lol sarcast you want my comment on it?

first of all i understand they aren't professional actors, and the probably don't have to be if they knew how to play an instrument!!! @_@
i think the only person who actually looked right was the vocalist lol

the intro guitarist was picking nonsense(picking bass strings at treble notes)
the drummer was too stiff i think he was afraid to hit the drums...(VERY obvious)
the gurl guitarist was playing nonsense, she was even moving her fingers at bending parts... and moving at lower register(first few frets) at the higher solo parts..
i think the bassist was kind of faking as well, but he probably faked better than the rest
Thats about all the technical errors.
On to the video recording part
i think the lighting isn't very balanced at some scenes, noticed there are some over exposures. (unless it was done on purpose)
the camera isn't very still at some scenes too, shaking too much especially got one part it was trying to shoot up the tree (2.02-2.08)

and thats about it la...
Overall i think you guys did a fantastic job editing the video. I liked the transitions, was done very smoothly from one scene to another. and the environment was picked rather nicely.
But i have to say, although I don't expect professional quality MV, this probably doesn't even pass as an average video, imo feels like just something another amateur cooked up for youtube. Also, it shouldn't be called a remake. Remakes are usually officially done. This, being unofficial should be called a parody or fan-made.

I'm very sorry i am so harsh on you guys, i know i'm not your lecturer or anything but as a musician(and this IS a musicians forum) i just cannot ignore all the technical parts of playing an instrument. You, as a musician should also understand that.
Perhaps if you posted this elsewhere(in kopitiam or something) non-musicians wouldn't realise all these mistakes and will tell you, great job.
Hope you don't feel offended >.<
if you do, just pm me and i will gladly edit this post. ^^

I agree on this..
the intro guitarist was picking nonsense(picking bass strings at treble notes)
the drummer was too stiff i think he was afraid to hit the drums...(VERY obvious)
the gurl guitarist was playing nonsense, she was even moving her fingers at bending parts... and moving at lower register(first few frets) at the higher solo parts..
i think the bassist was kind of faking as well, but he probably faked better than the rest
Thats about all the technical errors.

oo, u are ryozenki friend? 
he showed me video that day,

Jrocker, or call it Visual kei band

XP at singapore there are a band who "Cosplay" + jrock fashion during their performance, their band name is "Night cat" if not wrong.
nice fashion, they sing jp song, english and mandarin etc
Here i share a video of a band performance at Malaysia XP, sorry the record not nice
those who like naruto might like this song..haha
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rErxsdqXFuw

yeah i noticed to cool wall lol at first thought it was A'famosa in melaka hahaha
is it your friend's house? o.O