country...STPM, very very hard oh, malaysian said only smart can overcome....WTF country like US, german, france, UK, australia doest take a look at it??? THey had always known for their best quality in education...AYa, u try figure out urself la ...human is superior because of discovery knowledge or installment of knowledge???
I aslo felt the same way u did for the unfair treatment by goverment...all those scholarship stuff...but i think this is nothing to do with the origin purpose of education
*
have u been to any of these countries or gathered on how they run their education system? our education system is almost the exact same copy of UK's. it's the same template, same content level, same method of delivery. perhaps the only thing different is the actual content itself.

schools are for u to establish ur basics. whether u can become a genius who'll create the next fuel type for world energy needs depends on where u go for tertiary education.


Andyzz
post Aug 4 2009, 01:15 AM

Lost Kampung Boy
******
Senior Member
1,196 posts

Joined: Oct 2006
From: Kampung


To add on,the goverment make some subject a must in university for IPTS just to reach and been acknowledge by LAN.We've learn moral since standard 1 i think,till to uni,we are still learning moral.
TScommunist892003
post Aug 4 2009, 02:32 AM

On my way
****
Senior Member
550 posts

Joined: Dec 2008


QUOTE(kei_86 @ Aug 3 2009, 05:24 PM)
if we're talking about the problem of student not really learning because we're memorizing more than understanding, then I'd say the problem isn't really about our education system per se but also the society. This exam oriented education that we have today has lots of pro and cons

the thing about exam is that it is tangible, can be seen and gauged by everyone. The parents want it because it is a proof that either their child has done something in school or the school has been doing their job. Teacher needs it to see whether his pedagogy worked or not and whether he should change into something else. The administration needs it to administer their teachers.

on its own, our curricular and exam is GOOD, but the overemphasize on exams and wrong emphasis of the curricular is BAD. With the parents and administrator racing to collect As, students are shoved with information and required to just vomit everything out again during exam. Just for the As, whether they understand or not does not matter.

I'm taking TESL myself and I find the fact that literature classroom in our country is very sad indeed. Literature is supposed to be appreciated and not dissected into points of data per se.

however I'm not against our system of education, I do believe that almost all the subjects offered in our primary and secondary school isn't that bad. I doubt that a child would know what to learn at such early a stage in their life. I consider education really starts at tertiary education because only then would a child know his/her path. If everyone would just drop the obsession with the exams in school,  our school isn't that bad at all I'd say. At least teachers are able to do more than teaching with less stress and observation from the higher ups.

get rid of the exam obsession I'd say.
*
Now someone get my points...thx u...i am totally agree with u....others forget it...LOL...Maybe malaysian communicate differently...always take my statements offensively...SENSITIVe...just keep telling me what is right and wrong...tell me what i need to know...why not tell me about ur reason and opinion???

Isnt this a discussion??

This post has been edited by communist892003: Aug 4 2009, 02:50 AM
azarimy
post Aug 4 2009, 03:57 AM

mister architect: the arrogant pr*ck
Group Icon
Elite
10,672 posts

Joined: Jul 2005
From: shah alam - skudai - shah alam


QUOTE(communist892003 @ Aug 3 2009, 06:32 PM)
Now someone get my points...thx u...i am totally agree with u....others forget it...LOL...Maybe malaysian communicate differently...always take my statements offensively...SENSITIVe...just keep telling me what is right and wrong...tell me what i need to know...why not tell me about ur reason and opinion???

Isnt this a discussion??
*
no, it's not that we're sensitive. it's ur insensitivity that irks us. if a carpenter fails, he should blame himself not the tool. that's assigning the problem where it's worth. if u cant dance, dont blame the irregular floor.

u implied that STPM is not as worthy as A-levels or other overseas certificates. but it has been established that STPM is recognized worldwide as equivalent to A-levels and can be used to gain direct entry to a degree course. ur failure to recognize STPM urges us to question ur judgment over the rest of the matter.
onelove89
post Aug 4 2009, 06:52 AM

Fighter for God
*******
Senior Member
3,107 posts

Joined: Apr 2007
From: Sarawak


QUOTE(transhumanist92 @ Aug 3 2009, 05:54 PM)
I think that we should abolish the process of attending classes too. A person should be able to get a Doctorate from Yale by just sending in his fee. I mean why mess with all of that stuff in between. It doesn't make much difference does it? I mean what does one really learn anyway?

As a matter of fact let's just do away with school altogether. You get a degree at birth and then sort of muddle through. That seems about right.

Screw knowledge, it's all subjective anyway isn't it?

Let's just all become lefties and work together for the common good. We can all starve together. What a trip.
*
Wow, SUPER sarcastic =)


Anyways, yesh the education system in msia is a bit weird to be honest. But doesn't mean that what we're learning at useless and obsolete. Why the frequent tests? Why asking us things we do not know? If there were no frequent tests, we'll probably slack ourselves dumb. Besides, test is a tool to show the level of your understanding in a particular field. Why asking us things we do not know? Cos it'll be pointless to ask us something we know.

There are places and spots in the education system worth reviewing. Eg. I'm totally against pendidikan moral. Enough said why, I'm sure we all know why whistling.gif From kindy to uni, we're gathering knowledge, understanding, and applying. You might feel you're inefficiently harvesting now, then you should do something bout it. Physics for example, understand the core concepts, and apply it. It's not simply just remembering theories and equations.

Well, I reckon the education system is still alright. Just some places that I'm not satisfied with, but hey! Nothing is perfect right? =) Study smart instead of hard. btw i'm same age as u and I'm in uni. Loving all the things I'm studying. =) Cos I need those knowledge for my job in future.


*STPM is harder than A-levels, according to many students*



transhumanist92
post Aug 4 2009, 05:42 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
255 posts

Joined: Feb 2008
From: Prison Planet


Exams are an objective task to measure the ability of an individuals learning skills as well as commitment.

It is simply a test to show who is capable of memorizing and who is not capable of memorizing regardless of the subject.

The subject at hand does not matter. The ability to think on your feet and memorize is what does matter.

If you can't take the time to strengthen your memorization skills or even your common sense skills, then you can't be a productive member of society.

For instance, some people don't even need to study because of what the individual learned in the past and what the individual has memorized from the teachers lecture. Mixed with the ability to think on your feet and cross out ridiculous answers and guess at the ones that are most probable are the students that excel.

Schooling also tests the students will power to learn and understand information that is boring. Do you honestly think as an individual everything you encounter in life is going to be fun to memorize?

The student needs to learn how to memorize information that is boring to them.

It is called learning how to learn and critically thinking skills. If you can't pass a simple question and answer form, then you have problems.

azarimy
post Aug 4 2009, 07:02 PM

mister architect: the arrogant pr*ck
Group Icon
Elite
10,672 posts

Joined: Jul 2005
From: shah alam - skudai - shah alam


people seem to perceive that exams only tests memory skills. this is false.

exams are geared towards testing something, anything, that we wanna measure. so it could be memorization skills, critical thinking, problem solution, bridging and so on. each element would have a different way of questioning.

abolishing exams is abolishing the measuring tape. that wont solve the education issues in malaysia. what is needed is a different measuring tape. u cant measure ur waist using a ruler, u need a measuring tape!
kink_ass
post Aug 4 2009, 10:36 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
79 posts

Joined: Jun 2008
please, if you wanna discuss about education, leave the politics out of it. i think some of you have misinterpreted what ts is trying to deliver from the beginning. it has nothing to do with the privileges.

after reading all the posts, it did changed my mindset towards our nation's education system. all of you do have your points.

all the while, I've had this mindset that our education system is too exam orientated. which is partially true for some reasons. of course, the society's obsession with examination is a major factor. with parents pushing their kids to gather as many A's as possible, it is definitely going to lead certain quarter of the society to jump on the advantage of providing tuitions solely for the purpose of business. tuition is no longer for the weaker students but for students who want to compete for Who's-Got-The-Most-As. hence, leading to a very exam orientated education in school as students only learn what will be tested (forecast questions,soalan bocor and etc) not what they wish/desire to know. the thirst for knowledge and understanding is no longer there. passion is lost.

then again, you cannot take away the examination as yes, as most of you have said it is the 'measuring tape' of education. teachers do need to gauge the students, the administration needs to gauge the teachers and parents would want to gauge the schools. that's just one of the many reasons why you cannot take away exams from an education system.

i believe there's no need for an overhaul but just review certain aspects in the education system. quit going back and forth on the decision to teach in english or malay medium. if we want to progress and be on top with the others, then time is gold. we need to set a course, and go with it. don't go back otherwise it's just a cycle.

This post has been edited by kink_ass: Aug 4 2009, 10:40 PM
TScommunist892003
post Aug 5 2009, 02:04 AM

On my way
****
Senior Member
550 posts

Joined: Dec 2008


Education is necessary...But the wrong of the wrong is we tend to be way too excessive...Greed of security and achievement...Schooling is important or vital, but doesnt mean the only way to gain the basic or knowledge is from SCHOOL...Our purpose of education had change...Rather than develop one's potential skill, ppl tend to turn their child into what they wan...Excessively is what a good word to describe our education...drift away from the origin purpose of education
I always believed man is superior because of discovery knowledge, not installment of knowledge...U can stuck everything in ur brain, but if u dont nurture ur skill as pioneer or hunter of knowledge, u wont get or even build an equation (understanding) in our mind...Education i refer is stucking everything in ur brain, at the end of the day u go for a test see whether there is a hole u hadnt fill...I prefer to use my computer to do so

Most of our objectives to school because the guarantee of better jobs and financial security in future....Most dono even care the great meaning behind the knowledge...treating education as a investment business where u can start early in childhood...SOme parents gamble everything and even in poor condition, still dont allow the kids to works things out , keep reminding the education is a way out of poverty, behave of knowledge or financial security???...It doesnt mean they are wrong to think so, but do u think today society is way way to excessive??thinking that the better u are at school, the better of chances u success in future and the smarter u are...... I always wonder why TOp 50 students in my school, most of them doesnt even love or bother to watch documentary channel, reading book than text book...which i love the most...WHen i ask them why, they ask it is pointless...But when i meet with some top students in australia, they love this documentary so much that they said it inflict so much curiousity about this world, make their life meaningfully...this is the scenario i'm facing

I wonder the main purpose we go school is for knowledge or otherwise?? If indeed to gain basic of knowledge, what is the major motive behind it?? ARE WE SINCERE TO GAIN KNOWLEDGE??? ARE WE SINCERE??


Added on August 5, 2009, 2:13 amI dont consider ppl like einstein, bill gate, thomas edison as a genius because of their achievement....OF coz they are genius...But i prefer their great achievement in life because they are human....THey do things naturally ....pursue knowledge the origin way that human pursue it ...SHould we pursue knowledge sincrely and naturally???

This post has been edited by communist892003: Aug 5 2009, 02:13 AM
spursfan
post Aug 5 2009, 03:18 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
110 posts

Joined: Jan 2009
in terms of education, the best is probably vocational school ...

you learn stuff that is actually beneficial instead of theory and calculation ... and don't get me started on p.moral ...

even if you drop out of school, you have skills to fall back on ... if you are good enough to go to uni, u will breeze through the practical stuff

science stream, art stream ... all bs if u ask me
kei_86
post Aug 5 2009, 04:47 PM

New Member
*
Junior Member
13 posts

Joined: Dec 2007
QUOTE(communist892003 @ Aug 5 2009, 02:04 AM)
Education is necessary...But the wrong of the wrong is we tend to be way too excessive...Greed of security and achievement...Schooling is important or vital, but doesnt mean the only way to gain the basic or knowledge is from SCHOOL...Our purpose of education had change...Rather than develop one's potential skill, ppl tend to turn their child into what they wan...Excessively is what a good word to describe our education...drift away from the origin purpose of education
the purpose of education hasn't change, it is the people that changed. All of the complaints that you brought forth are caused by the people rather than the education system.

We need school, it is the place where children are gathered, its the place to learn about socializing, it is organized, it has rules and it has superiors. Without schools how easy would it be to expose a child to a great number of kids of their age? Socializing, organizations, rules and superiors are all parts of life that must be learn. Its not all about the academic per se.

no one is saying that school is the only way to gain knowledge, you're assuming things. Parents, society, library or even the internet are all source of knowledge. But there are many restriction such as time and accessibility which put all these other options aside. If school is abolished to make way for these alternatives, what of those without access to it? You'd screw them up just like that?
skystrike
post Aug 5 2009, 11:16 PM

back to normal
******
Senior Member
1,279 posts

Joined: Jul 2008
From: behind you...


i think malaysia education system is too exam oriented....i suggest that education system in malaysia (specific in school) implemented 50% practical based n 50% exam based...
Orlando
post Aug 5 2009, 11:24 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
88 posts

Joined: Jun 2008


The aim of education should b to teach us rather how to think, thn wat to think, rather to improve our minds,so as to enable us to think for ourselves, thn to load d memory with thoughts of other men -Bill Beatie

Education is therefore a process of living and not a preparation for future living -John Dewey
azarimy
post Aug 5 2009, 11:49 PM

mister architect: the arrogant pr*ck
Group Icon
Elite
10,672 posts

Joined: Jul 2005
From: shah alam - skudai - shah alam


QUOTE(skystrike @ Aug 5 2009, 03:16 PM)
i think malaysia education system is too exam oriented....i suggest that education system in malaysia (specific in school) implemented 50% practical based n 50% exam based...
*
and how do u suppose we gauge the practical based education?
Dark Lord
post Aug 21 2009, 01:59 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
288 posts

Joined: Dec 2005
From: Heaven and Hell


Primary school is to strengthen the basic knowledge of a student.

Secondary school
Form 1 to Form 3 is a stage where you will be knowing which field you are better of, in term of Science Stream and Art Stream.

Form 4 and Form 5, indeed a stage to find out more specific which subject you are GOOD and INTERESTED in, especially Science stream, which have physics, chemistry, biology, etc.

Form 6 is for those who no money + able to handle the subject you gonna take ppl. Others, just go for private.

Uni is all about knowing basic of a specific field and get more knowledge about it BY YOUR SELF. Its all about SELF LEARNING once you gone to Uni level.

This post has been edited by Dark Lord: Aug 21 2009, 02:27 PM
xavi5567
post Aug 21 2009, 03:33 PM

\(●'Å'●)/
*******
Senior Member
3,348 posts

Joined: May 2006
From: The Matrix

experience is good.. but without education, nothing learned.. the problem is malaysia is tat the teacher is not well train.. they r more text based experience.. in europe .. the educationist r usually from the industry.. so the student r teach by pro in each subject..
Dark Lord
post Aug 21 2009, 03:48 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
288 posts

Joined: Dec 2005
From: Heaven and Hell


they teach primary also???
EquinoX
post Aug 21 2009, 05:15 PM

Casual
***
Junior Member
352 posts

Joined: May 2007
I think TS try to say that education meaningless doesnt not mean learn is meaningless. It is two different meaning. But i still disagree with TS, as i think education is also important cause it is basis of knowledge. It jus such as free market, in which is balance condition.
But we know world isnt fair at all way, so sometimes there is still lack of something somewhere.
To say about msian education, I really sad cause they doesnt see the problem, but jus implement and create new rules. Sometimes even the rules they done, not even solve or end it problem. It jus show us that they are working =="
And yes, STPM even harder than Uni.. Don flame me, is my opinion, cause STPM, 1 and half years study, exam will cover full, and there is no tips, cues, clues. Uni or college, every sem, which only around 5 months duration. Every sem not same subject, and we doesnt know .. If the lecturer helping student? Tips? and etc.
wnar
post Aug 28 2009, 11:21 PM

New Member
*
Junior Member
31 posts

Joined: Nov 2008
From: Putrajaya
I really hate PMR and SPM. It's all about marking scheme especially SCIENCE. Why dont they let us think and understand rather than just write things that you actually dont know and like we havet o memorize stuff.
Brenda Smith
post May 28 2010, 12:06 PM

New Member
*
Newbie
1 posts

Joined: May 2010
Exams, memorization -- these are too common for most schools. Schools follow what was written on the book and teachers disseminate this information and check whether students have grasped the lesson. Do these hinder a student from learning the actual lesson? I think not. Exams improve discipline, as well as a student's critical thinking.

This is where internship will take role. For years, a student will experience heavy memorization and studying what seem to be trivial in the "real" world". However, the time will come when a student will be ready to apply what has been taught to him, by means of internship. It's the best way to gauge the student's grasp on the lessons taught to him.

Be it a boarding school or a university, a student should still learn to master what has been taught. Although some lessons and courses might not be useful when he graduates, still it's a practice of being critical and possessing knowledge on other things (History -- who would think this will be useful in the future?)

I agree with what a previous member said that no amount of knowledge is meaningless. It's just a matter of learning and thinking outside the box, right?
entryman
post May 28 2010, 01:39 PM

Look at all my stars!!
*******
Senior Member
2,179 posts

Joined: Sep 2008


I wonder if this thought of mine is even feasible, if in the future I have a child.

Age 1-2. Basic talking, words, alphabets, walking, playing with useful toys such as lego, play dough, all of which spawn self creativity, responsibility etc. taught and supervised by parents. This will develop the bond between parents and child. Mingling with other kids at playgrounds would also expose the kid to society. Baby language such as gugugaga or kuchikuchiku prohibited. Never hit a child. Punishment can be through stern talking, or removal of a favorable thing.

Age 2-3. Exposure to certain young child development classes that are focused on arithmetic, drawing, language, creativity, would help direct a child to his/her future education as well as mingling with society, so it won't become a shock during later ages. Singing and basic drawing can be self administered at home, so further bonding between parent and child can be ensured.

Age 2-3. Child dance classes to allow the child to mix around with other kids. Exposure to electronic baby toys. Continue language development and mingling with society, taught mannerism and responsibility and how to behave well in public through frequent excursions to various public settings, both in the city as well as in nature. Exposure to music, art and the beautiful part of society and let the child be amazed by its wonders.

Age 4-5. Continuation of those in years 3-4, and able to appreciate nature and wildlife and the difference between that and the modern city, able to assimilate easily and comfortably in both settings. Start more advanced stage of language, mannerism and responsibility. Can have child development professionals visit the house once in a while to get the child more exposed to the notion of teachers. Let a child start voicing out ideas, make decisions, be independent in getting and preparing food, going outdoors, opening doors, switching on lights and taps. Instill the sense of responsibility through reminding them and testing if they have turned off what they have turned on, and checking on these constantly and showing that it is important. Also, taking care of a small and manageable pet would be a great way too. Exposure to high tech gadgets such as mobile phones, plasma TVs, computers, the insides and organs of a car, etc. however prevent over-enthusiasm and addiction by dilution with many other new things in life.

5-6. Continuation with more advanced level of language, arithmetic, and computer literacy. Encourage a child to speak out, and correct any errors made by repeating to the child patiently. Exposure to more advanced cars or buggies for kids would be great too. Allow child to choose which form of art he/her is interested in, as mentioned above e.g. piano, singing, dancing, etc. or maybe even hint at the arithmetics if a child is very fast in it.

6-7. Get the child to try online guides and educational tools that are for 2 years his senior. If a child doesn't know something, always encourage learning by teaching him and explaining. Always encourage questions, and deeper thinking and appreciation.

7-12. Start to instill a sense of responsibility in the child for his/her education. Level by level mastery of arithmetic and language suitable for his/her age through internet education. Can opt for tutors for specific subjects. Continue exposure to the public and outdoors to maintain levels of socializing and public exposure. Public exposure is always ensured through social parties, dance classes, birthday parties, kids outdoor camp etc. Allow kid to make decisions during shopping for groceries, driving directions, dining places, purchasing from different companies, patient explanation of why something is good or bad, and curb the temptation for indulgence, but instill the sense of working hard towards achieve something, while enjoying the process at the same time. Overseas trips to expose child to new surroundings.

13-16. Overseas trips to both modernized areas as well as rural areas. Modernized can be places such as KL city, Dubai, NYC, London, Shanghai, and rural can be Nepal, Tibet, Indonesia, etc. Mountain climbing, go karting etc. Exposure to corporate arena through corporate sponsored events or site visits to workplace, as well as business meetings. Allow kid to enter temporary workforce if interested, as well as e-commerce. Continuation in achieving and loving high standards in both general knowledge as well as money & banking & economics, and the awe of sciences. This is also the period where the child can be trained professionally towards a professional field.

17 - Ready for Harvard. LoL.

Notice I haven't included sportsmanship interests, public speaking, leadership experience, and religion in the above. They're all equally important. Notice that SMK, SJK, schools etc etc weren't included, thus the questioning of feasibility. Of course, the child should be also be prepared for the minimum requirements of O-Levels and A-Levels.

This post has been edited by entryman: May 28 2010, 01:47 PM

 

Change to:
| Lo-Fi Version
0.0181sec    0.44    5 queries    GZIP Disabled
Time is now: 25th November 2025 - 04:39 AM