QUOTE(zhiyung @ Oct 15 2008, 03:29 AM)
To my experience, vertical = cooler, so since RROD is kind of heat-related, i think it does contribute a little. But anyhow, it all comes to luck, your machine can go 90c for 2 years without any problem, but it may also go dead even if running 40c for 2 days...
Just buy and enjoy, claim warranty when RROD... no point worrying this and that and ends up not able to enjoy this beauty.
to me, horizontal makes more sense, cos you're not blocking the intake vent at the bottom (right side, if you're facing the box). hot air rises, so when it's vertical, any heat not immediately evacuated by the fans/fan shroud heads up to the hdd area. it will eventually dissipate, but having one of the chips below the other chip may not appear to be the best idea.
also, have seen pics of vertically placed boards with the heatsinks removed, and with the thermal paste having slowly migrated downwards due to gravity.
either way, it's a fundamentally flawed design, so it's really a roll of the dice until MS brings out their more heat efficient designs.