Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )

Bump Topic Topic Closed RSS Feed

Outline · [ Standard ] · Linear+

Household [Home Appliances] Water Filter, for drinking water purpose

views
     
dreyvii
post Apr 1 2014, 12:16 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
79 posts

Joined: Jun 2008
Any reviews on GE filters for drinking water?

Also, my contractor recommended to just use a normal filter for the mains (before the tank) to filter out particles, then just change the filter cartridge every few months when it's dirty. Is that a good idea?

I'm not keen on the filter where u need to do backwash. Feels like a waste of water to me. Please advice, sifus
dreyvii
post Apr 2 2014, 09:27 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
79 posts

Joined: Jun 2008
QUOTE(wattsivy @ Apr 1 2014, 12:45 PM)
Just get d indoor water treatment sys ll do,if you ar budget tight. Coz indoor drinking water much more important than outdoor
*
I think generally still need an outdoor filter. I don't want to shower/cook with dirty water

QUOTE(supersound @ Apr 1 2014, 01:06 PM)
Outdoor unit sure need to back flsuh, if you don't install that, your indoor unit how expensive also useless.
Indoor unit you can use carbon filter(rm150 Panasonic), but suggest to use better type filter as this carbon filter won't really remove all the "dirt". Your water supply matters on filter selections.
*
Back flush is to clear up the sand and particles? Won't the normal cheapo filters do the same thing? If I change the cartridge every few months, it still won't cost as much as the sand filters, right? And no wasting water, although some may say recycle the water to wash car porch or gardening, etc

QUOTE(NightFelix @ Apr 1 2014, 01:12 PM)
Outdoor either go for user-replaceable like 3M or backwash flush sand filter like Pentair/any identical.
Any type of filter always come with Pros and Cons. So don't expect a perfect unbeatable system.
*
Well said. But was just wondering if it is a good choice to go for a simple filter vs something more expensive

QUOTE(platinum_12 @ Apr 1 2014, 02:09 PM)
Im not a sifus.. i used that kind of set up. Just a normal filter at the main and an activated carbon filter at the undersink. Catridge at the main i change it once in two months, which cost me only rm15 for 1micron filter. Used to used 5micron which cost me rm7 n change it every 4 months. Activated carbon i yet to change it. One catridge cost me around rm15. So far so good. No rust detected at the cattle or any of the piping fittings.
*
Good to know that! Does the outdoor filter get very dirty when u change it? How does the water taste? Any rusty taste or funny smells?

I'm a bit particular about my drinking water. I actually like the taste of RO water, but it's not healthy, so will not use that. The Panasonic filters mentioned also taste fine. But surprisingly, despite the price and reviews, I don't like the e-spring water taste. It's a good filter, no doubt. But I actually don't like the taste of the minerals. It doesn't taste crystal clear and sweet. That's why was wondering if anyone has a good drinking filter to recommend. I saw the GE filter and quite like the looks. Never tasted the water though, that's why want to ask if anyone heard or used it before.
dreyvii
post Apr 2 2014, 10:53 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
79 posts

Joined: Jun 2008
QUOTE(supersound @ Apr 2 2014, 10:07 AM)
The outdoor unit won't be that expensive, about rm500-800 also you can get, provided you know the place. In shopping centers sure are more expensive, as they charge 2-5X extra.
As for back flush, you only need to back flush it for 5-10 minutes, so use it for gardening or car washing.
The cartridge for indoor unit I only change once a year, rm40, so in some sense, I save more than you.
*
Will it be more difficult to install the outdoor unit later? Budget constraints right now. Let me just test out the simple filter first, then choose to upgrade later if it's not too much if a hassle

QUOTE(NightFelix @ Apr 2 2014, 10:09 AM)
Whoever asked me, I will recommend outdoor for 3M AP902 and indoor for Amway eSpring, if budget running tight, go for 3M DWS1000. Both having the certified of NSF 42 and 53, while eSpring have bonus UV tech NSF 55.

There are always pros and cons between you choose either membrane filter, sand filter. While 3M AP902 is something like in between both. User replaceable cartridge when reach 378,541liters. While Amway eSpring will be same as well when reach 5,000liters. I can't said is expensive or cheap but is affordable in the long run.

Sand filters got many brand or types, some need to do backwash like every weeks or months for what I have encounter/feedback from friends or families. Don't forget, both sand filter need to change after couple of years and membrane filter need to change as well.

RO water sure taste good because I have one Coway Petit in my office, but in long term usage like at home, I would recommend others instead of picking RO system. While like you said, you don't like the taste of eSpring, it might be possible to early new cartidge just replace into the eSpring, the water came out something strange if you drink for the first time, but after you filter like more than 500-1,000liters later, you won't taste that anymore. I using it too, that is why I know what you talking about.

I have no idea about GE Water brands. Maybe you could share your thought about it, which model and what its feature or what it capable of doing it?
*
Oh, really? The funny taste of e-spring is due to the new filter? Oic. But I thought the E-spring is quite high maintenance too? Cos it is set to beep every year or every so many litres, whichever comes first, to signal it's time to change the cartridge/UV device, no? And the sound is really annoying too. One more drawback is, it needs to be plugged into a power socket. Can it be connected under the sink to save counter space? How do we connect it to the sink outlet then?

QUOTE(clio571 @ Apr 2 2014, 11:24 AM)
Anyone use 3M AP Easy Complete water filter? is it good?
*
Would like to hear more about 3M filters too...thx

QUOTE(wattsivy @ Apr 2 2014, 12:03 PM)
Talking abt espring i actually feel it fresh. But for taste is quite subjective. U can let a kids try. Usually they can recognize which water is nice to drink. As i get many feedback abt espring taste sweet...kids like to drink water.
I m d one same as you particular wif water. Plus i m a chemist tat y i choose espring. Regarding of one of the model of panasonic is made by alkaline water. Tat y i would not consider it in my list
*
I'm nit sure if it's because my parents boiled the water first, that's why it tastes funny. But then again, it tasted funny even when I drank directly from the tap. Really, kids can tell the difference? Haha...I thought kids just drink coke. tongue.gif yeah, basically is just need a good filter that gives me water that tastes nice and safe to drink...

Topic ClosedOptions
 

Change to:
| Lo-Fi Version
0.0585sec    0.44    7 queries    GZIP Disabled
Time is now: 11th December 2025 - 11:22 PM