QUOTE(alanmukkl @ Jul 26 2009, 01:26 AM)
lease feel FREE TO GIVE ME FEEDBACK regarding todays Mines Wonderland Sony SF4 Mini Tournament ...
Need to provide feedback to official SONY SIDE.
Please be honest ok? Cause I needed these comments to make our gaming industry on Tournament side much more better....
Thanks
Hi Alan, here are some of the feedback that are in the other SF4 thread, i am pasting them here so that you can see them.
QUOTE(MasterAlvin @ Jul 25 2009, 08:25 PM)
honestly speaking, many of us are thankful for these kind of tournaments, but personally i did feel that the organizers today did not have a full idea of what they were doing. interrupting players IN THE MIDDLE of their matches, banning sticks, and 2 round games all the way up to semi finals, 60 second rounds, and infinite round time for semifinal onwards...
i hope they get someone who actually knows the game to draft up the rules, the next time they attempt these things.
it could have been so much better.
and honestly, i think it's reasonable whoever wants to use pads can use pads, but banning sticks is... i mean yeah, if you think it's unfair that we have sticks, pls feel free to borrow one of our dear sticks, we'd love to share it. we feel unfair too when we are forced to use pads.
and thanks for rawfish to bring it up, i think the organiser deserves some credit in the clear scoring system, and a good job in separating the crowd and the contestants. good TV set ups. but honestly, i will enjoy the sound of the game more rather than some loud music that's irrelevant to the game.
i like the tags

QUOTE(leongteng5 @ Jul 26 2009, 12:51 AM)
About the tourney: I had a blast. But I cant help but think if the tourney actually allowed sticks, I wouldn't have this much of a chance of winning. Bravo to the usual stick players (Desmond, Alvin, BigMac, Alan and the rest) to show up on pad matches, something I didn't do when the situation reversed on megamall. I'm glad I won anyway, I don't win much competitions so this is pretty much made my day. Desmond we'll have our real rematch on the next good tourney!
QUOTE(rawfish @ Jul 26 2009, 05:52 AM)
Ok, the GOOD feedback on The Mines' tournament:• Very well-organized event
• Rope cordon were used to separate the crowd from the contestants' area
• Played on 40" Bravia Vs. No eye-strain nor lag noticed
• Scoring system clear, and the notebook was even routed to a Bravia for all to see
• Attentive staff
• Interesting MC
• The customary cosplay Ryu and Chun Li. I like their presence and shouts out loudly this is an SF-event
• It's free
• Door gift (t-shirts and towels) given to participants
• Proper SF4 tags were printed and distributed (hung around the neck)
• Decent prizes to go around for the top 8 winners
Now for what I feel needs to be highlighted:• Very badly-organized Street Fighter event. Many opportunities to make this better.
• Event held in a (IMHO) tight and confined space. Aside from participants, they should know that fighting games make good crowd attraction, especially on a busy weekend. They should capitalize on this and use the mall's concourse area to stage the event to draw a better crowd and sell their brand better (though there may be budgeting or setup challenges for this).
• No choice to bring your own stick. This severely brings great handicap to players (example, a likely-to-be EX-Sony supporter like myself). Bringing a stick does not guarantee the user the championship. It's skill. This is what a tournament is about, an open challenge of skill. Best man (or woman) wins. Since this is an open invitation (public), you leave the options open as well. Do not limit or restrict the capacity for a player to play his/her best. If bringing sticks shy the public away, may I then ask you to look at today's results. People will definitely sign-up no matter what they see being used to play, to at least gauge how well they fare and try their luck at the prize. People will also leave, due to the need to be somewhere else, or getting beaten by the better pad player. Or as some people I met quoted, "good game, bro. takde joystick tak best la *balik*".
• No choice to bring your own pad. This is acceptable, if only the pads were in good condition. Sadly they were not. Mike, a good Abel player is someone who seldom complains on hardware fault. He lost unconvincingly and shared that the pad had a worn-out d-pad. By that time it was too late to inform the organizers as it was already at the knock-out stage and we had little evidence to prove.
• No choice to customize the settings on the pad. So I decided to join the pad tournament, which makes myself seem like joining the Special Olympics (no disrespect to pad players, you know your game and are better with it, it's just like I am useless on it). I tried hard to make the temp transition, and it seemed ok as long the PPP/KKK buttons are mapped from the right shoulder buttons to the right ones). To my horror (the rules were not posted online, and only announced/published at the venue), even button customization is strictly banned too. I can understand the banning of mapping Focus Attacks or Throws together, but this....???
• No choice to use certain characters. No, we're not talking about Seth (in fact, Seth has weak attacks and defence - no more reason to ban him). There's 3 PS3 setups.
Setup #1: Fei Long, Akuma, Gouken, Seth, Rose, Dan and Gen are not unlocked
Setup #2: Everyone unlocked
Setup #3: No one unlocked. Default arcade characters.
So anyone who uses these characters need to pray hard that they are assigned to the correct machines.
• 2-round games, even in the semi-finals. Only finals and 3rd-placing decider went to best-of-5-rounds
• 60 second games. This was too fast and encouraged plenty of people just hitting hard then jumping back to wait for time-out. But anything you say, dear organizers.
• I have no qualms about the score keeper. He initially interrupted people in the midst of battle to ask for their tag number and current score, but after feedback he was more thoughtful and sensitive. Thank you for this.
True, it is your event and you have ultimatum over the rules. The keyword here is "choice". I have a choice to enter this tournament or simply stay at home and stay contended. You need to do your homework before organizing an event like this, or you will definitely make yourselves look bad. This message may not mean anything to you as it's just from some guy in cyber-space. But I hope this is reflected upon and well-taken as a very honest, no-frills one - as I know, you're looking towards setting up an online community as evident with PlayStation Friends @ Facebook. So you need to start to listen to people within this channel.
Thank you for the event, overall I enjoyed myself as I had a good company of friends but am questioning the effectiveness of your corporate office's leadership team, over yesterday's event.
QUOTE(Quistreous @ Jul 25 2009, 09:13 PM)
I would like to note that the tournament setting for both the Penang and KL market is totally different! I find that the KL people are slightly more efficient than in Penang. Even though there are still some places which still needs improvement, overall it was an enjoyable event!
I totally agree with you about that stupid organizer who walks around and interrupts players all the time! I mean, I totally lost concentration and my "steadiness" everytime I got interrupted! People playing halfway and he goes like, "Ei, you no 013 ah? You win or lose ah? So now you win lar?" I was literary glaring at him and the crowd was cursing him for interrupting the matches. He deserved it, in my opinion!

The rules are quite fair but like you said, I think its also fair that we are allowed to bring our own controllers or arcade stick. I mean, its just a controller/ arcade stick! Its not like you can input some special button where you press to "focus punch" immediately. I hope that future tournaments would take this into consideration as I believe its important to allow players to feel comfortable in their own environment. Personally, I found that some controllers were rather "faulty" in the sense that the button sensitivity was off. My friends and several other contestants complained about this as well. I would also like to comment on the time limit. I think that all tournaments should follow the standard time of 99 seconds instead of 60. It was pretty shocking for us when sometimes, we just realized that its 60 seconds instead of 99. Haha!
All in all, I really enjoy gatherings like these! I will input my feedback to the Penang organizers so they would do a better job in organizing the other tournaments to come!
This post has been edited by MasterAlvin: Jul 26 2009, 09:30 AM