So people in T6 gear are laughing at people with pre kara gear and wipe at Maiden? No one ever remembered downing Maiden is a great achievement anymore?

Now noob grp can down Maiden I agree, but without UBER pvp gear (t6 quality with less damage/heal but more stam) do you think a 6k health meleer (without t4 or pvp gear) is a good choice to attempt Maiden?