QUOTE(aiman04 @ Jun 8 2012, 10:37 AM)
I like this film, but only because I'm a big sci-fi fan. But as a movie it was like being made by a film student who scored A in cinematography/design/visuals/spectacle but got an F on the screenwriting subject. Music ineffective and sometimes misplaced. Even editing was all sloppy, inconsistent pacing. It could've been a classic. But it's not. Big ideas, big theme, big questions, but written very badly and with such laziness.. Plot holes, illogical character behaviors, convenient expositions, too plenty to list down. The problem has nothing to do with the movie's link to the original
Alien. They failed the most basic rule of good film making - BAD, LAZY WRITING.
My rating:
As Sci-fi Geek: 8/10
As Movie Critic: 5/10
Prometheus' cinema release has more potholes than the Malaysian road. That's why my hunch is that Ridley Scott's gonna provide those missing links with an hour-long of extra footage in the bluray release.

The characters aren't exactly a letdown, 'cept for a few ones that I wished were given more scene time to portray a solid expedition team. From the looks of the progress, its as if all they needed was the Android. A botanist......a geologist?? They're just another meat to the story. Hell, I wouldn't care if they brought in a marine biologist or a space rocket scientist.
» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «
Charlize Theron as Meredith Vickers is a tad dissapointing. I can't tell if she's an antagonist in the film. Idris Elba as Janek the captain had one line that aptly capture her characteristics in the movie.
Janek: Hey Vickers, Vickers.
Vickers:
turns around...Janek: I was wondering.....Are you a robot?
I love Charlize Theron. She just looks so cute in her scene, but the character just doesn't fit her that well. Being the corporate daughter of Peter Wayland, she had like a love-hate relationship with her father, but at the same time, she is this hard-stance, b*tch-cold boss in the Prometheus. In the end, she lost all that when Weyland emerges into the scene. Now she is this lonely, unwanted daughter who lost the respect of anyone and even lost control of the ship, and finally ends up a pancake on a distant moon pinned down under an alien spaceship for millenia. How depressing is that?