i'm want to upgrade my pc speaker...as title above which one better to buy and value to me?

Creative MegaWorks THX 5.1 550 - rm550

Specifications

Power Rating: 500 Watts RMS
500 Watts System Power

Satellite Speakers: (Rated @ 10% THD @ 1kHz) 70 Watts RMS per speaker (x 4 speakers)


Center Speaker: (Rated @ 10% THD @ 1kHz) 70 Watts RMS


Subwoofer: (Rated @ 10% THD @ 1kHz) 150 Watts RMS


Signal-to-Noise-Ratio 99 dB


Overall Frequency Response: 25 Hz to 20kHz



Cables
Front Left, Right & Center Satellites: 3m / 9ft (RCA Gold plug) (Open ended bare wire)
Rear Left & Right Satellite: 5m / 16ft (RCA Gold plug) (Open ended bare wire)
Triple Line-In Audio Cable: 2m / 6.5ft (Gold - plated)
Volume Control: 2m / 6.5ft (Color - Black)

Sockets (refer to the Back Panel of the Subwoofer)
Audio Inputs: 3.5mm stereo mini jack
Front: Lime Pantone 577C
Back: Black
Center / Subwoofer: Orange Pantone 157C
Auxilary: White
Speaker Outputs - F/L & R/L: White RCA Socket
- F/R & R/R: Red RCA Socket
- F CENTER: Black RCA Socket

Volume Control: DIN
@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@


Creative GigaWorks G500 - rm550

Specifications

Speaker power: 310 watts total RMS power

* Front : 36 watts RMS per speaker
(Measured @ 8 ohms @ 10% THD @ 180Hz to 20kHz, two channels driven)
* Rear : 36 watts RMS per speaker
(Measured @ 8 ohms @ 10% THD @ 180Hz to 20kHz, two channels driven)
* Center : 36 watts RMS
(Measured @ 8 ohms @ 10% THD @ 180Hz to 20kHz, one channel driven)
* Subwoofer : 130 watts RMS
(Measured @ 6 ohms @ 10% THD @ 35Hz to 180Hz, one channel driven)
620 watts total Peak Power

Frequency Response: 35Hz to 20kHz
Signal-to-Noise Ratio (SNR): 85dB


somebody can tell me ur experience if u have used before...and make me decision which one better

---

Added on April 19, 2008, 1:52 pmno somebody give me any idea Or opinion?

to user this 2 item..please help me..now i consider to get Logitech Z680

This post has been edited by nidzamputra: Apr 19 2008, 10:48 PM

for treable tis set should b not bad oo
but den those THX certified is juz a usual thing dun put so much hope on it hehe~ even logitect z5500 THX for it also juz usual not like those real home theater try to think tat usual home theater set for THX certified at least cost u 10k for the speaker oni
but den those multimedia speaker juz cost u few hundred or 1k something like tat. so dun put so much hope on it

update...

now i got offer Logitech Z680 from forumer...i my opinion i want to get this logitech speaker...

what i do research & google...i see Z680 subwoofer rated 188watt RMS compare Creative MegaWorks THX 5.1 550 rated 150watt RMS.....


i think to get this logitech...is it value for my money?

Wattage is not everything man...logitech subwoofer too high wattage actually drown out the other speaker sound..if u listen a lot music with strong bass or u like bass more then any other thing, then logitech is the speaker for u man...

This post has been edited by stardust_kkk: Apr 20 2008, 12:55 PM

that i like it..listen music with a strong bass..this is my target

gigaworks sub r prone 2 overheat..prepare 2 find a good cooling solution if u r getting it

This post has been edited by jasonlim: Apr 20 2008, 06:51 PM

Any Mega work 550THX user over there? any well known problme with this model?

Don't buy a model which is already obsolete 3-4 years ago as there will not be any spare parts available like what we experience with Creative's s750, from Creative Labs Megaworks 550 or Logitech z680. Both these series already have newer series replacing it and definitely you will be asking for trouble if there is problem when the warranty is over.

My advice is to get the newer series with caution; go to their forum to see what other user says about the speakers and overheating sub+amp is one of them. Price may be attractive but eventually you will end up with a lemon and you cursing and swearing. These are like all computer hardware if its an old series you will know that it will not be entertain by the retailer and distributor when there are problems. YOU ARE ON YOUR OWN, BRO. Don't buy it because of price , there are always a reason why it so cheap currently,believe me.

how about quality Logitech G51?this is new product from logitech..the price also nice for me

---

Added on April 21, 2008, 12:27 amyeah guys...come share here...


This post has been edited by nidzamputra: Apr 21 2008, 12:27 AM

Check out the review G51 review

i'm Megaworks 550 THX user, I'd been using AL 885 previously before this megaworks.
So far sound quality definately mega best the AL885 flat, althought sattelite doesnt come with tweeter. For Altec is good in bass, you can hear the bass got tune one when set to Prologic mode, unlike logitech the bass just got boom boom sound.
For Music Lover, Mega is ur choice, high wattage doesnt mean anything. When lowest volume, I still can ejoy my music as the sattelite produce the sound clearly, but AL in low vol i cant barely hear anything cause the bass will cover everything.

hi where and how much u got it?

hi man u sure Creative MegaWorks THX 5.1 550 - rm550 ? <G500 i know Rm550 >

This post has been edited by ask8900: Jun 5 2008, 01:00 AM

I bought for ~Rm600 from UK back then.

IIRC, that's the price from imculguy

not being bias or what, but creative was never good at speakers.

the megawork 550 is ok, but the woofer bottoms out when the volume goes beyond midpoint.

for logitech, their system are either just loud, or too bass heavy.
there are alot of ppl who say that the Z5500 is good, but i think not.
its satellite speaker are very good in its class, but the letdown is that the woofer is only strong when pushed beyond a certain volume. below that, the system is just loud and boring, lacking low end support.

just my two cents ppl. =)

this is cheap for a brand new set!! msia veli veli exp..

i own z680, although it's a old model but it does play pretty good. Frankly i would say speaker is something will last for long time and if you really want to invest, invest in the one that really got some quality.

noted, creative speakers tend to blow amp but for clarity, i think they are the best. logitech heavy bass, personal preference by lower down the bass from the control unit and tweak from your player's EQ (if you are using pc), the sound will turn out pretty sweet. Aego M got good reviews but sadly only 2.1 and it cost a lot.

I'm getting the Megaworks 550 in about 2 weeks time to pair up with my creative x-fi fatality...

finally i just bought 2nd hand Logitech Z680 speaker & OEM x-fi Fatality ....but not try it yet..need to sleep la...